Finding the best BBQ in Tappan, NY feels a bit like searching for hidden treasure—except the payoff here comes with sticky fingers and that unmistakable smoky perfume on your clothes. I’ve had afternoons when the grill smoke rose like good news, the tang of sauce hinted at something special, and each bite turned into more of a memory than a meal. If you’ve ever followed the aroma of burning hickory across a parking lot, you know the joy I’m talking about.
This list isn’t just another roundup; it’s built from real ventures through Tappan’s BBQ spots and their surrounding neighborhoods, where the love for slow-cooked meats ushers in a quirky cast of pitmasters and loyal locals. Whether your taste leans toward sweet, tangy, or a secret dry rub, the variety around here is worth exploring. You’ll soon see there’s a barbecue experience with your name on it, and maybe a story or two waiting to happen along the way.
Where to find the best bbq in Tappan, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Tappan, NY:
- No-Co Kithen
- The Blind Boar BBQ
- County Wood Stoves
- The Brew House
- Funky Monkey
- Revenge Bbq
- Ancora Barbeque
- Bailey’s Smokehouse
- Broadway Grill
- The Barbecue Pit
1. No-Co Kithen
No-Co Kithen, tucked away at 67 Old Tappan Road, does BBQ with an inventive twist. Every visit feels like a pleasant surprise. I once stumbled in on a slow afternoon, only to leave convinced it’s the sort of place you make excuses to return to.
What sets No-Co Kithen apart is how they balance bold flavors with honest, simple cooking. The smoke lingers in every bite, and the portions show they’re not shy about sharing the good stuff.
It’s tough to pass up their smoked chicken platter. The meat falls off the bone, and the house-made BBQ sauce runs the sweet-salty line just right. Their ribs, too, stand out for their deep char and tenderness—real proof that care goes into every plate.
2. The Blind Boar BBQ
(201) 784-6900Call
The Blind Boar BBQ isn’t just another roadside smokehouse—it’s where you learn that straightforward barbecue can be great without being overdone. Just over the border from Tappan, this local staple draws families, friends, and folks who know their brisket from their burnt ends.
On my first visit, I noticed the atmosphere felt relaxed and unpretentious. The friendly staff serves up food that speaks for itself. The Blind Boar favors low prices and honest cooking over bells and whistles, which keeps regulars coming back.
If you’re here, the smoked brisket sandwich is worth a try. It arrives tender with just the right smoke ring, paired with classic sides like slaw and cornbread. Their pulled chicken is another standout: juicy, seasoned well, and perfect for anyone craving real, no-nonsense BBQ.
3. County Wood Stoves
County Wood Stoves is not your typical BBQ joint—it’s where backyard dreams get their upgrade. Walk into their Sparkill shop, and you’ll find the kind of gear that makes neighborhood BBQs legendary. Years ago, I stumbled onto their showroom while looking for a firepit and left with a custom outdoor kitchen idea that still gets compliments.
What separates County Wood Stoves is the deep expertise and the personal attention every customer gets. This family-run place doesn’t just sell grills; they help you create an at-home BBQ setup that’ll have smoke drifting down your block for all the right reasons.
Budding pitmasters should check out their outdoor kitchen setups and BBQ grills. Their quality selection includes trusted brands, and every option is built with flavor and function in mind. For anyone serious about barbecue in Tappan, NY, this is where your best meals begin.
4. The Brew House
(845) 735-3970Call
The Brew House sits right in the heart of Pearl River, drawing steady crowds with its blend of laid-back energy and slow-cooked meats. I landed here after a long workweek, craving nothing too fancy—just honest BBQ and a good seat. What I got was better: real smoke, great portions, and enough warmth to turn a stranger into a regular.
There’s a confidence in the menu that matches the vibe. The Brew House doesn’t overcomplicate things, focusing on solid flavors and quality cuts. Every plate comes out looking like someone’s already bragged about it.
Don’t skip the BBQ chicken. Smoky, juicy, and done right, it doesn’t need much dressing up. Pair it with their beef brisket—it’s tender and full of flavor. Together, they show why this spot holds its own among Tappan’s best.
5. Funky Monkey
(201) 660-7097Call
Funky Monkey comes with a punchy name and a quirky style that’s hard to forget. Nestled on Walker Ave in Closter, it’s a quick trip from Tappan for those seeking BBQ that breaks from tradition. On my last visit, a quick bite turned into a lingered meal—the food has a way of slowing you down and sparking conversation.
What makes Funky Monkey memorable isn’t just the flavor, but the playful spirit in every dish. The menu bursts with variety, showing off a kitchen that knows how to balance smoke and surprise.
The go-to here is the hickory smoked chicken. Lightly charred, packed with flavor, and served in generous portions, it proves that BBQ can be both fun and seriously delicious. If you’re in the mood for something different, you’ll leave pleased.
