Every town has a BBQ story to tell, but Rye, NY is in a league of its own. From smoky briskets to charred ribs that practically fall off the bone, the local smokehouses and grills serve up plates worth remembering. While exploring Rye’s BBQ scene, I’ve lost count of the times I left a spot with the scent of hickory clinging to my jacket and a newfound appreciation for how this town does slow-cooked, flame-kissed fare. There’s something almost meditative about watching a pitmaster work—just the right balance of patience, craft, and boldness.
Finding the best BBQ in Rye isn’t about following a scent trail, though it does help. It’s about knowing which grills and kitchens truly deliver. Whether you crave classic pulled chicken or want to try something a little outside the usual (without straying from tradition), this guide will steer you straight. Consider this your plate-to-table roadmap—curated by someone who’s tasted their way through the contenders, grateful for every perfectly glazed bite.
Where to find the best bbq in Rye, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Rye, NY:
- Brisa Marina Bar & Grill
- Telly’s Taverna
- Frankie & Johnnie’s Steakhouse
- Executive Corner Deli and Catering
- Hal’s Deli
- Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque
- Halstead S Bar & Grill
- Brother Jimmys BBQ
- Marcas Bar
- The Great American BBQ Co
1. Brisa Marina Bar & Grill
(914) 934-9090Call
At Brisa Marina Bar & Grill, the barbecue is rich with smoky depth and unmistakable care. Tucked on Grace Church Street, this local favorite knows how to balance relaxed atmosphere with serious flavor. The welcoming hum inside makes lingering over a meal all too easy.
On my first visit, the sizzle from the open grill was enough to pique my curiosity—and appetite. Their grilled chicken is marinated just right, capturing hints of citrus and spice. If you love a sturdy side, the house-made slaw pairs well, adding crunch and freshness.
Standouts here always feel thoughtfully put together. For BBQ lovers searching in Rye, Brisa Marina Bar & Grill infuses every dish with a taste of home and just enough boldness to keep things interesting.
2. Telly’s Taverna
Stepping into Telly’s Taverna feels like taking a quick trip to the Aegean, right in the heart of Port Chester. The blue-and-white accents set the mood, but it’s the Greek take on barbecue that makes it memorable. Diana Loiselle’s commitment to fresh ingredients and honest flavors comes through on every plate.
During my last visit, the aroma from their open kitchen led me straight to the grilled chicken souvlaki. Juicy and well-seasoned, it arrives with a hint of char that signals true grill mastery. The lemon potatoes are a perfect companion, balancing each bite with zesty comfort.
What makes Telly’s stand out is its consistency. Whether you’re a local or a first-timer, the warmth of Greek hospitality and their fresh, simply prepared barbecue keep guests coming back for more.
3. Frankie & Johnnie’s Steakhouse
Frankie & Johnnie’s Steakhouse doesn’t just draw a crowd for its perfectly aged steaks—their approach to barbecue is just as noteworthy. Housed in an inviting spot on Purchase Street, this is where refined table settings meet bold, smoky flavors. Even on a busy night, the service remains attentive.
On my most recent visit, the barbecue glazed chicken was a revelation. The meat was tender, accented with a sauce that balanced sweet and tangy without overpowering the main attraction. Add a side of their expertly roasted vegetables and you’ve got a plate that feels both generous and thoughtfully composed.
This steakhouse stands out for its balance between classic comfort and elevated technique. For Rye BBQ seekers, Frankie & Johnnie’s delivers a sense of occasion with every bite.
4. Executive Corner Deli and Catering
Executive Corner Deli and Catering is the kind of neighborhood spot where the menu surprises you with both variety and careful execution. Set just across the border in Greenwich, the deli offers an unpretentious but satisfying spin on BBQ classics. It’s easy to see why regulars keep this place in their lunch rotation.
My first experience here involved the grilled chicken BBQ sandwich. It tasted fresh off the grill, layered with crisp lettuce and just enough smoky sauce to bring everything together. Their homemade potato salads make for a reliable (and popular) side.
What sets Executive Corner Deli apart is consistency and value. For a quick BBQ fix near Rye, this spot stitches together deli comfort and backyard barbecue charm in every bite.
5. Hal’s Deli
(914) 732-3332Call
Hal’s Deli delivers a lively mix of traditional deli fare and bold, flavorful twists thanks to its subtle Mexican influence. The space hums with activity, yet the service always feels personal. Even as a first-time guest, I found myself chatting with staff like an old friend.
