Best BBQ in Finger Lakes, NY

The Finger Lakes in New York is a true gem. I’ve explored its beautiful landscapes and amazing food scene. But let’s talk BBQ. This place has some of the best barbecue I’ve ever tasted. I can’t wait to share my favorites with you.

So, what’s the best BBQ in Finger Lakes, NY? It’s a mix of places serving up mouthwatering smoked meats and tasty sides. You’ll find lots of choices. Each spot has its own special flavors and a unique vibe. It’s a BBQ lover’s paradise!

Get ready! I’m about to take you on a delicious journey. You’ll learn about my top picks. Each one will surprise you in its own way. Trust me, you don’t want to miss this!

Top 10 BBQ in Finger Lakes, NY

1. Smokin Petes Barbecue
2. Nickel’s Pit BBQ Watkins Glen
3. Between the Lakes BBQ
4. The Rusty Pig
5. 3 Legged Pig BBQ Real Pit BBQ
6. State Bakery + BBQ
7. Lake Bistro formerly known as Lake BBQ
8. PriseBox BBQ
9. Finger Lakes Plates
10. Smoke & Dough

1. Smokin Petes Barbecue

Smokin’ Pete’s Barbecue is a gem in Geneva, NY. It’s in a nice spot on W Lake Rd. I love that they have both indoor and outdoor seating. It’s super cozy and laid-back.

When I walked in, the smell of smoke hit me right away. It was amazing! The staff was so friendly. They made me feel welcome. I could tell they really cared about the food.

What I truly love about Smokin’ Pete’s is their flavor. Every bite of their meat is juicy and packed with taste. I can’t recommend the pulled pork sandwich enough. It’s a total winner! And you have to get the mac and cheese. It’s creamy and delicious. Trust me, you won’t regret it!

2. Nickel’s Pit BBQ Watkins Glen

Nickel’s Pit BBQ in Watkins Glen is a blast. It’s right on N Franklin St in a cool, old building. The vibe is super lively. You can sit inside or outside, and there’s always live music.

I had an awesome time there. The place was buzzing with energy, and the BBQ smell was irresistible. I loved chilling on the patio, enjoying the sun and the food.

What sets Nickel’s Pit BBQ apart is their fantastic flavors. Their ribs are a must-try! I’m talking about the St. Louis-style ribs. They’re juicy, tender, and smoky. You’ve got to pair them with the house-made cornbread. It’s a killer combo that shows off their BBQ skills!

3. Between the Lakes BBQ

Between the Lakes BBQ is such a cool spot in Romulus, NY. It’s right on NY-89. I love that you can eat inside or outside. If you’re busy, they also have takeout. Super convenient!

When I went, I was hit with the amazing smell of smoke. It felt so welcoming, and the vibe was awesome. I knew I was in for something special.

What really stands out at Between the Lakes BBQ is their flavors. The brisket is a must! You have to try the smoked brisket sandwich. It’s loaded, juicy, and so tasty. Don’t forget to get their homemade coleslaw too. It adds the perfect crunch and keeps it fresh! It’s a BBQ lover’s dream!

4. The Rusty Pig

The Rusty Pig in Geneva is such a delightful place. It’s on Seneca St. The vibe is cozy and rustic. Seriously, those ceilings and wall panels are cool. You can sit inside or outside. They even do reservations.

So, when I walked in, it felt super welcoming. The BBQ smell? Amazing. I grabbed a craft beer and chilled. Super relaxing.

What makes The Rusty Pig special? Their BBQ twist. You must try the pulled pork burger. It’s juicy and smoky. Pair it with their crispy sweet potato fries. Trust me, it’s a combo you’ll love.

5. 3 Legged Pig BBQ Real Pit BBQ

3 Legged Pig BBQ Real Pit BBQ is such a great spot in Lakeville. It’s on Rochester Rd, and you can feel the fun vibe as soon as you walk in. They have indoor and outdoor seating. If you’re in a hurry, they also do curbside pickup.

When I went there, I was really impressed. The smell of smoked meat hit me right away. The staff was super friendly, and I felt right at home.

What makes 3 Legged Pig stand out? Their real pit BBQ. I highly suggest getting the brisket platter. It’s so tender and flavorful. And don’t skip the baked beans. They’re sweet, smoky, and the perfect side. You’ll leave with a happy belly!

6. State Bakery + BBQ

State Bakery + BBQ in Newfield is a real treat. It’s a cozy spot that feels welcoming. You can sit inside or outside, which is nice. If you’re in a rush, they have takeout too. The entrance is also wheelchair accessible.

When I walked in, the smell of delicious BBQ hit me. It felt homely and warm, like a comfy hug. I knew I was in for something special.

What makes State Bakery + BBQ stand out? Their food is made with care. I really recommend the pulled pork sandwich. It’s super tender and packs a lot of flavor. And definitely try their cornbread. It’s sweet and perfect with the BBQ. You won’t be disappointed!