6. Revenge Bbq
(914) 674-4848Call
Revenge BBQ in Irvington brings a bold energy that makes you sit up straight, even before you reach the end of Main Street. On my first visit, the smell of hardwood smoke trailed into the sidewalk, practically daring you to step inside. It’s easy to appreciate the casual, no-fuss setting, but the flavors are what win repeat business.
Revenge BBQ stands out for its commitment to real wood smoking and unfussy portions. The folks behind the counter are quick to share which meats just came off the pit, inviting you to try what’s at its peak.
Order the smoked turkey—it comes juicy, with a subtle heat from the rub and an irresistible outer crust. Pair it with their pit beans for that classic BBQ comfort. Every bite here feels both familiar and fresh, much like the place itself.
7. Ancora Barbeque
(914) 963-1682Call
Ancora Barbeque, found on Broadway in Yonkers, is the spot where barbecue meets a dash of Old World charm. My first meal there felt more like dropping in on a family gathering than eating out. The atmosphere is easy and warm, with staff eager to share what’s fresh from the pit.
Ancora Barbeque separates itself with its home-cooked approach—flavors are deep, meats are tender, and there’s obvious care in every detail. You’ll catch hints of Mediterranean and classic American styles blending on each plate.
The char-grilled chicken is a staple and it’s clear why. Each piece packs a smoky punch while staying juicy, and the light touch of herbs shows real finesse. Order with their fresh sides, and you’re set for a meal that speaks for itself.
8. Bailey’s Smokehouse
Bailey’s Smokehouse in Blauvelt is the type of place you end up visiting more than once, even if you didn’t plan to. My first lunch here turned into a lazy weekend escape, with the aroma of hardwood smoke lingering longer than most good conversations. It’s the kind of BBQ that feels crafted, not just cooked.
Bailey’s Smokehouse is committed to slow-smoking, with every cut marinated overnight before a 12-hour smoke. That signature smoke ring is their badge of honor—proof that each bite means business. The vibe is unpretentious, with big booths and a crowd that looks like they all know each other.
Their brisket platter should top your list. Tender, well-seasoned, and rich with smoke, it’s everything you want BBQ to be. The house-made BBQ chicken is another must—juicy and flavorful, especially with a dollop of their sweet and tangy sauce.
9. Broadway Grill
Broadway Grill, right off Irvington’s main drag, is the kind of spot you wander into for a quick bite and end up lingering over. I stopped in once on a slow evening, and the conversation around the bar was as good as the food coming out of the kitchen.
What puts Broadway Grill on the map is its welcoming vibe and its knack for making BBQ accessible but never basic. The staff always seems to know what’s freshest, adding a personal touch to each order.
The star here is the slow-cooked BBQ chicken. It’s tender with crisped edges and a glaze that clings in all the right ways. Pair it with one of their rotating sides for a meal that feels special, even on a casual night out.
10. The Barbecue Pit
The Barbecue Pit in the Bronx flips the script on typical BBQ with a menu mixing Indian flavors, vegetarian choices, and classic smoked meats under one roof. My first outing here turned into a flavor adventure, with every dish hinting at something unexpected and vibrant.
What sets The Barbecue Pit apart is its inclusivity—there’s a dish for every taste, whether you lean traditional or prefer something plant-based. Staff never seem stumped by custom requests, and the food consistently hits homey and hearty notes.
The BBQ chicken is a top pick—smoked until just charred, juicy, and layered with a spiced sauce that’s anything but bland. Pair it with the tofu biryani for a blend of comfort and spice you won’t find elsewhere near Tappan.
More Things to Try in Tappan, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best BBQ in Tappan, NY?
Some top spots around Tappan include No-Co Kithen, Bailey’s Smokehouse, and The Brew House. Each has its own approach, from classic smoked chicken to creative platters.
Are there halal BBQ options in or near Tappan, NY?
While many BBQ restaurants focus on traditional offerings, some places prepare halal-friendly dishes. It’s always best to call ahead and check with each restaurant about their ingredients and preparation practices.
What BBQ dishes are most popular in Tappan?
Smokehouse brisket, BBQ chicken, ribs, and pulled chicken steal the spotlight at most local spots. Many places serve them with signature sauces and classic sides like slaw or cornbread.
Can I get BBQ takeout or delivery in Tappan, NY?
Yes, most BBQ restaurants in and around Tappan offer takeout, and several will deliver. Websites or a quick phone call can confirm the menu and service options.
Are there vegetarian or healthy BBQ options?
Some BBQ restaurants, like The Barbecue Pit, offer vegetarian and even vegan dishes. You’ll find items like smoked tofu, grilled veggies, and creative salads.