Sometimes, the smoky scent of barbecue floating on a New City breeze is all it takes to get you craving the real thing. You know the spot—you can almost taste the char and sweet spice in the air before you even open the door. Finding the best BBQ in New City, NY isn’t just about flavor; it’s about the hunt for juicy brisket, tender wings, and unique sauces that steal the show. Whether you’re after a full-on rack of ribs for a lazy afternoon with friends or a quick bite that packs a punch, New City serves up a range of barbecue joints worth your attention.
Over the years, I’ve learned that true BBQ fans have one thing in common: they never settle for average. I’ve spent more evenings than I care to count hunting down hidden gems and well-loved staples in Rockland County—delivering napkin-stained reviews and sticky-fingered research so you don’t have to. Consider this your shortcut to the meaty highlights and slow-cooked classics that locals return to, week after week. Still reading? Good. By the end of this guide, you’ll know exactly where to find your next barbecue fix, no guesswork needed.
Where to find the best bbq in New City, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in New City, NY:
- Bailey’s Smokehouse – New City
- Monsey Barbecue
- Big Daddy’s Homeplate BBQ
- Portuguese Churrasqueira BBQ Restaurant
- Woody’s Bar-B-Q
- The Publik House
- BBC Grill Savor Latin
- Beast BBQ
- 306 Southern BBQ
- Little Vietnam Bar & Grill
1. Bailey’s Smokehouse – New City
Bailey’s Smokehouse in New City is a local staple for genuine, slow-cooked BBQ. Every visit, I’m struck by the hypnotic aroma of hickory smoke pouring from the kitchen—there’s no mistaking the real deal here.
The brisket is what drew me in first—tender, juicy, and perfectly seasoned. Their brisket sandwich is a top pick, loaded with smokiness and served with a homemade sauce that’s just sweet enough. Those who like a little variety should try their platter, where you’ll get generous portions of pulled chicken, succulent ribs, and classic Southern sides.
What makes Bailey’s stand out isn’t just the food; it’s the laid-back, friendly vibe and attention to detail in every bite. Here, BBQ is less of a meal and more of an experience worth savoring.
2. Monsey Barbecue
Monsey Barbecue brings a comforting, family-style spin to BBQ that always feels inviting. The first time I dropped by, I noticed locals chatting as servers hustled platters of smoky perfection to every table. The smell of their BBQ chicken alone could lure you in from the parking lot.
Monsey Barbecue stands out for its consistency and attention to classic barbecue standards. Their seasoned chicken and house-made sides are reliable crowd-pleasers, reflecting years of hometown experience. The grilled turkey is a favorite—juicy, tender, and smoky enough to rival the best brisket.
Try the chicken platter with their signature sauce or opt for their turkey legs if you want something that’s both comforting and memorable. You’ll notice right away: this is BBQ made with care, served in generous portions, and always satisfying.
3. Big Daddy’s Homeplate BBQ
Big Daddy’s Homeplate BBQ is where Southern BBQ hospitality meets Rockland County charm. Every visit for me feels like stepping into a friend’s backyard cookout, with warm greetings and the unmistakable scent of slow-cooked meats wafting through the air.
Their standout is the classic BBQ chicken—smoked until it’s falling off the bone, bursting with layers of flavor. Add on their seasoned wings and an order of collard greens for a plate that balances both hearty and homey. Their no-fuss sides, like cornbread and fresh slaw, complete the experience in true Southern style.
If you’re a fan of traditional comfort, start with their barbecue chicken platter or go for the sampler to try a bit of everything. Big Daddy’s offers heartfelt hospitality with every bite, making it a stop worth savoring.
4. Portuguese Churrasqueira BBQ Restaurant
Portuguese Churrasqueira BBQ Restaurant brings a distinctive twist to the local barbecue scene. The first time I visited, the aroma of fresh herbs and charcoal led me straight to their open grill—a pleasant sign that something special was cooking.
What sets this spot apart is its dedication to traditional Portuguese barbecue, with flavors that go far beyond smoky sweetness. The grilled chicken is the headline act: marinated with garlic, lemon, and spices, then charred to juicy perfection. Served with rice or crisp fries, each plate is memorable and satisfying.
Try the chicken churrasco for a true taste of their method, or order the grilled fish if you want something unexpected yet just as well-executed. Every bite showcases careful preparation and bold, unforgettable flavor.
5. Woody’s Bar-B-Q
Woody’s Bar-B-Q boasts a classic roadside vibe, perfect for anyone in search of stick-to-your-ribs barbecue done right. My first visit, I was greeted with a friendly hello and the unmistakable scent of sizzling barbecue that meant business.
Woody’s stands apart for its tenderness and consistent flavor—smoke, spice, and sweetness all balance in every bite. I found their BBQ chicken platter and sweet corn to be a comforting meal that hit all the right notes after a long day.
