Finding real BBQ in Plattsburgh, NY isn’t about luck. It’s about knowing exactly where to look. Seasoned smoke, tangy sauces, and that unmistakable aroma—there’s a good reason folks talk about Plattsburgh’s barbecue scene. I still remember the first time I grabbed a bite of brisket here, expecting something average, and getting absolutely proven wrong. That’s how it usually goes: the best BBQ isn’t shouted from rooftops, but whispered between those in-the-know.
If you’re hunting for the kind of BBQ that sticks in your memory, this guide will help. I’ve tasted my way through pit stops, breweries, and neighborhood joints. Some spots might surprise you, others you may have heard about but never tried. Each one is a little different, but every place on this list has earned a seat at the table. Trust these picks to point you toward your next favorite meal, and maybe even a new weekend tradition.
Where to find the best bbq in Plattsburgh, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Plattsburgh, NY:
- Texas Roadhouse
- Dickey’s Barbecue Pit
- The Pepper
- The Chimney Sweep Hearthside Shoppe
- Heat Wave
- Livingood’s Restaurant & Brewery
- Barkeaters Barbeque
- Penalty Box
- Bayview Bar & Grill
- Doc’s Last Call
1. Texas Roadhouse
If you crave BBQ that holds its own against the best, Texas Roadhouse on Cornelia Street deserves a visit. The aroma alone tells you something good is about to happen. Every time I slide into one of their booths, I know I’m in for a satisfying meal, with generous portions and plenty of energy buzzing around.
The star here is their fall-off-the-bone ribs—smoky, tender, and brushed with a sauce that’s both sweet and just a hint spicy. Paired with made-from-scratch sides, like cinnamon butter bread or seasoned green beans, it’s a combination built for returning regulars.
Hand-cut steaks also share the BBQ spotlight, served juicy and expertly prepared. For anyone who likes a proper plate of smoked meat, the Roadhouse sampler is a surefire way to get a taste of everything they do well.
2. Dickey’s Barbecue Pit
Dickey’s Barbecue Pit offers a Texas-style BBQ experience right in Plattsburgh. Each visit feels like stepping into a neighborhood tradition, where slow-smoked meats and home-style sides are the focus. I’ve dropped by at lunch and been tempted by the smoky aromas drifting from the kitchen—always a good sign for a BBQ joint.
The brisket at Dickey’s stands out, sliced thick and balanced between perfectly smoky and tender. Add a side of baked beans or classic potato salad, and you’ve got a plate that hits all the right notes. Their pulled chicken is another solid pick, juicy and loaded with flavor from hours in the smoker.
If you’re undecided, the pitmaster’s choice platter brings a variety, showing off the menu’s range. Dickey’s feels welcoming, and the barbecue keeps you coming back.
3. The Pepper
The Pepper brings a twist to BBQ in Plattsburgh by blending smoky American barbecue with bold Mexican flavors. Stepping inside, the vibrant atmosphere grabs you right away. One visit left me hooked by their creative approach—classic barbecue, but with a punch of spice and color.
The BBQ chicken enchiladas are a must-try, wrapping tender smoked chicken in warm tortillas and finishing with a tangy sauce. Their char-grilled steak fajitas have just the right amount of smokiness and always arrive sizzling.
If you’re drawn to something a bit different, order the BBQ tacos. The mix of slow-cooked meat and fresh toppings is both hearty and refreshing. The Pepper proves that barbecue isn’t just one flavor—it’s an adventure.
4. The Chimney Sweep Hearthside Shoppe
The Chimney Sweep Hearthside Shoppe isn’t your typical BBQ spot—it’s the local go-to for those who take grilling seriously. Visiting the shop brings back memories of testing out new smokers and chatting with staff who know every trick for getting that perfect smoke ring.
This place stands out because it’s more than just a store. It’s a hub where barbecue fans gather advice, supplies, and a good bit of inspiration for home cooking. The selection covers everything from classic charcoal grills to state-of-the-art pellet smokers, making it easy to find exactly what your backyard needs.
If you’re looking to elevate your BBQ game in Plattsburgh, start here. Their staff guide you to the right equipment and teach you how to use it, so every meal tastes like a cookout worth remembering.
5. Heat Wave
Heat Wave is where barbecue enthusiasts go when they want to up their grilling routine. I’ve stopped in more than once to compare grill models and ended up swapping recipe tips with fellow visitors. This shop isn’t flashy, but it’s full of reliable gear and big ideas for backyard cooks.
They focus on a wide range of grills and smoking supplies, making it easy to find the right setup for classic slow-cooked barbecue. The knowledgeable team is always ready with practical advice, whether you’re working with charcoal or considering your first pellet grill.
