There’s something about discovering the best barbecue that feels like a mini adventure. Whether it’s the rich tang of smoky sauces or the quiet buzz of a summer evening around a grill, great BBQ in South Hill, NY hits all the right spots. I still remember the day I first chased down that distinct aroma on a side street in South Hill. The air practically promised brisket so tender it fell apart with a look, and each pit seemed to have a story as juicy as its ribs.
If you’re on the hunt for spots that live up to the hype, you’re in the right place. This guide is grounded in first-hand bites, local favorites, and an honest take on what makes each place different. You’ll find classic pits, a few surprise standouts, and all the smokehouse stops that real BBQ enthusiasts rave about. If a BBQ crawl is your idea of the perfect afternoon, this list will help you plan where to start—and where you might want to linger for seconds.
Where to find the best bbq in South Hill, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in South Hill, NY:
- Rotisserie Smokehouse
- Smoke BBQ Pit Inc
- Avenue BBQ Hut
- Max Bar
- The Best Seafood & BBQ Chicken Corp
- O’Hanlon Bar & Grill
- A J’s Snack Bar
- Vino Volo
- All Nations Bar
- J & D Bar-B-Q
1. Rotisserie Smokehouse
Rotisserie Smokehouse sits quietly on County Road 48, but the flavors speak up before you even step inside. This place delivers classic BBQ in its purest form—no unnecessary frills, just wood, smoke, and skill. The first time I stopped by for lunch, the smoky scent pulled me from the parking lot right to the counter. Service is easygoing, and the warmth comes from both the staff and the ovens.
Their rotisserie chicken deserves a spot in every BBQ discussion in South Hill. The skin crisps up beautifully, the spice blend is spot on, and the meat stays juicy right down to the bone. Slow-cooked ribs are another must—tender without falling apart, served with a housemade sauce that keeps things balanced and bold.
If you’re undecided, grab a platter to try a little bit of everything. Dining here is equal parts comfort and discovery.
2. Smoke BBQ Pit Inc
(718) 523-1900Call
Smoke BBQ Pit Inc isn’t about flash. It’s about honest-to-goodness barbecue done right—deep flavors, friendly faces, and the kind of aroma that draws a line out the door. Tucked on Liberty Ave, it’s long been a mainstay for locals in the know. My own recommendation? Never underestimate a kitchen that lets the smoker do the talking.
The jerk chicken is the standout here. Each bite balances a gentle heat with that unmistakable smoky char. The sides—collard greens and macaroni salad—add just the right touch. Barbecue fans should make space for the brisket, sliced thick and full of flavor.
Whether you take it to go or grab a seat, Smoke BBQ Pit Inc packs every meal with easygoing charm.
3. Avenue BBQ Hut
Avenue BBQ Hut blends Caribbean flair with New York City attitude, and the results are genuinely delicious. This spot keeps it simple: order at the counter, watch the kitchen at work, and take home plates that look as good as they taste. Each visit hits with the aroma of slow-cooked spice that lingers even after you’ve left.
Their BBQ chicken is all about deep Caribbean spices—moist, smoky, and unapologetically bold. The jerk salmon earns loyal fans too, flaking apart under a peppery glaze that rarely misses. What ties it all together? Sides like rice and peas or sweet plantains that show off Avenue BBQ Hut’s roots.
Prices are fair, portions are generous, and you’ll leave with a strong urge to come back.
4. Max Bar
(718) 843-9588Call
Max Bar is the kind of neighborhood BBQ spot that always feels busy for a reason. The staff keeps it friendly, but it’s the smoky aroma that guarantees you’ll want to stay awhile. My last meal here started with the sizzle from the open kitchen and ended with a plate of ribs worth writing home about.
The barbecue ribs are the star—smoked until tender, with a glossy glaze that balances sweetness and spice. If you’re feeling adventurous, sample the grilled chicken too. Max Bar doesn’t overcomplicate things; the focus is always on freshness and full flavor.
This is barbecue made for sharing, but you might find yourself jealously guarding your plate once you start digging in.
5. The Best Seafood & BBQ Chicken Corp
(718) 846-0909Call
The Best Seafood & BBQ Chicken Corp might sound like a mouthful, but it lives up to its name. Walking in, you’re met with the sizzle of grills and an endless parade of platters heading out to tables. This is a family-style spot where comfort food and BBQ meet in perfect harmony.
The barbecue chicken is the standout here—delicately charred, packed with savory spices, and always juicy. Seafood fans should try the grilled fish, which comes flaky, fresh, and lightly smoked. The sides are classic and filling, perfect for soaking up all the leftover sauce.
