BBQ cravings hit differently in Holbrook, NY, where local spots share smoke-filled secrets and lively stories. If you’ve ever followed the scent of smoldering wood through the streets, you know that finding the right barbecue is more than just chasing flavor; it’s about discovering the character behind each grill. I’ve had my fair share of brisket adventures here—lean cuts, juicy bites, and the gentle char that makes each meal an experience.
Each spot on this list is about more than food. It’s that mix of friendly chatter, the way sauce sticks to ribs, and the easy feeling of eating slow with friends or family. Whether you’re after classic ribs, inventive sides, or smoky wings, Holbrook delivers a BBQ tour worth savoring. If you’re hoping to skip the guesswork and head straight for the best, this guide brings you right to the grill, one hot spot at a time.
Where to find the best bbq in Holbrook, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Holbrook, NY:
- Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill
- Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck
- Thristy Scholar
- BBQ Stews Inc
- Just Wing It
- Karvers Grille
- Outback Steakhouse
- The Propane Guys
- Island Outdoor, LLC
- Choopan Grill
1. Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill
Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill sits just off Express Drive in Ronkonkoma, making it a favorite local stop for those serious about their BBQ. Walk inside and you’re hit with the gentle aroma of hickory, which signals good things ahead. The atmosphere combines a laid-back vibe with a classic grillhouse energy—think friendly staff, big booths, and the right level of noise.
Their standout dishes are the slow-smoked brisket and juicy turkey, which carry an unmistakable, deep smokiness that’s hard to find elsewhere in Holbrook. The ribs come glazed and just tender enough, always drawing me back. Pair these with a side of fire-roasted corn or their BBQ beans for a meal that feels both comforting and well-crafted.
Stop in with friends or family and let each plate speak for itself. Smokey Bones makes the kind of BBQ memories you remember long after dessert.
2. Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck
If you catch the Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck parked in Ronkonkoma, you’re in for something special. This isn’t your average food truck; the smoky aroma draws crowds from neighboring blocks. The BBQ ribs and smoked turkey here have a rich, slow-cooked flavor that grabs your attention from the first bite.
The menu travels across BBQ favorites, but you can’t go wrong with their brisket sandwich—it’s packed, tender, and has that right touch of char. The cornbread is soft, a touch sweet, and perfectly completes the meal.
There’s something memorable about eating great barbecue right from a truck window. Rolling Smoke’s easy warmth and homemade care make every order a little celebration on wheels.
3. Thristy Scholar
(631) 648-9454Call
Thristy Scholar is tucked along Union Ave and draws a friendly crowd with its easy-going bar-and-grill atmosphere. Walking inside, you get a sense of comfort—no fuss, just good times and the smell of the grill keeping things lively. The BBQ wings here are simply addictive, with a smoky glaze that keeps you reaching for just one more.
If you’re new, start with the pulled chicken sandwich. It’s juicy, has just the right kick of flavor, and gets even better with their house-made slaw. The sides—crisp fries and crunchy pickles—round everything off.
This is the type of place where simple BBQ classics are done right. Thristy Scholar turns every casual meal into a reason to linger just a bit longer.
4. BBQ Stews Inc
BBQ Stews Inc on Main Street is a quiet favorite for anyone after home-style barbecue and stress-free catering. What makes them different is their focus on off-premise events, so you can enjoy authentic BBQ wherever the party happens. The smoked chicken and pulled turkey trays are top choices, each promising tender bites and robust flavor that stands up at any gathering.
I’ve seen skeptical guests become instant fans after a taste of their slow-cooked meats. Their classic sides—especially the mac and cheese—pair perfectly and always disappear first.
BBQ Stews Inc brings a sense of comfort and simplicity to the table. It’s honest food, well-made, and perfect for sharing with a hungry crowd.
5. Just Wing It
(631) 676-7400Call
Just Wing It, tucked off Portion Road, is a go-to for anyone craving wings done right. Walk in during game night, and the energy is contagious—locals cheering, plates clattering, and the unmistakable aroma of barbecue in the air. The BBQ wings steal the show here, crisped at the edges and coated in a smoky, tangy sauce.
If you want variety, try their grilled chicken sandwiches. Each bite stacks tender chicken with fresh toppings, always served on a soft bun. Their sides, like the seasoned fries, round out a satisfying meal without overcomplicating things.
Just Wing It has a knack for BBQ comfort food. The staff keeps things light and friendly, making it a spot where you’ll feel right at home after the first order.