If you’re serious about perfecting ribs, chicken, or brisket at home, Heat Wave is worth a look. They take your setup as seriously as you take your barbecue.
6. Livingood’s Restaurant & Brewery
Livingood’s Restaurant & Brewery in Peru takes the BBQ tradition and gives it a distinctive local twist. I like the blend of energetic taproom vibes with the comforting smell of smoked meats wafting from the kitchen. Their menu isn’t limited to barbecue, but what they do offer packs plenty of flavor.
The pulled chicken sandwich is a standout, juicy and seasoned just right, served on a soft roll alongside crisp slaw. They also offer wood-fired barbecue plates for those who want something heartier. Each dish comes with thoughtful sides—expect fresh, local ingredients and house-made sauces that highlight their commitment to quality.
Pairing your plate with one of their craft brews is almost a tradition. Livingood’s always feels inviting, making it a top pick for anyone who enjoys BBQ with a bit of creative flair.
7. Barkeaters Barbeque
(518) 834-9464Call
Barkeaters Barbeque in Keeseville has a reputation that reaches straight to Plattsburgh. I’ve pulled off Route 9 for takeout more than once, and every visit underlines why it’s worth the short drive. The smell of the pit signals you’re in the right place for classic barbecue—simple, direct, and packed with smoky character.
The ribs are the headline here. Tender, meaty, and perfectly glazed, they barely need extra sauce. If you’re in a group or just hungry, order the pulled chicken too. It’s juicy and smoky, great in a sandwich or straight with sides.
Barkeaters keeps it straightforward, serving up hearty plates with sides like coleslaw and baked beans. This is BBQ done the old-fashioned way—no fuss, just deep flavors and satisfied appetites.
8. Penalty Box
(802) 863-2065Call
Penalty Box might be just across the lake in Colchester, but it’s worth the trip for BBQ fans in Plattsburgh. My last visit added a new favorite to my list—smoky barbecue in a sports bar setting, where everyone’s watching the game and tucking into full-flavored plates.
The pulled chicken sandwich deserves a mention. It’s thick, tender, and served with sides that balance out the meal well. I’m also a fan of their slow-cooked ribs, which arrive with just the right amount of char.
Penalty Box nails the laid-back atmosphere while still serving up food that’s built for lingering. If you want BBQ with plenty of local energy, this is a solid choice.
9. Bayview Bar & Grill
(802) 652-2444Call
Bayview Bar & Grill stands right at the edge of Colchester, making it a favorite stop after a day near the water or a drive from Plattsburgh. My evenings here have always included big plates, friendly service, and panoramic views that make the food taste just a bit better.
Their smoked chicken is a menu highlight, juicy on the inside with a crisp, flavorful finish. If you want a taste of everything, the sampler platter lines up all the barbecue hits—ribs, pulled chicken, and classic sides.
Bayview’s charm lies in its easygoing energy and commitment to satisfying barbecue. The scene is laid-back, the portions are generous, and each dish is delivered with real attention to detail.
10. Doc’s Last Call
(518) 834-5956Call
Doc’s Last Call keeps things down-to-earth with the kind of no-nonsense barbecue you hope to find in a small-town spot. My first stop here was after a long drive, and I was met with friendly faces and the welcoming scent of a grill working overtime.
The pulled chicken and barbecue platters both shine, each offering hearty portions and sauce with just a touch of sweetness. The sides—think coleslaw and fries—round out the meal with classic, comforting flavors.
Doc’s is the kind of place where the food is the star and regulars mix with newcomers. If you’re after honest barbecue and want to feel like a local, this is a must-stop near Plattsburgh.
More Things to Try in Plattsburgh, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top BBQ spots in Plattsburgh, NY?
Some of the best BBQ options include Texas Roadhouse, Dickey’s Barbecue Pit, and The Pepper. Each brings a unique twist on smoked classics, from traditional ribs to barbecue tacos.
Are there vegetarian options at Plattsburgh BBQ restaurants?
Many BBQ restaurants in the area, like Texas Roadhouse and The Pepper, offer vegetarian-friendly dishes and sides, making it easy to enjoy a meal with everyone.
Do any BBQ places in Plattsburgh offer takeout or catering?
Yes, most BBQ spots including Dickey’s Barbecue Pit and Barkeaters Barbeque have takeout options. Many also provide catering for events—always a good call for a crowd.
What kind of BBQ styles can I find in Plattsburgh?
You’ll find a mix of Texas-style, classic American, and even BBQ-meets-Mexican dishes, so there’s plenty to try if you’re adventurous.
Is it easy to find gluten-free BBQ in Plattsburgh?
Several spots, like Texas Roadhouse, offer gluten-free options. It’s always best to check with the restaurant staff for specific menu details.