Finding great BBQ in Holtsville, NY is like seeking out that smoky scent drifting from a neighbor’s backyard—it catches your attention and curiosity in equal measure. Whether you dream of ribs that fall off the bone or brisket with just the right amount of char, this town has you covered. After countless forks and napkins, I’ve explored Holtsville’s BBQ landscape and tasted my way through the standouts.
Every spot on this list brings something unique to the table, from classic smokehouses with deep local roots to hidden gems that surprise you with bold flavors. Whether you’re just passing through or a local on a quest for the area’s top barbecue, you’ll find plenty to get excited about. Let’s dig into Holtsville’s best BBQ experiences—your next favorite meal might be closer than you think.
Where to find the best bbq in Holtsville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Holtsville, NY:
- Thristy Scholar
- Village Pub
- Karvers Grille
- BBQ Stews Inc
- El Capitan Sports Bar
- L I Wings-N-Things
- Outback Steakhouse
- The Propane Guys
- BobbiQue
- Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill
1. Thristy Scholar
(631) 648-9454Call
Thristy Scholar manages a cozy blend of laid-back bar energy and true BBQ flavor. My first visit came after a friend raved about their smoked wings, and the hype felt justified from the first bite. The wings arrive crisp at the edges and smoky through the core—a rare combo.
The vibe is friendly yet lively, perfect for lingering over a platter. Thristy Scholar’s standout is their BBQ chicken sandwich, packed with the right amount of sauce and crunch. Their pulled chicken also gets plenty of local praise, with a subtle smoke that doesn’t overpower.
If you want classic BBQ done right without any fuss, start here. The food and atmosphere make it worth sitting down and digging in.
2. Village Pub
(631) 880-7099Call
Village Pub is the kind of place where the aroma of the grill travels right out to the parking lot. I remember ducking in one rainy afternoon and finding the atmosphere as warm as the food. Their BBQ chicken wrap is a must—juicy, smoky, and wrapped up with just enough sauce to keep you wanting more.
This spot stands out for mixing classic pub comfort with solid BBQ options. Regulars linger over ribs, while newcomers quickly gravitate to the char-grilled chicken platters. Each bite balances flavor and tenderness, offering something for everyone.
If you like your barbecue with a side of lively conversation or a game on the screen, Village Pub is worth a visit. It feels like a local secret that’s hiding in plain sight.
3. Karvers Grille
Karvers Grille feels like a spot where you could settle in for hours, surrounded by the scent of smoked meat and chatter from the bar. My first outing here was on a casual Thursday, where the steady buzz made it easy to relax. The staff made each guest feel like a regular, even if it was your first visit.
This place earns its reputation for offering BBQ that’s both flavorful and consistent. The star of the menu has to be their smoked BBQ chicken plate, which strikes just the right note between juicy and smoky. The sides—especially the crisp slaw—round out the meal without stealing the show.
If you’re searching for a go-to BBQ spot that’s a true all-rounder, Karvers Grille won’t steer you wrong. Their approach is classic, but the flavors always stand out.
4. BBQ Stews Inc
BBQ Stews Inc brings big smokehouse flavor right to your home or event. The first time I tried their catering, it was for a family get-together that needed a real crowd-pleaser. Their dishes arrived piping hot, with aromas that had everyone drifting toward the serving table early.
This caterer sets itself apart by making every bite taste like backyard BBQ done right. The highlight was their pulled chicken, which was moist and packed with smokiness. Their BBQ platters come loaded with classic sides, all made with a homemade touch that lifts the meal.
BBQ Stews Inc is ideal for anyone hosting guests who expect real BBQ comfort food—delivered fast and always flavorful. You’ll want seconds, so plan accordingly.
5. El Capitan Sports Bar
(631) 289-1999Call
El Capitan Sports Bar is the type of place where barbecue meets game-day excitement. I came here during the playoffs, grabbed a seat near the TV, and quickly noticed the steady parade of BBQ coming from the kitchen. The staff keeps things cheerful, and you never feel rushed—even when it’s busy.
If you’re searching for a standout, try their BBQ grilled chicken. The meat is smoky, tender, and comes slathered in a tangy sauce that pairs perfectly with crisp fries. For sharing, their chicken platter makes for a hefty meal between friends watching the action on screen.
El Capitan stands out for making BBQ feel fun and relaxed, blending bold flavors with a lively setting. It’s where sports and smoke both take center stage.
