If you’ve ever driven through New Hyde Park around dinnertime, you’ll know the aroma of smoke and spices hangs in the air, tempting even the most seasoned barbecue seekers. I remember my first foray into this thriving scene—standing in line, clutching a menu, watching pitmasters work their magic behind a haze of smoldering oak and hickory. That first taste was all it took to realize BBQ here is more than a meal; it’s an event, brimming with uniquely local flavors and flair.
This guide isn’t a generic roundup. Each spot has been scouted for its distinctive style, consistent quality, and warm hospitality. Whether you crave slow-cooked brisket, halal platters sizzling straight from the grill, or inventive sides that steal the show, these places stand up to the hype. Get ready to explore the best BBQ in New Hyde Park with confidence and maybe discover a new favorite you never knew was around the corner.
Where to find the best bbq in New Hyde Park, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in New Hyde Park, NY:
- McCarthys
- Sempre Fame Gourmet Grill & BBQ Catering
- Shackletons Bar & Grill
- Bell’s Kitchen and Smokehouse
- Bar B Q Tonight
- Cross Island Party Catering
- Park Place Restaurant & Bar
- Bramasole Italian Restaurant
- Atl Wings Inc
- Churrasqueira Bairrada Restaurant
1. McCarthys
McCarthys blends classic barbecue with a lively bar scene, perfect for anyone chasing the comfort of smoked flavors and neighborhood friendliness. It’s the kind of spot where locals swap stories over brisket, and every visit feels a little like a reunion.
One night, a friend urged me to try the BBQ platter, and I haven’t looked back. The smoked chicken and beef options are crowd favorites—tender, juicy, and finished with just enough char from the grill. The kitchen clearly respects the craft.
Order the beef ribs—they’re packed with smoke, tang, and a subtle sweetness that lingers. They capture what McCarthys does best: comfort food that refuses to be ordinary.
Parking’s easy and the staff offers warmth to spare, making this a standout for genuine, welcoming eats.
2. Sempre Fame Gourmet Grill & BBQ Catering
Sempre Fame Gourmet Grill & BBQ Catering is where the craft of barbecue meets pure creativity. Walking in, you sense the pride these folks take in transforming fresh ingredients into something memorable. Once, I sampled their smoked beef skewers at a friend’s event, and everyone couldn’t stop talking about the flavors for days.
Their grilled lamb kebabs are a particular standout—juicy, aromatic, and perfectly seasoned. It’s clear they’re serious about their marinades and slow-cooking techniques. The kitchen is not shy about playing with spices, but every bite comes together in harmony.
Order the smoked turkey legs or BBQ platters if you want a taste of what makes this place local legend. It’s backyard comfort with chef-driven finesse.
3. Shackletons Bar & Grill
Shackletons Bar & Grill may fly under the radar, but it’s a place regulars refuse to gatekeep. The vibe is comfortable, with a friendly hum that makes stopping by feel like seeing old friends. It’s the kind of spot I stumbled on after a long drive, craving something hearty and satisfying.
Their BBQ beef sliders are a must-try. Served piping hot, these bites strike the perfect balance between smoke and tenderness. The kitchen knows when to let the meat shine and when a bold sauce belongs in the spotlight.
If you’re torn, go for the grilled chicken platter. It’s juicy, lightly charred, and best enjoyed with their smoky side dishes. At Shackletons, simplicity is their signature, and it works.
4. Bell’s Kitchen and Smokehouse
(516) 492-3557Call
Bell’s Kitchen and Smokehouse is the spot where comfort food gets treated with true passion. The aroma when you walk in signals that this is genuine barbecue, made by people who care about every slice and sizzle. My last visit was met with an easy smile from the staff and a menu that reads like a love letter to bold flavor.
The smoked turkey breast is a standout, impossibly moist and deeply seasoned. It’s a dish that always earns a repeat order at my table. Their brisket, slow-cooked and expertly trimmed, matches any craving for meaty satisfaction without overpowering with sauce.
If you want a side, try their grilled vegetables. It’s surprising how much attention goes into the little things here. Bell’s keeps it real—hearty, warm, and memorable.
5. Bar B Q Tonight
(718) 347-4555Call
Bar B Q Tonight is a staple for anyone searching for authentic South Asian barbecue near New Hyde Park. Stepping inside, you’re greeted by the gentle sizzle of kebabs and the aroma of spices toasting over charcoal. My own visit here felt like a quick passport to Karachi, minus the jet lag.
Their chicken seekh kebabs are legendary—moist, deeply seasoned, and cooked just right. The kitchen isn’t shy about bold seasoning, and it pays off in every bite. Tender beef kababs also top the must-try list, served with rice or naan for the full experience.
For variety, order their mixed BBQ platter. Bar B Q Tonight captures classic flavors and delivers them with flair, all while keeping it affordable and welcoming.
