The smell of real BBQ can stop anyone in their tracks. It tugs at memories of family get-togethers, smoky backyards, and lazy afternoons spent chasing one more rib before the plate goes empty. In Medford, NY, searching for that perfect bite is not just a pastime—it’s a proper hobby. Choosing from secret rubs, house-made sauces, and slow-cooked brisket, you’ll find the town’s BBQ game holds its own, with every spot serving up its own story.
I’ve wandered through Medford’s BBQ joints like a hungry explorer, sampling wings that sing with spice, pulled meat so tender it barely hangs on a fork, and platters that make it hard to pick a favorite. This list trims out the guesswork, putting you right at the heart of Medford’s best BBQ without ever steering off course. Whether you’re craving classic comfort or BBQ with a twist, the scene here is as satisfying as it is varied—and you’ll want to see which place takes the crown for your next BBQ craving.
Where to find the best bbq in Medford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Medford, NY:
- Village Pub
- L I Wings-N-Things
- BobbiQue
- Choopan Grill
- Old Dock Grill
- Texas Roadhouse
- Kapplers Bar
- Thristy Scholar
- RibCrib
1. Village Pub
(631) 880-7099Call
I wandered into Village Pub after hearing whispers about their smoky BBQ on Horseblock Road. What caught my attention was the rich scent drifting out as soon as the doors swung open. The atmosphere buzzes with friendly chatter, and locals treat the place like a second home, making it easy for newcomers to settle in.
Their BBQ menu is a highlight, especially the slow-cooked ribs and pulled chicken—both arrive with just the right balance of smoke and spice. You can watch cooks in action behind the bar, working their grills with easy confidence.
For a true taste, I always order the platter with seasoned chicken and a pile of classic BBQ sides. Each bite reflects Village Pub’s knack for simple, hearty food done right.
2. L I Wings-N-Things
Long before I ever saw the sign for L I Wings-N-Things, I heard about their wings from a friend who swore up and down they were the best in the area. Stepping inside, I was met by the spicy aroma that promises good things, fast service, and a menu that suits every BBQ mood.
Their grilled chicken wings are the star, available in a range of BBQ sauces and rubs that balance sweet, smoky, and a little heat. Each order arrives juicy, never greasy, with a texture that keeps you coming back.
If you want variety, grab a mixed platter with fresh grilled chicken, zesty BBQ sauce, and classic sides. L I Wings-N-Things knows how to satisfy BBQ cravings without fuss.
3. BobbiQue
Walking into BobbiQue on Main Street feels like you’ve landed inside a southern BBQ dream. The low hum of live music and the sight of their bustling pit set the mood for a relaxed, messy meal. I quickly realized this spot had more character than most—big flavors, good company, and paper towels at every table.
Their St. Louis-style ribs steal the spotlight. Each rib comes out with crisp bark and melting, smoky meat, begging to be savored. As a brisket enthusiast myself, I couldn’t resist their take—a juicy, slow-cooked marvel with rich flavor in every forkful.
If you want a sampler, try the combo platter with ribs, brisket, and pulled chicken. BobbiQue piles on the authenticity, giving you a taste of BBQ done right in Medford’s backyard.
4. Choopan Grill
(631) 696-1817Call
Most BBQ spots stick to familiar territory, but Choopan Grill brings something different to the table. Tucked away on Middle Country Road, it delivers BBQ with a twist—think bold spices and careful grilling. The first time I visited, what caught my attention was the smoky aroma paired with unique flavors you don’t find everywhere.
Their kebabs are the main attraction, charred just right and always juicy. Grilled chicken and beef are both crowd-pleasers, each bite bursting with seasoning that lingers long after the meal. The grill marks alone are reason enough to come back.
Order a mixed grill platter if you want variety. It showcases Choopan’s BBQ style and proves that good grilling goes far beyond the usual ribs and wings.
5. Old Dock Grill
When you crave BBQ but want a lighter option, Old Dock Grill carves out its own niche. Tucked beside Yaphank’s waters, this spot mixes deli classics with tangy grilled specialties. My first visit was all about a relaxed lunch, sun shining and the grill scent drifting across the patio tables.
