Best BBQ in Oyster Bay, NY

Oyster Bay, NY, has some seriously amazing BBQ spots that I just can’t wait to share with you! I’ve tasted my way through the area, and I’m excited to tell you all about the best places to grab some smoky, delicious food. Trust me, you’re going to want to check these out!

So, what’s the best BBQ in Oyster Bay, NY? Well, the best BBQ here features a bunch of fantastic restaurants that serve up mouthwatering smoked meats, tasty sauces, and a cozy vibe. Each place has its own special twist on BBQ, making sure there’s something for everyone to enjoy.

I promise you’ll find some real gems in this article! From juicy brisket to fall-off-the-bone ribs, I’ll take you through the top BBQ joints in Oyster Bay, and you’ll see what makes each one so special. Let’s dive in and find your new favorite BBQ spot!

Top 10 BBQ in Oyster Bay, NY

1. Stuey’s Smokehouse BBQ
2. Del’s Bar & Grill
3. Beach Bird
4. Wild Honey Restaurant
5. Old Fields Barbecue Huntington
6. The Homestead
7. Coach Meeting House
8. Blowin’ Smoke BBQ
9. Teddy’s Bully Bar
10. 2 Spring

1. Stuey’s Smokehouse BBQ

Stuey’s Smokehouse BBQ is such a cool place! It’s at 50 Birch Hill Rd in Locust Valley, NY, and I just love going there. When I walked in, the yummy smell of smoke hit me right away, and I felt so cozy. They have nice spots to sit inside or outside, which is great for enjoying a meal.

What makes Stuey’s super special is how they cook their food. Everything is smoked just right, and the flavors are really bold. You have to try the brisket! It’s so tender and juicy, and when you dip it in their homemade BBQ sauce, it’s like a flavor explosion!

And oh, don’t forget about the ribs! They are so soft that they just fall off the bone. Trust me, Stuey’s is a must-try for anyone who loves BBQ!

2. Del’s Bar & Grill

Del’s Bar & Grill is such a fun place to eat! It’s at 129 Pine Hollow Rd in Oyster Bay, NY, and I had a great time when I went there. The moment I walked in, I felt super welcome, and I loved that I could choose to sit inside or outside. It’s a nice spot to hang out with friends or family.

What makes Del’s really special is their yummy BBQ and friendly service. Everything I tried was so fresh and tasty! You have to get the pulled pork sandwich—it’s so tender and full of flavor, especially with their special sauce on it.

And don’t skip the chicken wings! They are crispy and just perfect. Del’s Bar & Grill is definitely a must-visit for anyone who loves good food!

3. Beach Bird

Beach Bird is such a fun place to eat! It’s at 19 E Main St in Oyster Bay, NY, and I had the best time when I went there. As soon as I walked in, the bright colors and happy vibe made me smile. They have nice spots to sit inside or outside, which is perfect for a sunny day.

What really makes Beach Bird special is their yummy BBQ. Everything tastes so fresh and light! You have to try their BBQ chicken—it’s super juicy and packed with flavor. And don’t forget about the coleslaw; it’s really tasty and goes great with the chicken!

If you’re in a hurry, their takeout is awesome too! Beach Bird is definitely a must-visit for anyone who loves delicious BBQ in a cheerful place!

4. Wild Honey Restaurant

Wild Honey Restaurant is such a cozy and lovely place! It’s right at 1 E Main St in Oyster Bay, NY, and I had the best dinner there. The warm candlelight made everything feel super special, and I really liked that I could choose to sit inside or outside. It’s a perfect spot for a nice meal with friends or family.

What makes Wild Honey really stand out is their fun and creative food. Everything I tried was so yummy and different! You have to get the honey-glazed chicken; it’s super juicy and has this sweet flavor that’s just perfect.

And don’t forget to try their fresh seasonal veggies—they are so tasty! Wild Honey Restaurant is definitely a must-visit for anyone who wants a delightful meal!

5. Old Fields Barbecue Huntington

Old Fields Barbecue Huntington is such a fun place to eat! It’s at 15 New St in Huntington, NY, and I had a blast when I went there. The vibe is super relaxed, and I loved that I could choose to sit inside or outside. It felt really cozy, just right for enjoying some yummy BBQ.

What makes Old Fields really special is their tasty BBQ meats and platters. Everything I tried was so flavorful and filling! You have to get the brisket; it’s so tender and smoky, just perfect for BBQ lovers like me.

And don’t forget about the sides! The mac and cheese is creamy and super delicious. Old Fields Barbecue Huntington is definitely a must-visit for anyone who loves good BBQ!

