Hunting for the best BBQ in Hurley, NY is a quest that requires both patience and a healthy appetite. This is the kind of small town where smoke hangs in the air on weekends, and the locals are often caught debating the merits of slow-cooked brisket versus tangy pulled chicken. I still remember stepping out of my car one early evening to the scent of oak and hickory curling through the air—every corner seemed to guard its own secret recipe.
It became clear that finding unforgettable barbecue here isn’t about chasing hype. It’s about trusting your nose, listening to trusted recommendations, and being open to a few surprises. With so many options tucked along scenic backroads and friendly main streets, you’re bound to wonder which spot nails the perfect balance of smoky flavor and authentic sides. That’s exactly what this guide is about—sorting through the choices to bring you the essential list of BBQ joints in Hurley, NY, so you can focus on memorable meals, not second guesses.
Where to find the best bbq in Hurley, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Hurley, NY:
- Chops Grille
- Texas Roadhouse
- ALL SMOKED OUT BBQ
- Broadway Joe’s
- Hickory BBQ Smokehouse
- Bistro To Go
- Ole Savannah
- Armadillo Bar & Grill
- Brotherly Grub BBQ
- Sabroso
1. Chops Grille
Chops Grille on John Street is where classic comfort gets an upgrade. The space strikes a balance between relaxed and refined, perfect for a casual meal or something with a little more energy. When I stopped in, the scent of slow-smoked meats reached me before the menu did—that’s always a good sign.
What sets Chops Grille apart is their approach to BBQ. The brisket comes tender with just the right amount of smoke, and the pulled chicken never disappoints. Sides like coleslaw and cornbread are done with a homemade touch, elevating the plate.
For a first visit, try the BBQ platter. It shows off everything they do well—smoky, flavorful, and no shortcuts. Chops Grille feels both familiar and special, which isn’t always an easy trick to pull off.
2. Texas Roadhouse
Texas Roadhouse in Kingston isn’t just about steaks—even though they nail those, too. The place hums with energy, from the jukebox to the friendly servers who seem to remember everyone. Every visit of mine was marked by laughter and the irresistible aroma of BBQ mingling with fresh-baked bread.
The standout here has to be their fall-off-the-bone ribs. Smoked until tender and brushed with just enough sauce, they’re everything barbecue should be. Their made-from-scratch sides—think seasoned corn or crisp salads—make it a full-on comfort meal.
If you’re new, order the ribs with a side of buttery corn. It’s the classic Roadhouse experience, warm and filling with a hit of smoky flavor. No detail is overlooked, which is why diners keep coming back.
3. ALL SMOKED OUT BBQ
(845) 383-1137Call
Walking up to ALL SMOKED OUT BBQ, you’ll spot the smokers working overtime right out front—always a good sign. This spot has a down-to-earth vibe that keeps things simple and focused on flavor. My first try here involved a plate loaded with pulled chicken and classic sides, and it set the bar high for comfort food.
What puts ALL SMOKED OUT BBQ ahead is how every bite tastes genuinely homemade. The pulled chicken is juicy, perfectly seasoned, and piled high. Their house sauce manages to be tangy without overpowering the smoke, striking a nice balance.
Order the BBQ chicken plate with coleslaw and cornbread. This combo lets you experience their signature style—straightforward, hearty, and deeply satisfying. If you love simple barbecue done well, this is the spot.
4. Broadway Joe’s
(845) 340-7912Call
Broadway Joe’s welcomes you with a laid-back, local feel—the sort of spot where regulars chat with staff and newcomers get the same treatment. It’s a neighborhood BBQ joint that doesn’t try too hard but never misses the mark. On my first visit, the smell of spice-laden barbecue and sizzling grills filled the air and immediately set the right mood.
What makes Broadway Joe’s special is their knack for creating smoky, flavorful dishes that keep things classic. Their barbecued chicken is tender and full of that deep, satisfying smoke, exactly what you want from real BBQ. Pair it with house-made sides and you’ve got comfort by the forkful.
If it’s your first trip, start with the BBQ chicken platter. It shows off their strengths—generous portions, balanced seasoning, and an inviting, familiar atmosphere that turns first-timers into repeat customers.
5. Hickory BBQ Smokehouse
Hickory BBQ Smokehouse is where barbecue meets cozy comfort on Route 28. The rustic vibe paired with the constant aroma of smoked wood makes it a local favorite. My meal here started with perfectly crisp onion rings, and from that first bite, I knew this place was serious about flavor.
What truly elevates Hickory BBQ Smokehouse is the tenderness of their slow-cooked meats. The turkey and ribs are both standouts—moist, smoky, and rich without being heavy. Each dish comes with hearty sides like mashed potatoes or seasoned red beans, rounding out a meal that feels both generous and thoughtful.
