Finding good BBQ in Manorville is a bit like tracking down a hidden gem on a long country road—equal parts adventure and reward. I’ve spent weekends chasing that mouthwatering smoke, only to stumble into spots where the brisket starts you talking and the cornbread keeps you lingering. Manorville has more to offer than meets the eye; its BBQ scene is a quiet pride, where local pitmasters let their craft do the talking.
Choosing where to go can get overwhelming when you look at just how many tempting stops line these roads. Each serves its own take on ribs, pulled chicken, and all the fixings—some tucked into cozy corners, others humming with chatter and grilling sounds late into the night. I’ve tasted my way through sauce styles and spice rubs, and lived to share the blueprint. If you want the real deal and not just the best-known names, you’re in the right place. Let’s get into it.
Where to find the best bbq in Manorville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Manorville, NY:
- Fatboysbbq
- Cody’s Barbecue Grill
- Spicy’s BBQ
- Maple Tree BBQ
- Old Dock Grill
- BBQ Pellet Guy
- Sunset BBQ
1. Fatboysbbq
Fatboysbbq sits off Moriches Middle Island Road, but you’ll know you’re close when the scent of slow-cooked meat hits you from the parking lot. This spot is run by folks who truly care about barbecue, not just filling plates. There’s always a friendly word at the counter, and the sides taste just as homey as the mains.
The standout here has to be the brisket. It’s tender, deeply smoked, and sliced to order. I remember my first bite—smoky edges, juicy center, and a spice crust that lingers just long enough. Ask for their pulled chicken too; it’s juicy without drowning in sauce, a great pick if you want classic flavor with a little Manorville twist.
Pair your meat with collard greens or their baked beans. Both are full of soul and round out the meal. Fatboysbbq captures what Manorville barbecue is all about—simple, bold, and always satisfying.
2. Cody’s Barbecue Grill
(631) 284-9520Call
Cody’s Barbecue Grill in Riverhead is a spot where you immediately sense the care behind every cut of meat. On my last visit, the aroma of hickory smoke greeted me before I even hit the door. Inside, the space pairs lively energy with the kind of comfort that says, “Relax, you’re about to eat well.”
What sets Cody’s apart is consistency. Every rib I’ve tried there has been tender and smoked to perfection. Their barbecue chicken doesn’t hide behind heavy sauce either, letting the natural flavor stand out. Locals swear by the half-rack of ribs, and I found them to be the ideal balance of savory and sweet.
Order a generous plate of ribs and a side of slaw. If you like a bit of heat, try their house-made BBQ sauce. Cody’s brings classic flavors with a personal touch, making it worth the short trip from Manorville.
3. Spicy’s BBQ
(631) 727-2781Call
Spicy’s BBQ is a Riverhead institution that feels like a rite of passage for anyone craving real, unfussy barbecue. It’s a casual spot that hits the sweet spot between speed and satisfaction—perfect for an easy lunch or takeout.
What makes Spicy’s stand out is the flavor-forward approach to everything they serve. My first visit had me reaching for their beef BBQ plate, which doesn’t just settle for being smoky but adds a gentle kick in the seasoning. Their barbecue sauce is house-made and bold, unlike anything you’ll find in a bottle.
Go for the beef BBQ or grilled chicken sandwich. Both showcase what Spicy’s does best—straightforward, craveable comfort food that never skimps on the barbecue spirit.
4. Maple Tree BBQ
Maple Tree BBQ is a go-to for anyone in Manorville or Riverhead who craves authenticity in their barbecue. The scent of real wood smoke will draw you in long before you spot the sign. Everything here gets cured and smoked daily, a detail you’ll taste in every bite.
There’s a certain comfort in knowing that what hits your plate was tended to with care that same morning. I’m a fan of their pulled chicken, piled high and just saucy enough to keep things interesting without drowning the smoky notes. Their house sides, especially the mac and cheese, feel like an upgrade on diner comfort food.
Order the barbecue sampler if you can’t decide. That way, you get a taste of why Maple Tree BBQ keeps a loyal following—smoke, spice, and a sense that you’re eating somewhere just a bit special.
5. Old Dock Grill
Old Dock Grill in Yaphank is one of those rare finds that skillfully balances deli tradition with barbecue comfort. The menu is broad, but the commitment to freshness never slips, even on the busiest days. My first visit was a pleasant surprise: fast service, generous portions, and the kind of easygoing atmosphere that feels custom-made for unhurried meals.
The house barbecue chicken sandwich is a winner. Tender grilled chicken comes coated in their signature sauce, bright and tangy, layered on locally baked bread. It’s classic without trying too hard and delivers that backyard flavor you crave.
Their grilled fare rounds out the experience—don’t skip the daily barbecue specials if they’re available. Old Dock Grill stays true to its roots while offering a tasty nod to Manorville’s barbecue spirit.
6. BBQ Pellet Guy
BBQ Pellet Guy is not your average barbecue spot—it’s where true enthusiasts go when they want smoky flavor done right. Nestled in Riverhead, this place draws grill fans from all over Long Island, all looking for the kind of real-wood taste that’s hard to find elsewhere.
I popped in for a sampler and left convinced that slow-smoked beef is their secret weapon. It’s deeply flavored, with every bite carrying layers of smoke and spice. Even their grilled chicken stands out for its tenderness and subtle seasoning—a cut above your standard barbecue fare.
If you’re at a loss, order the beef platter. It’s a straightforward showcase of what BBQ Pellet Guy does best—satisfying barbecue, prepared with skill, and ready to rival anywhere else in the Manorville area.
7. Sunset BBQ
Sunset BBQ in Westhampton Beach delivers barbecue with a slightly European twist, thanks to its deli roots and unique flavor combinations. My visit here felt like summer—casual, lively, and filled with the scent of slow-grilled perfection wafting from the kitchen. The staff knows their regulars by name, which says a lot about the kind of spot this is.
The barbecue chicken here is a must-try. It’s marinated and grilled, staying juicy under a golden char, and the sauce strikes a fine balance between tangy and sweet. The sides, like potato salad and fresh slaw, taste homemade and never generic.
If you’re craving something a little different, try the chicken grilled sandwich or the house special barbecue chicken platter. Sunset BBQ brings something fresh and memorable to the Manorville BBQ scene.
More Things to Try in Manorville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What kind of barbecue styles can I find in Manorville, NY?
You’ll come across a mix of Southern-inspired barbecue, classic American smoked meats, and some local twists. Expect everything from slow-cooked brisket to pulled chicken, plus plenty of homemade sauces and sides.
Are there halal BBQ options in Manorville?
Some restaurants do offer halal-friendly options—just call ahead to confirm menu details and preparation methods to be sure.
What dishes should I try at a Manorville BBQ spot?
Brisket, pulled chicken, and smoked beef plates are go-to choices. Many places also make signature sandwiches and platters that let you sample a bit of everything.
Can I find BBQ catering services in Manorville?
Yes, several BBQ restaurants in and around Manorville offer catering for parties, events, or family gatherings. Options often range from simple tray pickups to full-service setups.
What makes Manorville BBQ different from other areas?
Manorville’s BBQ spots balance classic techniques with local charm. You’ll find pitmasters who care about smoke, spice, and serving up memorable meals that reflect Long Island’s easygoing spirit.
Are there vegetarian options at BBQ restaurants?
Most BBQ places now offer vegetarian-friendly sides such as mac and cheese, baked beans, and slaw. Some even feature grilled veggie platters or salads for a lighter option.
Is it necessary to make reservations?
For bigger groups or popular spots, a call ahead can be a good idea—especially on weekends when things get busy.