The grilled chicken platter stands out. Each bite is tender, smoky, and never overpowered by sauce. Their homemade BBQ sauce takes things up a notch, offering that sweet-smoky balance true fans appreciate.
If you’re in the mood for comfort but not a heavy meal, the grilled turkey sandwich with their signature BBQ sauce delivers. Old Dock Grill proves you don’t have to choose between hearty and healthy—just show up hungry.
6. Texas Roadhouse
There’s a special sort of energy at Texas Roadhouse in Selden—part steakhouse, part BBQ haven, always loud and cheerful. The first time I walked in, the sound of line dancing and sizzle from the open kitchen made it clear: this is a spot built around fun and hearty food.
Their fall-off-the-bone ribs are a must-try. They arrive with a sticky glaze, slow-cooked until the meat pulls apart with almost no effort. The BBQ chicken is a close runner-up, smoky and served with a side of their made-from-scratch sides.
For an experience that shows off Texas Roadhouse’s house style, order a rib and BBQ chicken combo. Every plate proves why the place keeps locals coming back for bold, classic BBQ.
7. Kapplers Bar
(631) 654-9554Call
If you want BBQ with a cozy, no-fuss vibe, Kapplers Bar in Patchogue has that covered. One visit and you see why people call it their local spot—the relaxed feel, the friendly faces, and the smoky aroma that lingers around the grill set it apart from chain restaurants.
The grilled chicken and beef platters shine here. Every order comes off the grill smoky, juicy, and with the right hint of char, bringing out simple BBQ flavors that don’t need much dressing up.
I keep coming back for their classic BBQ plate paired with crisp fries and house-made coleslaw. Kapplers Bar keeps it real with familiar comfort and good food that’s always satisfying when you want straightforward BBQ in Medford’s orbit.
8. Thristy Scholar
(631) 648-9454Call
There’s a laid-back charm to Thristy Scholar that makes it a favorite for BBQ with friends. It’s the sort of spot where the portions are generous and the music always fits the mood. My first visit stretched much longer than I planned, thanks to good company and the tempting aroma of their grill.
The grilled chicken and BBQ platters are real standouts. Each dish comes with smoky edges and a house sauce that finds just the right balance—not too sweet, not too spicy.
Order a platter with extra sides for a satisfying meal, especially on a casual night out. Thristy Scholar’s style is all about easy atmosphere and solid BBQ you can count on every time.
9. RibCrib
RibCrib on Route 112 is a reliability in the world of BBQ cravings. When I first stopped by, the staff’s easy confidence made it clear they take smoking meat seriously. The smell of low-and-slow barbecue draws you in before you’ve even opened the menu.
The ribs here really deserve attention. Smoked until tender and lacquered in a house BBQ sauce, they fall off the bone without losing their structure. The brisket and smoked chicken are neck and neck in terms of flavor, each bite delivering on the promise of great barbecue.
Order the combo platter if you want a bit of everything. RibCrib serves up classic BBQ fare with consistency and just enough flair to keep regulars coming back.
More Things to Try in Medford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best BBQ restaurants near Medford, NY?
Some local favorites include BobbiQue, Texas Roadhouse, RibCrib, Village Pub, and Choopan Grill. Each offers their own spin on classic BBQ, from slow-cooked ribs to juicy chicken platters.
Are there BBQ spots with outdoor seating in the Medford area?
Yes, several places like Old Dock Grill and BobbiQue offer outdoor seating—perfect for enjoying smoky flavors in the open air.
Can I find halal BBQ in Medford, NY?
While most spots focus on traditional American BBQ, Choopan Grill is known for dishes that may align with halal preferences. It’s a good idea to check with each restaurant about halal options.
Which BBQ restaurants offer catering in Medford?
Many spots such as Village Pub, Old Dock Grill, and Mac BBQ Deli & Caterings offer catering services for events and parties.
What are must-try dishes at Medford’s BBQ restaurants?
The fall-off-the-bone ribs at Texas Roadhouse, St. Louis-style ribs at BobbiQue, grilled kebabs at Choopan Grill, and classic BBQ chicken platters at several local bars are all worth tasting for a true sense of the area’s BBQ style.