Finding great BBQ in Seaford, NY feels like hunting for gems—overhyped or overlooked spots are part of the landscape, but when you land on a true winner, you remember every bite. I once spent an entire Saturday trying different BBQ joints around Seaford, hoping to discover smoky ribs without the usual parade of artificial sauces. I left stuffed, satisfied, and convinced that this town holds more than a few secrets behind its kitchen doors.
Seaford offers a quirky mix of BBQ experiences, from low-key pits to bustling restaurants serving up hearty, flavor-packed plates. If you’re after tender brisket, smoky chicken, or innovative sides, this list highlights the spots that get it right. Get ready to sift through the must-tries and surprise finds—every pick has earned its place, and your next favorite BBQ plate might just be a few blocks away.
Where to find the best bbq in Seaford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Seaford, NY:
- Smokin’ Al’s Famous BBQ Joint
- Dang BBQ
- Adelaide’s
- E T Quiggs
- Farrells Inc
- Runyon’s
- Pastrami Express
- Jetmore Fireplace Center, Inc.
- Grates N’ Grills
- BBQ Cleaning Brothers
1. Smokin’ Al’s Famous BBQ Joint
Smokin’ Al’s Famous BBQ Joint is where locals lose track of conversation as soon as the food arrives. The aroma alone is enough to pull you off Merrick Road and straight to a booth, napkins ready. I remember lingering over a plate of smoked chicken, the skin crisp yet yielding, with a sweet heat that demanded a second helping.
The secret at Smokin’ Al’s is their dedication to classic slow-cooked BBQ with a signature blend of spices. It’s a spot known for fall-off-the-bone ribs and smoke-kissed brisket, best savored with their homemade sauces. The sides, like creamy coleslaw or baked beans, balance out the richness of the meats.
If you’re torn, go for the smoked chicken platter or the ribs—they define what Smokin’ Al’s does best: straightforward, soulful BBQ that feels like a celebration.
2. Dang BBQ
Dang BBQ earns its reputation by blending Southern tradition with local flair. The first time I visited, my plan for a quick lunch turned into a drawn-out feast as dish after dish kept landing on our table, each better than the last. There’s a relaxed vibe here that lets you focus on the food and the company.
What sets Dang BBQ apart is their commitment to bold flavors and smoky perfection. The kitchen doesn’t skimp on time or technique, so the meats arrive juicy with just the right char. Their smoked turkey and BBQ chicken are favorites among regulars—tender, smoky, and seldom found this well executed anywhere else in Seaford.
Order the BBQ chicken platter for that classic, straight-from-the-pit taste, or sample their smoked mac and cheese if you crave something a bit different. Either way, you’ll understand why people keep coming back for more.
3. Adelaide’s
(516) 783-4500Call
Adelaide’s makes you feel like you’ve stepped into a cozy neighborhood secret, where regulars swap stories over platters of expertly smoked meat. My most memorable visit involved a rainy evening, the kind best spent tucked inside with a plate of their classic BBQ chicken, each bite bursting with layered spices and deep smoke flavor.
What really sets Adelaide’s apart is the care they put into every element. From the house-made sauces to the clinch-perfect sides, nothing here feels like an afterthought. Their BBQ chicken stands out for its tenderness and subtle balance of sweet, smoky, and savory notes.
Don’t miss the BBQ chicken platter for an honest showcase of what makes Adelaide’s a standout in the Seaford area.
4. E T Quiggs
(516) 785-9559Call
E T Quiggs is the kind of place where you settle in and lose track of time, especially when there’s a plate of smoky goodness in front of you. I first ended up at Quiggs on a friend’s recommendation, and before the night was over, I felt like a regular—thanks to their easygoing vibe and generous servings.
This spot is known for its warm, casual atmosphere and straightforward approach to BBQ. You’re here for the food as much as the company, and both deliver. Their BBQ chicken has that crave-worthy char, the kind you rarely find beyond backyard grills.
If you visit, the BBQ chicken or smoked turkey platter is a safe bet, showing off Quiggs’s secret: simple barbecue done exceptionally well and always with a friendly smile.
5. Farrells Inc
Farrells Inc is where good tunes and great BBQ naturally come together. My last visit happened on a night filled with local bands and the unmistakable aroma of smoky grilled chicken drifting from the kitchen. You feel the energy the moment you step inside—this is a gathering spot just as much as a BBQ destination.
What gives Farrells its edge is the blend of live entertainment and consistently flavorful barbecue. You’re just as likely to discover a new favorite band as you are a new go-to dish. The BBQ chicken is especially popular, always juicy and finished with a tangy sauce that has just the right amount of kick.
Order the BBQ chicken platter and settle in; it’s where music and great food find common ground.