For the full experience, go for the BBQ turkey platter with sweet potato pie on the side. It’s comfort food, smokehouse-style, and it tastes even better after a day exploring the Catskills.
6. Bistro To Go
Bistro To Go feels like the best secret on Route 28 for those craving both convenience and real flavor. The menu surprises you with home-cooked comfort and a clear focus on quality ingredients. My first stop here was meant to be quick, but the barbecue plates kept me lingering longer.
This spot stands out by blending local sourcing with a chef’s creativity—think wholesome sides and vegetables alongside slow-cooked meats. The pulled chicken is juicy, smoky, and balanced by their bright coleslaw. Even the cornbread serves as a warm invitation to stay awhile.
Order the BBQ chicken or brisket with local seasonal sides. You get full-on comfort food with a touch of finesse, perfect for either grabbing to go or enjoying on their patio.
7. Ole Savannah
Ole Savannah sits right on the waterfront, and it draws you in with a promise of Southern flavors and a relaxed view of the river. The space has that easy charm—modern but rooted in barbecue tradition. My evening here was marked by friendly service and plates that spoke to true Southern hospitality.
What distinguishes Ole Savannah is their unique balance: classic barbecue meets creative sides and fresh ingredients. The smoked chicken is always juicy, kissed with just the right amount of hickory. Sides like collard greens and roasted sweet potatoes keep things vibrant and never heavy.
Start with the smoked chicken platter and a side of collards. It’s a perfect introduction to their approach—full of flavor and a little lighter than you’d expect, all the while staying true to Southern roots.
8. Armadillo Bar & Grill
Armadillo Bar & Grill blends vibrant Mexican flavors with a relaxed Kingston edge. It’s small, welcoming, and every corner feels full of personality. My visit was spent out on the flower-filled patio, where the smell of grilled vegetables and smoky spices hung in the air.
This spot shines thanks to its scratch-made approach; even the chips and salsa are prepped fresh daily. The grilled chicken, whether in a fajita or a platter, comes juicy and laced with just the right hint of smoke. Vegetarian and gluten-free diners have plenty of options here, too.
Don’t miss the BBQ chicken fajitas—they showcase Armadillo’s signature mix of spice and smoke, making it a must-try for anyone craving something a little outside the traditional BBQ box.
9. Brotherly Grub BBQ
Brotherly Grub BBQ in Tillson delivers a down-home charm that sticks with you. The place feels like a backyard gathering, right down to the friendly faces and the rolling smoke from the pit. My first taste of their BBQ chicken instantly set the bar—tender, spot-on with the smoke, and seasoned without being overwhelmed by sauce.
What sets Brotherly Grub apart is their commitment to classic techniques and generous portions. The BBQ platters showcase meats that are cooked low and slow for hours, resulting in deep flavor and a perfect texture. Sides like slaw and baked beans round out a memorable meal.
If you’re indecisive, order the BBQ chicken plate with beans and slaw. It’s simple, honest barbecue served up with real hospitality, just as it should be.
10. Sabroso
(845) 876-8688Call
Sabroso adds a Latin-inspired twist to the barbecue scene, nestled quietly in Rhinebeck. The atmosphere combines warmth with a hint of spice—much like the food itself. My first encounter here was memorable for the smoky aromas drifting from the kitchen and the vibrant colors on each plate.
Sabroso stands out through its bold approach to seasoning and fresh ingredients. The BBQ chicken is especially juicy and well-marinated, striking the right balance between tang and smoke. Their signature house sauce elevates every bite.
Order the chicken BBQ platter with rice and beans to get the full effect of Sabroso’s style: familiar comfort food, but with a delicious Latin kick that sets it apart from the usual BBQ offerings.
More Things to Try in Hurley, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular BBQ dishes in Hurley, NY?
The BBQ favorites around Hurley include smoked chicken, beef brisket, and pulled chicken. Many places also feature classic sides like coleslaw, cornbread, baked beans, and seasoned vegetables.
Are there BBQ restaurants in Hurley, NY that offer takeout or catering?
Yes, several local spots such as Bistro To Go and Hickory BBQ Smokehouse offer takeout. Full-service catering is also available at select locations for parties and special events.
Can I find vegetarian options at BBQ restaurants near Hurley, NY?
Absolutely. Many places, such as Armadillo Bar & Grill and Bistro To Go, have sides and main dishes that are suitable for vegetarians. Always check the menu or call ahead to be sure.
What’s the atmosphere like at BBQ spots in Hurley, NY?
Most BBQ joints in this area are casual, friendly, and welcoming. You’ll find everything from cozy porch seating to vibrant waterfront views, depending on the spot you choose.
Do BBQ restaurants in Hurley, NY use halal ingredients?
It’s best to call the restaurant directly to ask about specific halal options, as offerings vary by location.