Barbecue in Nutley, NJ is like a hidden playlist on shuffle—sometimes smoky, sometimes tangy, always surprising. I first stumbled across Nutley’s BBQ scene trying to settle a debate over who makes the best halal-friendly brisket for a late Sunday meal. Three hours, five napkins, and more sauce than decency allows later, I knew this tiny town had a much bigger BBQ spirit than I expected.
What makes Nutley worth exploring for BBQ fans? There’s a wide stretch of choices, from old-school joints serving juicy bites with a soulful twist, to upstart grill masters eager to tempt you with something new. If you value variety, quality, and a secret or two behind every smokestack, you’re in for something memorable. Whether you’re hunting for a spot to share with friends, bring the family, or just indulge solo, the best BBQ in Nutley sits ready. Dig in and discover these local legends—your next favorite meal might be two turns away.
Where to find the best bbq in Nutley, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Nutley, NJ:
- Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque
- Pulaski BBQ Inc
- All The Smoke BBQ
- The Rock Bar & Grill
- Ryan’s BBQ
- Stephanies BBQ
- Mickey’s Bar and Grill
- Gone With The Wings
- Columbia BBQ
- Fire Pit BBQ
1. Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque
Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque on State Route 3 is what happens when someone gets barbecue exactly right. The first time I tried their brisket, the bark snapped just right and every bite was tender enough to need nothing but a fork and willpower.
The standout here is their slow-smoked brisket, served up with chef-inspired sides that actually taste like someone cared when making them. The pulled chicken is full of gentle smoke, and their wings vanish fast if you bring friends along.
Those craving that old-school BBQ feeling will find it in a platter piled with brisket, burnt ends, and generous helpings of seasoned fries or slaw—simple, honest, and built for sharing. Grab a seat or order out, your plate will be satisfying either way.
2. Pulaski BBQ Inc
Pulaski BBQ Inc on Walnut Street turns out the kind of barbecue that pulls in locals by word of mouth alone. My first time there, I watched a steady stream of regulars order without glancing at the menu—always a good sign. The aroma coming from the open kitchen is enough to draw anyone in from the sidewalk.
What sets Pulaski BBQ apart is the balance between smoke and seasoning. You taste it right away in their chicken and beef ribs, both cooked to a tenderness that doesn’t need a knife. The portions are generous, and every plate looks like it’s meant for sharing.
The rice and beans are a sleeper hit, so pair them with their juicy BBQ chicken or a hearty helping of beef ribs. Pulaski’s food proves sometimes the simple places get it just right, especially when they let the barbecue do all the talking.
3. All The Smoke BBQ
All The Smoke BBQ on Market Street is where you go when you want your meal to leave an impression. The first time I visited, the brisket’s smoky aroma greeted me before I even reached the door. It felt like a promise, and the pitmasters delivered.
The magic here is in their low-and-slow method. Their halal-friendly brisket and smoked chicken never fail—each bite is rich and moist, every edge kissed with real smoke. It’s food that has patience and pride built in.
Try their brisket platter, stacked high and served with fresh sides. If you like variety, mix in their grilled sausage and sampler plates. All The Smoke BBQ knows how to turn simple ingredients into something crave-worthy.
4. The Rock Bar & Grill
The Rock Bar & Grill on Main Ave offers barbecue with the buzz of a neighborhood hangout. My first visit was for a casual dinner, and I ended up staying much longer than planned—good food pairs well with an easygoing atmosphere. This place has the comfort of a regular’s retreat and the steady sizzle of the grill rolling out favorites all day.
Their standout? Smoked chicken platters and perfectly grilled beef skewers. Every plate has that backyard BBQ taste you can’t fake, especially when the grill marks and savory aroma arrive at your table.
If you crave generous servings, go for the chicken skewers with a side of crisp fries. The Rock’s grill offers simple, hearty barbecue where flavor gets the spotlight and regulars feel at home.
5. Ryan’s BBQ
Ryan’s BBQ on Stuyvesant Ave is the kind of place you hear about from someone who loves true barbecue. My first meal there came after a rainy afternoon and I was searching for something hearty—Ryan’s smoked chicken hit the spot right away, both in flavor and comfort.
The wood-fired grill is the centerpiece here, and you can taste it in every single bite. Their BBQ chicken and tender grilled lamb are crowd-pleasers, perfectly seasoned and kissed by just the right amount of smoke.
If you’re hungry, the mixed grill platter is a smart bet. It lets you try a spread of standout options, all crafted with the same careful touch. Ryan’s BBQ is where old-school technique meets generous servings and genuine flavor.