This place is all about big flavors and bigger portions, making it a popular choice for group outings or casual dinners.
6. O’Hanlon Bar & Grill
(718) 261-1402Call
O’Hanlon Bar & Grill is less flashy steakhouse, more classic neighborhood haunt, with just the right dose of charm. The setting is casual, with plenty of locals swapping stories between bites and sips. My favorite booth sits near the kitchen, where you catch a whiff of everything coming off the grill.
Their barbecue chicken sandwich is a standout—smoky, perfectly grilled, and never skimping on flavor. The wings come in several styles, but the smoky BBQ with a hint of sweet is best enjoyed with crisp fries on the side. Here, it’s all about unfussy comfort and reliable eats.
If you want to blend in with the regulars, grab a seat, order a BBQ platter, and let the atmosphere do the rest.
7. A J’s Snack Bar
(718) 297-4221Call
A J’s Snack Bar is understated, but locals know it as a dependable spot for a BBQ fix in Jamaica. This is the kind of place where the regulars know the staff by name and the grill has earned its keep. Walk in and you’ll spot a steady stream of takeout orders—always a promising sign.
The BBQ chicken platter is always a safe bet, served smoky and tender with classic sides you won’t want to skip. Another favorite is the grilled fish, light but still packing that signature char. Meals arrive hot, hearty, and without pretension.
It’s the easy-going, familiar vibe that keeps people coming back. For a low-key BBQ experience, A J’s is tough to beat.
8. Vino Volo
(718) 995-8466Call
Vino Volo stands out by pairing bold barbecue flavors with the kind of comfortable atmosphere that invites you to settle in. The moment you walk in, there’s an easy blend of grill smoke and lively conversation, making this spot feel instantly inviting. I’m partial to their spacious seating—it’s a rare find when you’re in the mood to linger over a meal.
The grilled chicken wings are a highlight here, kissed by smoke and served with just enough sauce. For something simple, try the pulled chicken sandwich. Portions are generous and always arrive piping hot, showing off the kitchen’s attention to detail.
Stop by with a friend or relax solo—either way, Vino Volo’s mix of comfort and flavor hits the mark.
9. All Nations Bar
(718) 526-2525Call
All Nations Bar lives up to its name, drawing a lively crowd with a mix of good music, solid company, and standout barbecue. The vibe here is relaxed but never dull, whether you’re stopping by for a weeknight meal or easing into the weekend with friends. On my first visit, it was the aroma floating from the grill that told me I was in the right place.
The BBQ chicken is a crowd favorite—seasoned well, grilled just right, and served with sides that taste like home cooking. If you’re a fan of bold flavors, don’t skip their grilled salmon, a dish that’s as satisfying as it is simple.
All Nations Bar’s secret is consistency—each visit delivers what you’d expect: great food, easy atmosphere, and no fuss.
10. J & D Bar-B-Q
(718) 657-9564Call
J & D Bar-B-Q keeps things old-school in the best way. You can smell the slow-cooked smoke before you even reach the door, and the welcome here is always genuine. My first meal at J & D was a lesson in why simplicity still wins: familiar classics, served hot and piled high.
The BBQ chicken is a staple—marinated, expertly grilled, and impossibly juicy every time. The ribs come heavily recommended, coated in a tangy sauce and tender enough to eat with just a fork. Sides lean into the hearty and homemade, rounding out every plate.
If you’re searching for no-nonsense barbecue that feels like a backyard cookout, J & D Bar-B-Q delivers every single visit.
More Things to Try in South Hill, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular BBQ dishes in South Hill, NY?
Classic BBQ chicken, ribs, brisket, and grilled fish are favorites. Most local spots also serve sides like rice and peas, collard greens, and sweet plantains.
Are there any halal BBQ options in South Hill, NY?
Many BBQ spots cater to different dietary needs. It’s best to call ahead to ask about halal offerings at specific restaurants.
Can I find Caribbean-style BBQ in South Hill?
Yes, several BBQ restaurants in the area serve Caribbean-inspired dishes, including jerk chicken and grilled fish packed with bold spices.
Do South Hill BBQ places offer vegan or vegetarian options?
Some restaurants offer veggie-friendly sides like salads, grilled veggies, and rice dishes. For vegan or vegetarian mains, choices may be limited, so checking menus ahead is a good idea.
Is takeout or delivery available from BBQ restaurants in South Hill?
Most local BBQ spots offer takeout, and many have delivery options—perfect for an easy BBQ meal at home.
