Mention BBQ in Mahopac, NY, and you’re sure to spark a debate. The town has a laid-back vibe, but when it comes to smoked brisket and saucy ribs, opinions get heated. Over the years, I’ve trailed the scent of woodsmoke through hidden roadside joints and lively grill spots, all in pursuit of that perfect, slow-cooked bite. Each spot on this list has surprised me in its own way—whether with tender halal meats, tangy sauces, or just the kind of char that lingers in your memory.
If you’re searching for the best BBQ in Mahopac, consider this your shortcut to the good stuff. I’ve sifted through the messy and the marvelous to highlight only the real standouts. Some places keep it classic, while others add their own twist on familiar favorites. By the end, you’ll know not just where to go, but exactly what to expect at each stop. If you’re ready for smoky satisfaction, start scrolling—you just might find your new favorite plate.
Where to find the best bbq in Mahopac, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Mahopac, NY:
- Holy Smoke
- The Parting
- Johnny D’s BBQ and Burgers
- The Chophouse Grille
- Northern Smoke
- Home & Hearth
- Bob*B*Q’s
- Sticky Fingers Smokehouse
- Diego’s Deli BBQ
- Kelly’s Corner
1. Holy Smoke
Holy Smoke sits just off Route 6n and has the feel of a classic roadside BBQ joint. The scent of hickory smoke hits before you reach the door. Inside, the casual vibe and friendly staff set the tone for a relaxed meal.
What always stands out here is the authentic slow-smoked technique. The brisket is rich and buttery, and the smoked turkey is a crowd favorite—both packed with flavor and never dry.
Try the burnt ends for a punch of smoky goodness, or go for the combo platters to sample more than one specialty. Each plate comes piled high, perfect for sharing or for a feast all your own. Holy Smoke delivers classic BBQ with just the right Mahopac twist.
2. The Parting
(845) 628-0649Call
The Parting, often called The Parting Glass by locals, has a classic, old-school atmosphere that feels both comforting and unpretentious. You get the sense that regulars have been settling into these booths for years. On my visits, it’s the kind of place where time slows down and the aroma of the grill lingers in the air.
What makes The Parting special is its balance of hearty BBQ and inviting bar fare. The staff knows the menu and always have a quick recommendation. Here, the ribs come out tender and smoky, and the chicken is juicy without being drowned in sauce.
Opt for the BBQ chicken platter or sample their house-made sides—the grilled corn and coleslaw are easy favorites. The Parting delivers comfort food with character, right in the heart of Mahopac.
3. Johnny D’s BBQ and Burgers
Johnny D’s BBQ and Burgers delivers a big, bold BBQ experience with a local touch. The open kitchen lets you watch the pitmasters work, filling the place with energy and anticipation. My first visit here turned into a feast—each plate had a distinct signature, and none overwhelmed the basics.
Johnny D’s stands out for straightforward flavors and generous portions. The pulled beef is a standout, with tender strands soaked in just enough house sauce to leave you reaching for an extra napkin.
Order the BBQ combo platter to sample beef, smoked chicken, and fresh sides—the cornbread is always warm and crumbly. Johnny D’s keeps things simple, hearty, and true to classic Mahopac BBQ style.
4. The Chophouse Grille
The Chophouse Grille blends a steakhouse feel with Southern BBQ flair, right along Mahopac’s bustling main drag. There’s a polish to the atmosphere—think cloth napkins, but still relaxed enough for a family meal. The staff handles brisket as confidently as ribeyes, and everything comes out with attention to detail.
The BBQ here shines in both texture and flavor. The smoked half-chicken is my top choice: juicy with a whisper of char, and never bland. Their sides, especially the house-made baked beans, reinforce the grill’s reputation for hearty eats.
Try one of their platters for a balanced BBQ meal, or mix it up with a grilled veggie medley. The Chophouse Grille brings a refined edge to Mahopac barbecue without losing that essential, down-to-earth warmth.
5. Northern Smoke
(845) 669-8600Call
Northern Smoke may be tucked away in Carmel, but it’s well within reach for Mahopac BBQ lovers in search of something a bit different. You feel the passion for the craft here, from the cozy, wood-accented décor to the aroma wafting from the kitchen. My meal started with that unmistakable scent of slow-cooked meat—a good sign.
The secret to Northern Smoke’s appeal is their small-batch approach, focusing on quality over quantity. The smoked chicken has a robust flavor but remains tender, never dry. The brisket is another highlight, sliced thick and edged with just the right amount of bark.
Definitely try the sampler plate, which lets you explore several of their specialties in one go. Pair it with their creamy coleslaw and you’ll find why Northern Smoke often tops BBQ lists around Mahopac.