6. The Homestead

The Homestead is such a cozy and fun place to eat! It’s at 107 South St in Oyster Bay, NY, and I had a really great time when I went there. The warm atmosphere made me feel right at home, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. Plus, they often have live music, which makes it even more special!

What really makes The Homestead stand out is their yummy American pub food. Everything I tried was super delicious! You have to get their BBQ ribs; they are so tender and full of flavor, just perfect for BBQ fans like me.

And don’t miss their loaded fries! They are crispy and topped with all the best stuff. The Homestead is definitely a must-visit for anyone who wants a tasty meal in a fun place!

7. Coach Meeting House

Coach Meeting House is such a fun place to eat! It’s at 160 Mill River Rd in Oyster Bay, NY, and I had a really nice time when I went there. The moment I walked in, I felt super welcome, and I loved that I could pick to sit inside or outside. It felt cozy and just right for enjoying a meal with friends.

What makes Coach Meeting House really special is their yummy BBQ and friendly service. Everything I tried was so tasty! You have to get their smoked brisket; it’s so tender and full of flavor, just perfect for BBQ fans like me.

And don’t forget to try their sweet potato fries! They are crispy and super delicious. Coach Meeting House is definitely a must-visit for anyone who loves good food!

8. Blowin’ Smoke BBQ

Blowin’ Smoke BBQ is such a fun place to eat! It’s at 8045 Jericho Turnpike in Woodbury, NY, and I had the best time when I went there. As soon as I walked in, the yummy smoky smell made my mouth water, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It felt super cozy, just right for enjoying some delicious BBQ.

What really makes Blowin’ Smoke special is their amazing flavors. Everything I tried was so tasty! You have to get their pulled pork; it’s super tender and full of flavor, just perfect for BBQ lovers like me.

And don’t forget to try their mac and cheese! It’s creamy and goes perfectly with your meal. Blowin’ Smoke BBQ is definitely a must-visit for anyone who loves yummy BBQ!

9. Teddy’s Bully Bar

Teddy’s Bully Bar is such a cool place to eat! It’s at 46 Audrey Ave in Oyster Bay, NY, and I had a really fun time when I went there. As soon as I walked in, I felt super welcome, and I loved that I could pick to sit inside or outside. It’s a cozy spot that’s just perfect for hanging out with friends.

What makes Teddy’s Bully Bar really special is their yummy BBQ and friendly vibe. Everything I tried was so tasty! You have to get their BBQ chicken; it’s juicy and full of flavor, just right for BBQ lovers like me.

And don’t forget to try their crispy onion rings! They are so good and make a perfect side. Teddy’s Bully Bar is definitely a must-visit for anyone who loves delicious BBQ!

10. 2 Spring

2 Spring is such a beautiful place to eat! It’s at 2 Spring St in Oyster Bay, NY, and I had a really nice time when I went there. As soon as I walked in, I felt like I was in a special spot. The cozy atmosphere made it perfect for a nice dinner with friends or family.

What makes 2 Spring really stand out is their fancy and super delicious food. Everything I tried was so tasty! You have to get their grilled steak; it’s so juicy and cooked just right.

And don’t forget to try their fresh seasonal veggies—they are really yummy! 2 Spring is definitely a must-visit for anyone looking for a special meal in a lovely setting!

Map of BBQ in Oyster Bay, NY

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best BBQ restaurants in Oyster Bay, NY?
The best BBQ spots in Oyster Bay are Stuey’s Smokehouse BBQ, Del’s Bar & Grill, and Beach Bird. Each place has its own yummy flavors and a cozy vibe that BBQ lovers will really enjoy!

2. Do these BBQ places offer takeout?
Yes, most BBQ restaurants in Oyster Bay, like Stuey’s Smokehouse BBQ and Del’s Bar & Grill, have takeout options. It’s super easy to grab some delicious BBQ to enjoy at home or on the go!

3. Are there vegetarian options at BBQ restaurants?
While BBQ places focus on meat, many have vegetarian choices like salads and sides. It’s always good to check the menu or ask the staff for what they recommend!

4. Can I make reservations at these BBQ spots?
Yes, some BBQ places like 2 Spring and The Homestead do take reservations. It’s a smart idea to call ahead, especially on busy nights, to make sure you get a table.

5. Is outdoor seating available at BBQ restaurants in Oyster Bay?
Yes! Many BBQ restaurants in Oyster Bay, like Beach Bird and Coach Meeting House, have outdoor seating. It’s perfect for enjoying a meal when the weather is nice!