6. Stephanies BBQ
Stephanies BBQ on Centre St feels like a cozy kitchen crossed with a serious smokehouse. My first visit was on a chilly night when nothing else would do but a big, hot plate of barbecue. The staff greeted me with easy smiles and the smell of grilled chicken in the air set the tone for a memorable meal.
The highlight here is their BBQ chicken, served up with juicy tenderness and a char that keeps you coming back. The portions are comforting, not just generous, and sides like seasoned rice and beans make it a true comfort meal.
If you’re after classic, relaxed BBQ, Stephanies hits the spot. Grab the mixed chicken platter and share, or keep it all to yourself if you’re feeling hungry. This spot delivers warmth and honest flavor, plate after plate.
7. Mickey’s Bar and Grill
Mickey’s Bar and Grill on Riverside Ave is where every kind of craving finds a match, thanks to a menu that flexes from barbecue to Italian and even a little Irish. My first dinner here was during game night, and the place had a buzz that made the meal feel like a gathering among friends—even if you arrive solo.
The star of the barbecue selection is their grilled chicken platter. It’s served hot off the grill, with just the right amount of char. The portions work well for sharing, or for refueling after a long day.
Pair your platter with a side of fries or mixed veggies, and enjoy the comfortable, family-friendly space. Mickey’s keeps it classic and satisfying, perfect for those who want choice and good food under one roof.
8. Gone With The Wings
(973) 661-2531Call
Gone With The Wings on River Rd is a must for anyone who loves their barbecue with a side of creativity. The first time I walked in, the place had the cheerful, lively vibe of a local hangout, and the kitchen’s energy was contagious.
Their wings are the standout, smoked then tossed in unique, house-made sauces that keep regulars guessing and grinning with each visit. You’ll find flavors that range from classic smoky to tangy and sweet, each one landing big on taste.
If you want to get a feel for what they do best, try a mixed platter of wings and grilled chicken. The variety ensures you get the full experience—and may turn a quick stop into a sit-down feast.
9. Columbia BBQ
Columbia BBQ on Washington Ave takes familiar barbecue favorites and adds a comforting, local twist. My first meal here started with their sizzling grilled chicken and a side of rice that made me wish I had a second stomach. The staff keeps the mood light, making it the kind of spot you want to linger a while.
What sets Columbia BBQ apart is their attention to flavor and texture. Every plate arrives with chicken that balances smoky, juicy, and perfectly seasoned, while sides like sautéed veggies round out the meal without overpowering the main event.
Order the grilled chicken platter for a reliable introduction to their kitchen’s strengths. For something to share, the family-style combos make Columbia BBQ a top pick for group dinners or casual celebrations.
10. Fire Pit BBQ
Fire Pit BBQ on Belleville Tpke is where classic grill flavor gets a modern touch. My first trip here happened on a busy weekend—just watching the kitchen staff confidently work the flames was half the fun. The environment is laid-back, perfect for a family meal or catching up with friends over a hearty plate.
The star at Fire Pit BBQ is their spit-roasted chicken. It arrives with crisp skin and tender, juicy meat that soaks up every bit of their signature marinade. The sides—think rice, beans, and seasoned vegetables—turn every meal into a feast.
Go for their combo platters if you want to sample it all, but the spit-roasted chicken is the reason people come back. Fire Pit BBQ proves that sometimes all you need is straightforward, well-cooked barbecue done right.
More Things to Try in Nutley, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular BBQ spots in Nutley, NJ?
Favorites often include Mighty Quinn’s Barbeque, Stephanies BBQ, Pulaski BBQ Inc, and Gone With The Wings. Each spot brings something unique to the table, whether it’s slow-smoked classics or creative wing flavors.
Are there halal-friendly BBQ options in Nutley?
Yes, several local barbecue joints offer halal-friendly dishes. Always check with the restaurant directly, as menus can change and options may vary.
Do BBQ restaurants in Nutley offer takeout or delivery?
Most places provide both, with some even partnering with food delivery services. If you’re in a hurry or planning an event, call ahead to order your favorites.
What should I order if I want traditional BBQ flavors?
Try smoked chicken, brisket, or ribs paired with classic sides like rice, beans, or slaw. These dishes highlight the true flavor and technique of Nutley’s best BBQ spots.
Is it necessary to make reservations at Nutley BBQ restaurants?
For most casual spots, walk-ins are welcome. However, if you’re going with a group or during peak hours, a reservation can save you a wait.