6. Cross Island Party Catering
(516) 489-5855Call
Cross Island Party Catering makes hosting a BBQ effortless, whether it’s a backyard celebration or a big family milestone. Their team brings not just the food but everything you might need, from grills to tents, transforming any space into barbecue central. My cousin’s graduation party had their setup, and the guests raved for weeks.
What separates them from the usual caterer is their attention to smoky, slow-cooked classics that suit a range of tastes. Everything arrives perfectly timed and piping hot, which shows their decades of expertise. Their service always feels personal, not just professional.
If you’re picking dishes, go for their beef brisket and grilled corn on the cob. Both deliver bold flavor and backyard authenticity. Cross Island Party Catering makes it easy to savor great barbecue wherever you are.
7. Park Place Restaurant & Bar
Park Place Restaurant & Bar gives you a taste of refined comfort, where barbecue shares the spotlight with classic American fare. When I first came in, the blend of upscale setting and a relaxed, welcoming vibe made it easy to settle in for a while.
The BBQ chicken platter is the highlight—tender meat with a subtle smoky finish and just the right balance of char. Their homestyle approach means the sides are more than an afterthought. Everything on the plate feels crafted rather than mass-produced.
If you’re looking for variety, try their grilled vegetable skewers or the smoked turkey breast. Both showcase Park Place’s knack for simple flavor done right. It’s a strong contender for dinner, date night, or catching up with friends.
8. Bramasole Italian Restaurant
Bramasole Italian Restaurant puts an Italian spin on barbecue, and the result is something you won’t find anywhere else in New Hyde Park. The mood inside feels as inviting as a family dinner, with attentive service that never hurries you along. My last meal here lingered long after the plates were cleared, for all the right reasons.
The grilled chicken alla Bramasole stands out—juicy, marinated with herbs, cooked just right, and finished with a drizzle of olive oil. You sense the blend of Mediterranean tradition and New York BBQ pride in every forkful.
The roasted vegetable platter deserves a mention too. Every item is charred to perfection, showing how barbecue here is both rustic and refined. Bramasole is where Italian and barbecue flavors become fast friends.
9. Atl Wings Inc
(516) 775-9464Call
Atl Wings Inc delivers on crave-worthy barbecue in a casual, friendly setting. The place is a magnet for wing lovers and fans of smoky, bold flavors. The first time I stopped by, the intoxicating scent of barbecue sauce hit me before I even reached the door—always a good sign.
The grilled chicken wings are the centerpiece here. Crisp on the outside, juicy inside, and coated in just the right amount of tangy sauce, they’re a true crowd-pleaser. The kitchen isn’t afraid to turn up the heat with their signature dry rubs and finishes.
If you’re feeling adventurous, ask for their smoked turkey wings. Each bite is loaded with flavor and shows a dedication to the barbecue craft. For sides, the grilled corn is simple but satisfying, rounding out a fun, filling meal.
10. Churrasqueira Bairrada Restaurant
Churrasqueira Bairrada Restaurant serves up a Portuguese barbecue experience that’s tough to match in the New Hyde Park area. Walking in, the tempting aroma of charcoal-grilled meats sets the stage for a hearty, memorable meal. My first time here, I couldn’t resist peeking at the rotisserie as plates kept flying by to happy tables.
Their piri-piri chicken is a signature—crisped over the flames, locked in with smoky heat, and utterly addictive. Each bite covers gentle spice, fresh herbs, and a touch of lemon. You’ll notice right away why so many regulars are loyal.
Pair that with their grilled beef skewers for classic, no-frills satisfaction. Churrasqueira Bairrada keeps it traditional, delivering big flavor in every dish.
More Things to Try in New Hyde Park, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top BBQ places in New Hyde Park, NY?
McCarthys, Bell’s Kitchen and Smokehouse, and Bar B Q Tonight are popular for their standout menus and inviting atmosphere. Each spot brings a distinct flavor to the local barbecue scene.
Are there halal BBQ options in New Hyde Park?
Yes, places like Bar B Q Tonight and Qabila Afghan Grill offer halal-friendly barbecue, focusing on fresh, seasoned dishes free from haram ingredients.
Can I find vegetarian BBQ dishes in the area?
Several BBQ spots now offer more than just meats. Look for grilled vegetable platters at Bramasole Italian Restaurant or Park Place Restaurant & Bar for a tasty alternative.
Which BBQ restaurant is best for catering events?
Cross Island Party Catering specializes in full-service BBQ catering, covering everything from small backyard gatherings to larger celebrations.
Do New Hyde Park BBQ restaurants offer delivery or takeout?
Most local BBQ places provide both takeout and delivery. Check with your restaurant of choice for the latest details on their policies and online ordering options.