7. Lake Bistro formerly known as Lake BBQ

Lake Bistro is such a cozy place. It’s right on Main Street. You can’t miss it. The smell of BBQ hits you as you walk in. It feels warm and welcoming, like home.

The staff is super friendly. They make you feel special. You can sit inside or outside. The setup is really nice. It’s also wheelchair-friendly, which is great.

I tried the BBQ ribs, and wow! They were soft, smoky, and so tasty. The cornbread? Sweet and perfect. The mac and cheese? Just pure comfort.

If you’re in Livonia, stop by Lake Bistro. It’s not just food. It’s an experience. And trust me, you’ll leave happy.

8. PriseBox BBQ

PriseBox BBQ is such a fantastic spot in Watkins Glen. It’s right on NY-14. I love that you can choose to eat inside or outside. And if you’re in a hurry, they offer takeout too!

When I walked in, the smell of BBQ hit me. Everything felt warm and friendly. I couldn’t wait to dig in.

What really stands out at PriseBox BBQ? Their meats are super tender and packed with flavor. I ordered the brisket and ribs. Wow! The brisket just melted in my mouth. The ribs were smoky and so good.

If you go, definitely try the brisket. You’ll love it! And don’t forget some of their delicious sauce on the side. It’s the perfect touch!

9. Finger Lakes Plates

Finger Lakes Plates is such a cool spot in Canandaigua. It’s on S Main St, and it’s super affordable. You can sit inside or outside, depending on your mood. They even have curbside pickup and delivery if you’re in a hurry.

When I walked in, I felt right at home. The staff was nice and quick to help. The menu had so many tempting choices!

What sets Finger Lakes Plates apart? Their fun twist on BBQ. I tried the smoked chicken sandwich, and wow! It was juicy and flavorful. You have to get the house-made fries too. They’re crispy and perfect for dipping. It’s a great spot, and you’ll leave smiling!

10. Smoke & Dough

Smoke & Dough is a hidden gem. It’s in Himrod, right along NY-14. The place feels so welcoming. You can sit inside or out. They even do takeout, which is awesome.

The first time I went, I was blown away. I tried their pulled pork. Wow! It was smoky, juicy, and just perfect. The coleslaw? Tangy and crunchy. They go together so well.

You have to get the brisket. It’s rich and full of flavor. Seriously, it’s melt-in-your-mouth good. Everything is made with care. It’s that perfect mix of taste and quality.

Smoke & Dough is special. The food, the vibe—it’s just all great. You’ll keep coming back for more!

Map of BBQ in Finger Lakes, NY

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Restaurant	Price	Seating	Takeout	Delivery	Wheelchair	Reservation
Smokin Petes Barbecue	Moderate	Yes	–	No	Accessible	No
Nickel’s Pit BBQ Watkins Glen	Moderate	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	No
Between the Lakes BBQ	–	Yes	Yes	No	–	–
The Rusty Pig	Moderate	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	Yes
3 Legged Pig BBQ Real Pit BBQ	Moderate	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	No
State Bakery + BBQ	–	Yes	Yes	–	Accessible	No
Lake Bistro formerly known as Lake BBQ	–	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	–
PriseBox BBQ	–	Yes	Yes	No	Accessible	No
Finger Lakes Plates	Inexpensive	Yes	Yes	Yes	Accessible	Yes
Smoke & Dough	–	Yes	Yes	No	–	–

Frequently Asked Questions

• What are the best BBQ spots in Finger Lakes, NY?

• There are some awesome places! Smokin Petes Barbecue and Nickel’s Pit BBQ are must-tries. You’ll love them!

• Are there vegetarian options at Finger Lakes BBQ places?

• Yes, definitely! Many spots have great veggie sides. Coleslaw and grilled veggies are always good choices.

• Can I sit outside at BBQ restaurants in Finger Lakes?

• You sure can! Places like Smoke & Dough have lovely outdoor seating. It’s perfect for enjoying good weather.

• Is takeout available at BBQ joints in Finger Lakes?

• Absolutely! Most BBQ places offer takeout. Super handy if you want to eat at home.

• What should I try at Finger Lakes BBQ restaurants?

• You’ve got to try the pulled pork and brisket. They’re both so flavorful and delicious!

• Do any BBQ places in Finger Lakes offer catering?

• Yes, many of them do! FLX BBQ Company is great for catering events. They’ll make your gathering delicious.

• Can I get drinks at BBQ restaurants in Finger Lakes?

• For sure! Many spots, like Nickel’s Pit BBQ, serve beer and other drinks. It adds to the fun.

• What’s the price range at Finger Lakes BBQ spots?

• You’ll find a range of prices. Most meals are reasonable, usually between $10 and $30.

• Should I make reservations at BBQ restaurants?

• It’s a good idea! Some places accept reservations, especially for larger groups. Better safe than sorry!

• Are there family-friendly BBQ restaurants in Finger Lakes?

  • Oh yes! Many BBQ spots are great for families. They have a fun vibe for everyone to enjoy.