Few quests test the soul like the search for the best BBQ in Selden, NY. I once spent an afternoon weaving through strip malls and quiet corners, seduced by that unmistakable smoky scent. Each stop on this list is seasoned with more than just hickory or mesquite—it’s built on the kind of neighborhood pride you can taste. Some joints radiate with slow-cooked meats; others surprise with fusion flavors or snappy sides.
Whether you’re after tender brisket, fall-off-the-bone ribs, or chicken done just right, Selden punches far above its weight. This handpicked guide cuts through the noise, so you can spend less time scrolling and more time digging in. Choose a spot that feels right—classic, quirky, or quick. With this roundup, you’re never far from a plate that delivers true BBQ satisfaction.
Where to find the best bbq in Selden, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Selden, NY:
- Choopan Grill
- Texas Roadhouse
- RibCrib
- Wing Wah Restaurant
- Wing Wah Kitchen
- Dickey’s Barbecue Pit
- Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck
- Thristy Scholar
- Outback Steakhouse
1. Choopan Grill
(631) 696-1817Call
Choopan Grill hides in plain sight on Middle Country Road, but the flavors are anything but shy. On my first visit, the steady hum of regulars told me this place feels like a local secret. Seating is casual, but the aroma promises something memorable.
The standout here is the grilled chicken kebab. It arrives juicy and charred, with a spice rub that builds real flavor. Lamb shish is another favorite, served tender and smoky, never greasy. You can taste the care in each skewer—simple, bold, and satisfying.
For sides, the rice pairs perfectly, soaking up every drip of charred goodness. If you’re seeking BBQ in Selden with personality and warmth, Choopan Grill should top your list.
2. Texas Roadhouse
Texas Roadhouse in Selden feels like a party every night, where the energy is almost as strong as the smoky aroma wafting from the kitchen. My last visit started with the irresistible scent of their famous fresh-baked bread—dangerous if you’re hungry.
The hand-cut grilled steaks here are a main event. Each one is seared to order and as tender as any steakhouse can offer. If you’re here for BBQ, the fall-off-the-bone ribs are the clear choice. They come lacquered in a house-made sauce that clings just right—tangy, not too sweet.
Don’t skip the made-from-scratch sides. The seasoned rice and vegetables round out a hearty meal, perfect for anyone craving classic American BBQ in Selden with a lively twist.
3. RibCrib
RibCrib sits just north of Selden, proving great BBQ doesn’t stop at town lines. I remember my first bite at RibCrib—a juicy, slow-smoked chicken leg that set a high bar for the rest of the meal. The space is unfussy, but the menu means business.
RibCrib’s smoked chicken and brisket are the signatures. The brisket comes sliced and draped over your plate, showing off just the right level of smoke ring and tenderness. The pit-cooked chicken boasts deep flavor, never dry, and always satisfying.
Try their classic sides like BBQ beans and coleslaw to round out your meal. For anyone chasing authentic BBQ near Selden, RibCrib serves up comfort with every order.
4. Wing Wah Restaurant
Wing Wah Restaurant has a comfortable, family-style feel that keeps locals coming back. My first meal here included an unexpected treat—the BBQ chicken, which had a subtle sweetness and crisp skin that stayed with me after the meal. The dining room is welcoming, making it easy to linger over a bite with friends or family.
The BBQ beef skewers are a house specialty. Grilled to a deep char on the outside, each bite is juicy with a hint of smoky spice. The kitchen’s technique stands out among the area’s BBQ offerings, fusing Asian-inspired marinades with classic American grilling.
Pair your skewers with vegetable fried rice or sautéed greens. If you enjoy barbecue that’s both familiar and a bit adventurous, Wing Wah is worth a spot on your list.
5. Wing Wah Kitchen
Wing Wah Kitchen, just a short drive from Selden, brings a distinctive Asian twist to classic BBQ fare. On my first visit, I was surprised at how well their grilled meats pair with their famed egg fried rice. The spot bustles at dinner, hinting at its loyal following.