6. Karvers Grille
Karvers Grille on Patchogue Holbrook Road brings together the best of a lively bar and grill with a menu full of barbecue comfort. The wood-paneled décor and bustling vibe make it easy to get comfortable, whether you’re there for lunch or a late dinner. The smoked brisket platter stands out: tender, full of flavor, with that signature smoky edge that true BBQ fans appreciate.
If you’re in a sharing mood, the pulled chicken sliders are worth a try. The house barbecue sauce is bold but balanced, bringing out the best in every bite. Sides like coleslaw and seasoned fries add the perfect finish.
The staff’s easy conversation and the relaxed setting at Karvers make every visit memorable. This spot is proof that Holbrook does casual BBQ with real style.
7. Outback Steakhouse
Outback Steakhouse, just off Main Street in Holbrook, is more than its name suggests. While famous for juicy steaks, it delivers a smoky barbecue experience with genuine Aussie hospitality. The space buzzes with families and big groups, creating an easygoing backdrop for hearty meals.
The Outback’s grilled chicken and baby back ribs offer a taste of their BBQ choices. Both arrive perfectly glazed, with a balance of tang and smoke that always feels satisfying. The chicken is especially moist, served with lively sides like fresh vegetables or seasoned fries.
For those craving a traditional BBQ fix in a steakhouse setting, Outback ties it together with generous portions and unfussy service. There’s comfort in every bite, making it a steady contender on Holbrook’s BBQ map.
8. The Propane Guys
The Propane Guys on Main Street are a quiet powerhouse in Holbrook’s BBQ scene—even if they aren’t serving meals. They’re the go-to shop for anyone serious about backyard barbecue. My best steaks and smoky grilled chicken started with a refill here, and the staff always shares tips that make a real difference.
Come here for quality propane, new barbecue grills, or essential supplies. They stock a surprising range, from tongs to heavy-duty covers, making it easy to upgrade your grill setup. The customer service is quick and friendly, never pushy.
The Propane Guys help make backyard cookouts possible. With their top-notch supplies, you can bring Holbrook’s smoky, savory BBQ right to your own patio.
9. Island Outdoor, LLC
Island Outdoor, LLC, tucked along Portion Road, is the quiet toolkit behind many great barbecue setups in Holbrook. Step inside and you’ll find a shop filled with serious BBQ equipment and hard-to-find parts. Their line of gaskets and grill supplies can turn even an aging smoker into the highlight of your backyard.
While they don’t serve food, I’ve relied on them any time my grill needed a tune-up or a new accessory. The staff knows the ins and outs of every product, offering guidance that’s actually useful. Whether you’re eyeing a new grill or just picking up replacement parts, they have you covered.
Island Outdoor, LLC is the spot where Holbrook’s home grillers level up—making sure every weekend cookout goes off without a hitch.
10. Choopan Grill
(631) 696-1817Call
Choopan Grill in Selden brings a unique twist to the BBQ scene close to Holbrook. Step inside and there’s a welcoming energy—plenty of regulars, steady conversation, and the enticing smell of grilled meats. Kabobs and marinated grilled chicken are real standouts here, blending BBQ tradition with flavors you won’t find elsewhere in the area.
The rice and salad that come with each platter make for a well-balanced, hearty meal. The lamb kabob, in particular, is succulent and seasoned just right, while the chicken is always juicy and charred at the edges.
Choopan Grill offers something different from the classic American BBQ, but excels with careful preparation and hospitality. It’s a spot that makes you want to linger over every bite.
More Things to Try in Holbrook, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top BBQ spots in Holbrook, NY?
Holbrook’s best choices range from Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill and Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck to local-favorite Karvers Grille. Each has its own style—from classic smoked meats to inventive sides.
Are there any BBQ restaurants in Holbrook with halal options?
A few places, such as Choopan Grill, offer a range of grilled meats that may meet specific dietary needs. Always check with each restaurant directly for the most up-to-date menu information.
Where can I get BBQ catering in Holbrook?
For events, BBQ Stews Inc and Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck both provide catering options that bring genuine BBQ to your gathering.
Which BBQ spot is best for families?
Spots like Outback Steakhouse and Karvers Grille have ample seating and kid-friendly menus, making them great for family outings.
Do any local BBQ spots offer vegetarian options?
While BBQ is meat-focused, some places feature sides like baked beans, mac and cheese, and salads. Ask about vegetarian-friendly menu items before visiting.