6. Runyon’s
Runyon’s is where locals gather for a lively meal that wears many hats. My first time there, I was caught between the clatter of the bar and the cozy buzz of the dining room. After a few bites of their grilled chicken, I stopped caring about anything else. The place carries a sense of nostalgia, the kind that makes you linger over your meal.
This spot stands out for its fusion of traditional grill fare and unexpected menu twists. While the pizetta often steals the spotlight, those in the know go for the BBQ chicken. Each piece is grilled to perfection, locking in flavor and that unmistakable char you crave in quality barbecue.
Order the BBQ chicken platter if you want to see what makes Runyon’s beloved. It’s classic, it’s hearty, and it lets the grill do the talking.
7. Pastrami Express
(516) 308-7555Call
Pastrami Express might sound like a deli stop, but it quietly nails some of the most satisfying BBQ in Seaford. My last visit was fueled by curiosity, but I left with a new appreciation for their slow-cooked approach. There’s a warmth here that feels both old-school and refreshingly no-nonsense.
What makes Pastrami Express a standout is its embrace of both BBQ and deli classics. The kitchen knows smoke, and it shows in each perfectly cooked bite. The smoked turkey is juicy, tender, and layered with subtle spices—a pleasant surprise for anyone used to the usual BBQ contenders.
Go for the smoked turkey platter to see how they balance deep flavor with a leaner cut. It’s BBQ comfort, Seaford-style, with just the right touch of deli charm.
8. Jetmore Fireplace Center, Inc.
Jetmore Fireplace Center, Inc. is the spot where BBQ dreams start before a single bite gets tasted. I wandered through their showroom in Wantagh, drawn by rows of shimmering grills that instantly made me rethink every backyard cookout I’d ever hosted. The staff here know their stuff and give tailored advice that doesn’t feel like a sales pitch.
What sets Jetmore apart is their range—it’s not just the usual suspects. They carry top-tier BBQ grills and accessories that can turn anyone into a neighborhood pitmaster. Whether you’re searching for a gas grill or unique barbecue tools, you’ll find options for any level of experience.
If you want your own BBQ in Seaford to rival local legends, ask about their signature grills. The Fisher & Paykel line is reliable and robust, making it easy to get serious smoke and flavor at home.
9. Grates N’ Grills
(516) 406-0895Call
Grates N’ Grills is the unsung hero behind many memorable home BBQs in the Seaford area. I once made the rookie mistake of thinking my grill didn’t need a professional cleaning—until a few grease fires proved otherwise. That’s when Grates N’ Grills stepped in, transforming my battered grill into something worthy of a true pitmaster.
What separates Grates N’ Grills from the rest is their attention to detail and grill expertise. They offer thorough cleanings, openings, and seasonal closings that keep your equipment safe and your food tasting its best. The difference is obvious as soon as you fire it up after their visit.
If BBQ in Seaford means backyard gatherings for you, schedule a thorough cleaning. Nothing enhances ribs or smoked chicken like a grill that’s spotless and ready for serious flavor.
10. BBQ Cleaning Brothers
BBQ Cleaning Brothers is the kind of service you wish you’d called earlier—especially after the first time you grill on spotless grates. My own grill went from ash-covered and sluggish to looking nearly new, all in a single afternoon thanks to these local brothers. Their passion for clean, safe BBQ gear is obvious from the start.
The edge here is simple: meticulous cleaning and attention to detail. John and Kevin treat your equipment with care, handling everything from basic cleaning to thorough tune-ups. They understand that great BBQ in Seaford starts with a clean setup, and they make it effortless.
If you want your next smoked chicken or brisket to be the talk of the neighborhood, let these two get your grill summer-ready. You’ll taste the difference in every bite.
More Things to Try in Seaford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best BBQ restaurants in Seaford, NY?
Some standout spots include Smokin’ Al’s Famous BBQ Joint, Dang BBQ, and Runyon’s. Each brings its own twist on classic, smoky BBQ favorites.
Are there any BBQ places offering halal or vegetarian options in Seaford, NY?
You’ll find some BBQ restaurants offer vegetarian-friendly sides like mac and cheese, salads, and baked beans. For specific halal menu items, it’s best to call ahead, as offerings can vary.
Can I get BBQ catering in Seaford?
Yes, many local BBQ spots, including Smokin’ Al’s and Dang BBQ, provide catering services for events and gatherings. Be sure to ask about customizable packages to suit your crowd.
Where can I buy BBQ grills and supplies near Seaford?
Jetmore Fireplace Center, Inc. in Wantagh and Grates N’ Grills in Massapequa both offer a great selection of grills, tools, and accessories for home cooks of all levels.
Is there anywhere to get my BBQ grill professionally cleaned in Seaford?
Absolutely. BBQ Cleaning Brothers and Grates N’ Grills both handle grill cleanings, tune-ups, and seasonal maintenance, so your equipment stays in top shape all year.