The barbecue chicken skewers shine here. Marinated with a blend of spices, they emerge from the grill both juicy and aromatic. Each bite balances smoky flavors with a light, tangy finish that keeps you reaching for more.
Pair your skewers with sautéed mixed vegetables or lo mein. For those craving a fusion approach to barbecue in Selden, Wing Wah Kitchen offers an inviting blend of comfort and creativity.
6. Dickey’s Barbecue Pit
Dickey’s Barbecue Pit delivers Texas-style BBQ right in Centereach, just minutes from Selden. The first time I walked in, the smoky aroma and rows of sizzling meats promised a legit pit experience. You’ll find hearty portions and a team that knows how to keep the flavors true to tradition.
The smoked chicken and turkey breast are not to be missed. Both carry that signature slow-cooked tenderness and rich hickory profile, served fresh with each order. Classic home-style sides like barbecue beans and mac and cheese complete the meal, turning it into a full Southern feast.
For those in search of real barbecue flavor near Selden without leaving Long Island, Dickey’s serves up genuine comfort with every bite.
7. Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck
Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck turns any parking lot into a barbecue destination. I first spotted the truck at a local event, where the smoky aroma actually pulled a crowd away from the main attraction. With its laid-back charm and family vibe, this mobile pit serves up hearty plates wherever it parks.
Their smoked chicken sandwich and BBQ grilled turkey are worth tracking down. Both capture that wood-fired depth, and portions are generous enough for serious appetites. The cornbread is a sleeper hit, soft and just the right amount of sweet.
Rolling Smoke excels at catering but don’t miss their daily stops—this truck makes BBQ accessible and fun. For BBQ in Selden with flexibility and flair, keep an eye out for that smoke plume.
8. Thristy Scholar
(631) 648-9454Call
Thristy Scholar is a hidden gem for those who crave BBQ alongside a casual bar vibe. My visit began as a pit stop, but the menu turned my quick stay into a longer meal. The warm staff and cozy booths make it easy to unwind after a long day.
The grilled chicken platter is surprisingly satisfying, arriving with char marks and a smoky aroma that signals real attention to the grill. Their barbecue wings, glazed and tangy, are another strong choice for sharing or making a meal out of.
If you need a comfort spot where BBQ meets friendly hospitality, Thristy Scholar has a knack for nailing both. Perfect for gathering, snacking, or just recharging solo.
9. Outback Steakhouse
Outback Steakhouse in East Setauket brings a bit of Aussie flair to classic American BBQ. My visits usually start with the bustle of the dining room, but I always settle in once I catch a whiff of the wood-fired grill. The staff keeps things lively, but the real draw is on the plate.
The grilled chicken on the barbie is always a hit—tender, charred, and finished with Outback’s signature seasoning. For those craving variety, the steak and chicken combo serves up both smoky and savory notes, cooked to your liking.
Pair your order with classic sides like fresh veggies or baked potato. Outback’s BBQ approach is approachable, reliable, and a great fit for both groups and solo diners looking for hearty flavors near Selden.
More Things to Try in Selden, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best spot for BBQ chicken in Selden?
Many locals rave about Choopan Grill for its juicy chicken kebabs, while Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck offers smoky chicken sandwiches full of flavor.
Are there halal BBQ options in Selden?
Some restaurants, like Choopan Grill, are known for using halal ingredients. It’s always smart to call ahead and confirm menu options if halal is important to you.
Which BBQ place is best for families?
Texas Roadhouse and Outback Steakhouse both feature family-friendly atmospheres, roomy seating, and menus with kid-friendly options.
Can I find Asian-inspired BBQ near Selden?
Yes, Wing Wah Restaurant and Wing Wah Kitchen offer barbecue dishes with Asian marinades and unique sides, blending East and West flavors.
Do these BBQ spots offer catering or takeout?
Most places, including Dickey’s Barbecue Pit and Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck, provide catering and takeout for events or family gatherings.