6. Home & Hearth
Home & Hearth isn’t your typical BBQ restaurant—it’s a destination for those who want to bring the BBQ magic home. The shop’s legacy spans decades, with friendly expertise from a team that knows grills inside and out. My first walk inside was a tour of gleaming smokers and innovative gadgets, all sparking ideas for my next backyard cookout.
What makes Home & Hearth unique is their range: from traditional wood smokers to sleek, modern grills. They offer guidance if you’re looking to elevate your own BBQ game in Mahopac or beyond.
If you’re serious about authentic, home-cooked BBQ, ask for their recommendations on hardwoods and grill accessories. Their selections make even a simple Sunday feel special. Home & Hearth is where BBQ enthusiasts get inspired.
7. Bob*B*Q’s
Bob*B*Q’s is a local favorite, best known for its friendly, family-run energy and the unmistakable smell of real wood smoke drifting through Shrub Oak. What sets Bob*B*Q’s apart is its focus on honest ingredients and time-honored BBQ traditions. I remember parking out front and seeing the steady stream of regulars—a good sign before even tasting a bite.
The menu is all about generous, satisfying portions. The pulled chicken is a standout, loaded into a sandwich or heaped high on a platter. Classic sides like baked beans and fries round out the meal perfectly.
If you want a quick, no-nonsense BBQ meal near Mahopac, order the chicken platter or sampler for the best they offer. Bob*B*Q’s makes barbecue that feels like home.
8. Sticky Fingers Smokehouse
Sticky Fingers Smokehouse draws barbecue fans from all over Westchester, and once you step inside, you’ll know why. There’s a playful vibe here—casual, welcoming, and packed with the aroma of smoky meats slow-roasting in the back. My first taste of their pulled chicken was enough to make me a believer.
The heart of Sticky Fingers lies in its commitment to authentic smokehouse style, with meats cooked low and slow for maximum flavor. The chicken is always juicy and well-seasoned, while their vegetarian sides keep everyone at the table happy.
Order the smoked chicken sandwich or try the BBQ sampler if you want to compare different specialties. Sticky Fingers is a reliable spot for consistent, crave-worthy barbecue near Mahopac.
9. Diego’s Deli BBQ
(914) 743-1679Call
Diego’s Deli BBQ is one of those places where the line between deli classics and barbecue favorites gets deliciously blurred. The counter is lined with regulars catching up with staff, and the menu feels both familiar and full of surprises. Every visit feels like discovering a new favorite, thanks to their creative menu.
What sets Diego’s apart is the fusion of classic deli know-how with true BBQ flavor. The smoked chicken, piled onto a fresh roll, is tender and spiced just right. Sides come in deli style—hearty, homemade, and always satisfying.
For the best of both worlds, order a BBQ combo sandwich stacked with sliced smoked chicken and their signature slaw. Diego’s Deli BBQ delivers comfort with a smoky twist, making it a unique stop near Mahopac.
10. Kelly’s Corner
(845) 278-4297Call
Kelly’s Corner feels like stepping into a welcoming neighborhood spot where everyone really does know your name. The setting is cozy, and there’s an unmistakable community vibe that keeps people coming back. Each meal I’ve had here has felt like sharing food among friends.
This place stands out for its honest, satisfying take on American comfort food—plus a menu that gives proper respect to BBQ classics. The grilled chicken platter is a must-order: bold flavors, generous portions, and all the traditional fixings on the side.
Try the BBQ chicken sandwich if you’re after something handheld and hearty, or dig into their combo plate to sample a bit of everything. At Kelly’s Corner, quality and comfort come first with every bite.
More Things to Try in Mahopac, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best BBQ restaurants in Mahopac, NY?
Some top picks include Holy Smoke, The Chophouse Grille, and Johnny D’s BBQ and Burgers. Each offers their own spin on classic BBQ, from smokehouse platters to juicy pulled chicken sandwiches.
Are there any BBQ places in Mahopac that offer halal options?
A few BBQ spots, such as Holy Smoke, often update their menu and may offer halal-friendly dishes. Call ahead for the latest options and preparation details.
Can I find vegetarian sides at Mahopac BBQ restaurants?
Most Mahopac BBQ spots offer vegetarian-friendly sides like coleslaw, fries, baked beans, and grilled veggies.
Which BBQ spot in Mahopac is good for families?
BobBQ’s and Kelly’s Corner both have laid-back settings and generous portions that work well for families.
Is takeout available at Mahopac BBQ joints?
Yes, most BBQ restaurants in Mahopac offer takeout, making it easy to enjoy your favorites at home.
Where can I get BBQ catering in Mahopac?
Several restaurants, including Johnny D’s BBQ and The Chophouse Grille, offer catering for parties and events—perfect for feeding a crowd with smoky, barbecue flavor.