Searching for the best BBQ in Sayville, NY can feel like hunting for buried treasure, only the rewards are saucier. Sayville isn’t just a town with a couple of smoky grills and picnic tables. It’s packed with hidden gems, neighborhood joints, and sometimes even a food truck that makes you wonder if you’re still on Long Island or somewhere closer to Memphis.
The first time I dove into Sayville’s BBQ scene, I thought I’d seen it all—until I tasted brisket so tender it left me reconsidering past life choices. Each spot on this list brings something delicious to the table, whether it’s house-rubbed ribs, tangy pulled chicken, or creative side dishes you’ll want to write home about. If you’re hungry for smoke, flavor, and a side of small-town charm, you’re in the right place. Let’s explore bites that are worth the drive (and maybe even a little nap after).
Where to find the best bbq in Sayville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Sayville, NY:
- Blackbirds Grille
- BobbiQue
- Kapplers Bar
- The BBQ King Inc
- Road House of Li
- Karvers Grille
- El Capitan Sports Bar
- Mac BBQ Deli & Caterings
1. Blackbirds Grille
Blackbirds Grille isn’t shy about its Southern-Cajun swagger. Walk in and you’ll catch the scent of slow-cooked meats and hear the gleam of laughter from the bar. On my last visit, I settled in for their BBQ ribs—smoky, tangy, and so tender you’ll need extra napkins.
The lively vibe adds to the draw, especially when live music kicks up on weekends. Their platters are legendary, but the brisket sandwich and pulled chicken stand out as pure Sayville comfort. The kitchen doesn’t cut corners, and the sides—think sweet cornbread and creamy slaw—prove it.
If you crave bold flavors with character to match, this is your spot. Don’t skip the house BBQ sauce—it’s the perfect finishing touch.
2. BobbiQue
At BobbiQue, authenticity isn’t just a buzzword—it’s the backbone. Step inside and you’re greeted by a relaxed vibe, live music, and a wall of craft beers that demands a second glance. The scent of smoked meats drifts from an on-site pit that treats brisket and ribs with the respect they deserve.
My last adventure here ended with sticky fingers and a smile. The St. Louis-style ribs are a highlight—deeply smoked, with just enough bark to keep things interesting. For something equally tempting, the pulled chicken offers a lighter but still flavor-packed alternative.
What sets this spot apart? Attention to every detail, from the cut of meat to the house-made sauce. BobbiQue nails Southern BBQ soul and brings it to Long Island.
3. Kapplers Bar
(631) 654-9554Call
Kapplers Bar delivers an old-school BBQ vibe with just the right touch of small-town charm. It’s the kind of place where regulars greet you as you walk in and the aroma of the grill creates instant cravings. My seat at the bar led to conversations as warm as the plates coming out of the kitchen.
The real reason you come here, though, is the BBQ platter. Their slow-cooked beef brisket is the star, loaded with smoky undertones and paired with classic sides—think baked beans and crispy fries. The pulled chicken sandwich runs a close second, every bite tender and packed with flavor.
If you’re after straightforward, satisfying BBQ in a laid-back setting, Kapplers Bar checks all the right boxes.
4. The BBQ King Inc
(631) 218-4604Call
The BBQ King Inc is a hidden gem for barbecue purists. This spot focuses on what matters most—big smoke flavor and generous portions. My first visit was pure serendipity; I walked in famished, left happy, and still think about their tender, slow-cooked meats.
Don’t miss their classic BBQ chicken—it’s juicy with the perfect char. The beef brisket offers deep, rich flavor and melts with every bite. Both dishes highlight true mastery of low-and-slow cooking techniques.
Service here is always friendly, and the atmosphere puts you at ease. For no-nonsense, expertly prepared barbecue in Sayville’s orbit, The BBQ King Inc sets a high bar.