If you like your barbecue unfussy and packed with flavor, go for the BBQ chicken or a loaded baked potato topped with smoky seasoning and fresh fixings. Woody’s makes simple food shine, and that’s always worth coming back for.
6. The Publik House
(845) 271-3200Call
The Publik House brings together pub comfort and barbecue favorites in a cozy, laid-back setting. What drew me back here was the warmth—from both the staff and the grill. There’s an easy, neighborly buzz each time you walk through the door.
This spot stands out for its hearty spins on classic BBQ that you can enjoy alongside a friend or solo after work. Their BBQ chicken sandwich, stacked with tender pieces and house sauce, stands up to any craving. Try it with a side of their crispy fries for a reliable, satisfying meal.
If you’re in the mood for something a little different, the grilled veggie platter is smoky, flavorful, and surprisingly filling. The Publik House makes every visit feel like a neighborhood tradition worth returning to.
7. BBC Grill Savor Latin
(845) 517-2003Call
BBC Grill Savor Latin is where smoky barbecue finds a bold, Latin twist. My first meal there was a pleasant surprise—barbecue favorites reimagined with vibrant spices and flavors that wake up the taste buds.
This spot stands out for its fusion of classic grilling and Latin American flair. The BBQ chicken is beautifully marinated and grilled until juicy, layered with spices that are both familiar and fresh. The corn on the cob, dusted with house seasoning, made a perfect companion dish.
Try the grilled chicken platter with a side of yuca or plantains to see what makes BBC Grill really shine. These dishes showcase their knack for bold, well-balanced seasoning and a playful approach to barbecue tradition.
8. Beast BBQ
(845) 777-9227Call
Beast BBQ makes a strong impression with serious smoke and unapologetic flavors. The first time I stopped by, the place lived up to its name—the portions are generous, and the aroma alone is enough to tempt anyone in from the street.
Every dish promises bold taste and attentive preparation. Their BBQ chicken, slow-cooked and finished with a robust sauce, stayed juicy through every bite. The hand-cut fries on the side were crisp and golden, setting off the main course nicely.
If you want to sample Beast BBQ’s full range, the BBQ chicken plate is a must-order. It’s hearty, flavorful, and piled high, so come hungry. The straightforward approach here pays off in bold, memorable bites every time.
9. 306 Southern BBQ
306 Southern BBQ invites you in with comforting aromas and that unmistakable Southern charm. On my last visit, I noticed the steady crowd—a clear sign this spot has a loyal following. The feel is warm, relaxed, and focused on old-school hospitality.
What sets 306 Southern BBQ apart is the balance between classic flavors and careful technique. Their BBQ chicken is slow-cooked and bathed in house-made sauce, with every taste delivering that signature smoke and tang. Their sweet potato fries are crisp and addictive, adding a little Southern sweetness to the meal.
The BBQ chicken platter is a highlight, piled high and perfect for sharing. If you want an authentic taste of Southern-style barbecue, this place delivers both tradition and comfort in each bite.
10. Little Vietnam Bar & Grill
Little Vietnam Bar & Grill is where barbecue gets an unexpectedly delicious Vietnamese twist. My first dinner here felt like a gentle dive into something new—grill smoke mingling with the scent of lemongrass and fresh herbs.
This spot earns its reputation with dishes that balance bold BBQ flavor and the crisp freshness Vietnamese cuisine is known for. Their grilled chicken skewers are a highlight: juicy, marinated with ginger, garlic, and spices, and served with a tangy dipping sauce that wakes up every bite.
If you want to try something different, go for their barbecue chicken or lemongrass-grilled plates paired with rice and pickled vegetables. Little Vietnam Bar & Grill takes familiar BBQ favorites someplace new and vibrant—perfect when you want a meal that’s both comforting and original.
More Things to Try in New City, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of barbecue are popular in New City, NY?
Most local spots offer classic American barbecue like chicken, ribs, and brisket, with a few places adding international twists—think Portuguese-style churrasco or Vietnamese grilled plates.
Are there BBQ restaurants in New City, NY that offer halal or kosher options?
Yes, some restaurants in and around New City cater to dietary needs. Always check with the restaurant before ordering to confirm they can accommodate halal or kosher preferences.
Which BBQ dish should I try first if I’m new to the area?
The BBQ chicken platter is a safe and tasty choice at many places here. It’s a local favorite and often highlights the spot’s unique sauce and smoking technique.
Are there family-friendly BBQ restaurants in New City, NY?
Definitely. Many BBQ spots are casual and have menus suitable for all ages. Some also offer kids’ portions and family platters.
Can I find vegetarian or pescatarian options at BBQ places in New City?
You’ll find some creative veggie dishes—like grilled vegetable platters or barbecue fish—at select spots, especially those with a broader menu.
Do BBQ restaurants in New City, NY offer takeout and catering?
Most places offer takeout, and some provide catering for events. It’s always good to call ahead or check their website for details.