6. L I Wings-N-Things
L I Wings-N-Things brings together quick service and bold barbecue flavors in a way that’s hard to resist. My go-to move here is to grab a big order of their grilled BBQ wings, perfect for when you crave serious smoke without the wait. Each wing has a crisp skin and a touch of sweetness from the sauce, making them stand out from the usual fast food fare.
This spot is perfect when you want BBQ on the fly but don’t want to sacrifice quality. The menu covers more than wings—try their BBQ chicken platter for something a bit heartier, served up with your choice of sides.
L I Wings-N-Things is where big flavor and convenience share center stage. It’s reliable, satisfying, and never skimps on taste.
7. Outback Steakhouse
Outback Steakhouse might be best known for their steaks, but their approach to BBQ flavors deserves some spotlight. The first time I stopped by, I aimed for something off the grill and was met with smoky aromas drifting from the open kitchen. The staff made sure every detail felt thoughtful, adding to the laid-back charm.
What sets Outback apart is their Wood-Fire Grilled Chicken. It’s juicy and kissed with just the right amount of smoke, capturing the spirit of barbecue in a polished package. The grilled chicken platter also gets high marks for consistency and generous sides.
If you’re craving BBQ flavor in a relaxed, family-friendly setting, Outback delivers the goods. The experience always feels a notch above your typical chain.
8. The Propane Guys
The Propane Guys is where every backyard BBQ gets its boost. My first visit was for a quick propane tank refill, but I ended up browsing their impressive range of barbecue grills and supplies. The staff was eager to help, sharing tips on getting the most out of my grill at home.
The standout here isn’t a dish but the gear that ensures your home-cooked BBQ turns out just right. Their selection of grills suits everyone from barbecue newbies to seasoned pitmasters. Accessories, from tongs to smoking chips, give plenty of ways to refine your technique.
If you’re looking to step up your BBQ game in Holtsville, The Propane Guys is the first stop. Local advice and quality supplies make all the difference.
9. BobbiQue
BobbiQue is the kind of BBQ joint where the soundtrack and slow-cooked aromas make you want to stay awhile. My first plate of their St. Louis-style ribs set the bar high—the bark had the right amount of bite, and the smoke flavor hit every note. Grab extra napkins, because the experience gets satisfyingly messy fast.
The relaxed, music-filled vibe makes every meal feel like a neighborhood hangout. BobbiQue’s dedication to authentic pit barbecue comes through in every dish, but the pulled chicken deserves a special mention for its tenderness and depth of flavor.
If you’re searching for a spot where BBQ is treated like an art form, BobbiQue delivers with flair. Go for the ribs or pulled chicken—you’ll understand why locals rave.
10. Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill
Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill has a talent for drawing you in with the subtle scent of smoke before you even reach the door. On my first visit, the energy felt equal parts lively and welcoming, setting the perfect scene for a BBQ feast. The large, bustling dining room is as inviting as the aroma from the kitchen.
What sets them apart is their BBQ chicken, which arrives juicy and beautifully glazed, with a smoke flavor that’s never overpowering. Their grilled chicken platter is a safe bet when you want big portions and sides that don’t feel like an afterthought.
If you’re after a casual spot to satisfy a BBQ craving, Smokey Bones delivers. Generous servings and reliable quality keep people coming back for more.
More Things to Try in Holtsville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some top BBQ spots in Holtsville, NY?
Popular options include BobbiQue, Karvers Grille, Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill, and Outback Steakhouse. Each brings its own flavor and style, whether you prefer classic pit smoke or modern twists on barbecue dishes.
Are there BBQ options suitable for families?
Absolutely. Restaurants like Outback Steakhouse and Karvers Grille offer welcoming atmospheres and kid-friendly menus. Many spots provide high chairs and group seating.
Can I find BBQ catering in Holtsville?
Yes—BBQ Stews Inc specializes in catering, providing smoked favorites and satisfying sides perfect for parties or family gatherings.
What are popular BBQ dishes to try?
Locals flock to BBQ chicken platters, smoked wings, and St. Louis-style ribs. Pulled chicken and flavorful sides round out great barbecue experiences in the area.
Are there BBQ restaurants with vegetarian options?
Many spots, such as Karvers Grille and Outback Steakhouse, offer salads and veggie-based sides so you can enjoy the atmosphere even if you’re not eating meat.