5. Road House of Li
(631) 468-8150Call
Road House of Li brings the spirit of a classic roadhouse straight to Bohemia’s BBQ scene. The atmosphere is casual and unfussy—exactly what you want when your mind is set on smoky, satisfying comfort food. I stopped by after a long week, and the welcoming staff quickly made me feel right at home.
The go-to here is the BBQ chicken platter, which strikes the ideal balance of crispy skin and tender meat beneath. Their ribs are a close contender, known for a flavorful sauce that doesn’t overpower the real star—the meat.
Pair your order with their fries or slaw for the full experience. Road House of Li isn’t just a pit stop, it’s a destination for barbecue lovers.
6. Karvers Grille
Karvers Grille feels like a local secret worth sharing. With its stylish interior and friendly vibe, it’s a great spot for everything from family gatherings to casual dinners. On my last visit, I was struck by how every dish seemed crafted with extra care, from the grill to the table.
Their smoked BBQ chicken is a highlight—juicy, boldly seasoned, and served with classic sides. If you’re in the mood for something different, try the house BBQ brisket sandwich, which balances tender meat and sauce just right.
Quick, attentive service rounds out the experience. Karvers Grille brings barbecue with a touch of style and comfort, making it a staple in Holbrook for those who crave the best BBQ flavors near Sayville.
7. El Capitan Sports Bar
(631) 289-1999Call
El Capitan Sports Bar brings together BBQ cravings and a fun game-day atmosphere. It’s a laid-back hangout, where friends gather over sports and plates are always full. After a long afternoon watching baseball, I found their barbecue to be the real MVP of the menu.
The highlight here is the barbecue chicken platter—tender, smoky, and served with crisp fries. The pulled chicken sandwich also packs a punch, delivering plenty of savory goodness in every bite.
If you want top-notch BBQ with a side of sports excitement, El Capitan’s relaxed, friendly setting is tough to beat. It’s the sort of place that makes you want to linger and savor every bite.
8. Mac BBQ Deli & Caterings
(631) 627-8110Call
Mac BBQ Deli & Caterings is a favorite among locals looking for down-to-earth, flavor-packed barbecue. The deli setting is casual and welcoming, perfect for lunch breaks or grabbing a feast to-go. I stumbled in on a rainy afternoon and found comfort in their warm, hearty dishes.
The star here is the pulled chicken sandwich. Moist, smoky, and topped with house slaw, it captures exactly what homestyle BBQ should taste like. Their BBQ platters never disappoint either, featuring generous portions and classic sides.
Whether you’re hosting a crowd or just feeding your BBQ craving, Mac BBQ Deli & Caterings delivers quality and value every time. It’s a spot you’ll want to visit again—and probably recommend to everyone you know.
More Things to Try in Sayville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated BBQ restaurants near Sayville, NY?
Popular spots include Blackbirds Grille, BobbiQue, The BBQ King Inc, and Mac BBQ Deli & Caterings. Each offers its own twist on classic barbecue favorites, so you’ll find something for every taste.
Which BBQ places in Sayville offer catering or takeout?
Mac BBQ Deli & Caterings is known for excellent catering and takeout options. Many others, like The BBQ King Inc and Karvers Grille, also offer easy pickup for family meals and events.
Are there any sports bars in Sayville with great BBQ?
El Capitan Sports Bar stands out for combining a fun sports bar vibe with hearty BBQ platters—ideal for game day gatherings or a casual night out.
What BBQ dishes should I try in Sayville?
Try the BBQ chicken platters, pulled chicken sandwiches, and beef brisket. These dishes highlight the technique and flavor that set Sayville BBQ apart.
Where can I find BBQ with classic Southern flavors in Sayville?
Blackbirds Grille is a top pick for Southern-Cajun inspired barbecue. Their bold flavors and signature dishes reflect true Southern tradition.
Do any BBQ restaurants in Sayville serve halal or vegetarian options?
While most BBQ restaurants focus on traditional meats, some offer vegetarian-friendly sides. If you have dietary preferences, call ahead to check on specific menu options.