The BBQ grilled chicken sandwich is a solid pick—juicy chicken, a hint of smoky sweetness, and a slaw that packs a little crunch. It’s satisfying without feeling heavy and pairs well with their classic deli sides, like crisp kettle chips or a tangy cucumber salad.
Hal’s stands apart for its ability to balance comfort and creativity. Every dish feels made with care, which keeps the BBQ lovers in Rye coming back for another round.
6. Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque
Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque is where the art of slow smoking meets comfort and speed. Tucked in White Plains, it’s a favorite for anyone who respects a no-nonsense approach to BBQ. The laid-back, cozy vibe makes the food stand out even more.
My last visit revolved around the smoked chicken. Each bite delivered tender meat and a smoky flavor that comes only from hours of patient cooking. Their chef-driven sides, like the crisp vinegar slaw, round out each plate with freshness and crunch.
Where Mighty Quinn’s shines is in its simplicity—solid technique and premium ingredients do the talking. For a reliable and satisfying BBQ fix near Rye, this is a stop that consistently delivers on flavor.
7. Halstead S Bar & Grill
(914) 835-8335Call
Halstead S Bar & Grill finds its strength in being both a comfortable local hangout and a spot that knows how to smoke and grill with confidence. The atmosphere is lively, but never overwhelming—you always feel welcome whether dropping by for dinner or a big game.
On my last visit, their BBQ chicken platter was the highlight. Perfectly cooked chicken paired with a sauce that adds just enough sweetness and tang. The side of seasoned fries is always crisp, making the whole meal feel especially satisfying.
What sets Halstead S apart is the combination of friendly service and well-executed classics. BBQ fans in Rye will appreciate the quality and consistency that keeps this place busy throughout the week.
8. Brother Jimmys BBQ
Brother Jimmy’s BBQ is the kind of place you visit when you’re craving big Southern flavors and laid-back energy. Located on Mamaroneck Avenue in White Plains, it attracts both barbecue enthusiasts and crowds just looking for a good time.
On my visit, the standout was their pit-smoked chicken, served tender with a smoky aroma that lingers—proof they know their way around the fire. The cornbread is worth a spot on your order, too, balancing sweetness with a golden crust.
Brother Jimmy’s stands out by delivering consistent, crowd-pleasing plates without pretension. If you want BBQ near Rye that’s hearty, flavorful, and never tries too hard, this is your spot for a relaxed feast.
9. Marcas Bar
(914) 948-3700Call
Marcas Bar is one of those unassuming spots where the company is as memorable as the food. Located on West Post Road, this bar-and-grill fusion offers a comfortable setting with a menu that puts barbecue front and center.
During my last visit, the grilled chicken barbecue plate stood out. The chicken came smoky and juicy, with just enough char to let the grill’s character shine through. Pair it with their seasoned fries or a crisp side salad for a complete meal.
Marcas Bar wins over newcomers with its friendly service and classic, unfussy BBQ. When you’re in the mood for straightforward grilling, this spot does it with just the right amount of flair.
10. The Great American BBQ Co
The Great American BBQ Co brings big-flavor barbecue to Greenwich Plaza, making it a popular choice for anyone searching for BBQ close to Rye. What you notice first is their devotion to the craft—slow-cooked meats and timeless sides served with a side of nostalgia. The vibe is casual and always inviting.
On a recent visit, the pit-grilled chicken made a lasting impression. Perfectly smoked and tender, it arrived with a house-made sauce that’s more tangy than sweet. Their homemade coleslaw pulls everything together, adding crispness to every plate.
What sets this place apart is consistency. Every order feels like it came straight off a backyard grill, yet manages a level of polish only a true barbecue crew can achieve.
More Things to Try in Rye, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best BBQ restaurants near Rye, NY?
Popular picks include Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque, Brother Jimmy’s BBQ, The Great American BBQ Co, and Halstead S Bar & Grill. Each spot serves its own style—think slow-smoked meats, signature sauces, and classics like grilled chicken barbecue plates.
Do any BBQ spots in Rye, NY offer halal options?
Menus change often, so it’s best to call ahead about halal options at places like Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque or ask about ingredients when you arrive.
Are there take-out or delivery BBQ options in Rye, NY?
Yes, many places such as Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque and Executive Corner Deli offer take-out and delivery. Most can be ordered online or by phone.
What sides should I try with BBQ in Rye?
You can’t go wrong with house-made slaw, seasoned fries, or a side of tangy cucumber salad. Most places offer these alongside smoky grilled meats for a well-rounded meal.
Is there good BBQ for large groups or catering?
Absolutely. The Great American BBQ Co and Executive Corner Deli both specialize in catering and have menus designed for group events and gatherings.