Eureka, California, is such a cool place for BBQ lovers like me! There are so many spots here that serve up delicious smoked meats and tasty sides. I’ve explored the local BBQ scene, and I’m excited to share my favorite places with you. Trust me, you’ll want to know where to go for the best bites in town!
So, what’s the best BBQ in Eureka, CA? Well, the best BBQ in Eureka, CA, is found at several amazing restaurants that really know how to smoke meat and whip up flavorful sauces. Some of my top picks include Sammy’s BBQ & Catering, Humboldt Smokehouse, and Porter Street BBQ. Each place has its own special twist on BBQ that you just have to try!
Get ready to dive into the best BBQ spots in Eureka! I’ll take you through each restaurant, sharing what makes them unique and why they’re worth a visit. Whether you’re craving tender brisket or mouthwatering ribs, I’ve got you covered!
Top 10 BBQ in Eureka, CA
- Sammy’s BBQ & Catering
- Porter Street BBQ of Eureka
- Humboldt Smokehouse
- Shamus T Bones
- Bayfront Restaurant
- Lost Coast Brewery & Cafe
- Pile High Deli
- Surfside Burger Shack
- A Taste of Bim | Caribbean Cuisine
- Applebee’s Grill + Bar
1. Sammy’s BBQ & Catering
Phone: (707) 443-4227
Menu: www.sammysbbqcatering.com
Directions: Open on Map
Oh wow, Sammy’s BBQ & Catering is just awesome! I remember the first time I walked in, and the smell of smoky goodness hit me right away. It felt so cozy inside, and I could choose to sit inside or outside, which is super nice. It’s a great spot to hang out with friends or family while enjoying some yummy food.
What makes Sammy’s really special is how tasty everything is! The meats are always super tender and full of flavor. You have to try the brisket—it’s so good and just melts in your mouth! And their homemade BBQ sauce? Wow, it adds the perfect touch!
If you want something different, definitely go for the pulled pork sandwich. It’s juicy and served on a soft bun, making it a perfect choice. Seriously, you’re gonna love it!
2. Porter Street BBQ of Eureka
Phone: (707) 443-1700
Menu: m.facebook.com
Directions: Open on Map
Porter Street BBQ of Eureka is such a cool spot! I remember the first time I went there, and I was so excited to dig into some BBQ. The place has a really chill vibe, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It’s perfect for enjoying a nice meal with friends while soaking up the sun.
What makes Porter Street BBQ super special is how tasty everything is! The meats are always juicy and full of flavor. You absolutely have to try their ribs—they’re so tender that they just fall off the bone! And the sauce? Oh man, it takes everything to the next level!
If you want something really yummy, go for the smoked chicken. It’s super juicy and packed with flavor. I promise, once you try it, you’ll want to come back again and again!
3. Humboldt Smokehouse
Phone: (707) 497-6261
Menu: www.humboldtsmokehouse.com
Directions: Open on Map
Humboldt Smokehouse is such a fun place to grab BBQ! I remember the first time I went there, and I just loved the cozy, casual feel of the place. It’s super nice because I could sit inside or outside, which is perfect for enjoying a sunny day with some yummy food.
What really makes Humboldt Smokehouse stand out is their amazing smoked meats. Everything is cooked so well, and you can really taste how fresh it is. You have to try their brisket—it’s so tender and full of flavor! And they have lots of different sauces, which is really cool because you can mix and match.
If you want something really tasty, definitely go for the pulled pork sandwich. It’s juicy and served on a soft bun, making it a perfect choice. I promise, once you try it, you’ll want to come back again and again!
4. Shamus T Bones
Shamus T Bones is such a fun place to eat BBQ! I remember the first time I went there, and it felt so cozy and welcoming, like a little country hideaway. The vibe is super relaxed, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It’s a perfect spot to chill out and enjoy some yummy food with friends.
What really makes Shamus T Bones stand out is their awesome menu. They have everything from grilled steaks to pit-smoked BBQ and tasty burgers. You absolutely have to try their smoked ribs—they’re so tender and full of flavor! And the BBQ sauce? Oh wow, it’s just the right amount of sweet and tangy.
If you’re really hungry, go for the BBQ burger. It’s juicy and piled high with all the good toppings. I promise, you’ll leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
5. Bayfront Restaurant
Bayfront Restaurant is such a cool place to eat! I remember the first time I went there, and I was super excited to try their sushi. The atmosphere is really nice, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It’s perfect for enjoying the pretty view while munching on delicious food.
What makes Bayfront Restaurant stand out is their fresh sushi and fun teppanyaki. Everything is so tasty! You have to try their California roll—it’s packed with yummy flavors and always fresh. And if you want a show, the teppanyaki is really fun to watch!
If you’re in the mood for something crispy, definitely order the shrimp tempura. It’s so crunchy and delicious! I promise, you’ll have a great time and leave with a big smile!
6. Lost Coast Brewery & Cafe
Lost Coast Brewery & Cafe is such a cool place to chill! I remember the first time I walked in, and I was super excited to try their yummy food and drinks. The vibe is really relaxed, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It’s a perfect spot to hang out with friends and enjoy some tasty meals together.
What makes Lost Coast Brewery really special is their awesome house beers and classic American food. Everything is super fresh and delicious! You have to try their fish and chips—they’re so crispy and tasty! And their beers? Wow, they have a great selection that goes perfectly with the food.
If you’re really hungry, definitely order the BBQ pulled pork sandwich. It’s juicy and full of flavor. I promise, you’ll have a great time and leave with a big smile!
7. Pile High Deli
Phone: (707) 443-5362
Menu: pilehighdeli.toast.site
Directions: Open on Map
Pile High Deli is such a fun place to grab a bite! I remember the first time I walked in, and I was super excited to see all the yummy sandwiches. The vibe is really friendly, and I loved that I could either get my food to go or eat there. It’s a perfect spot for a quick lunch or a tasty snack.
What makes Pile High Deli really special is their giant sandwiches! They really pile on the ingredients, and everything is super fresh. You have to try their turkey club—it’s stacked high with juicy turkey, crispy bacon, and all the good stuff. It’s so tasty and filling!
If you’re looking for something different, definitely order the pastrami sandwich. It’s packed with flavor and always hits the spot. I promise, you’ll leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
8. Surfside Burger Shack
Surfside Burger Shack is such a fun place to grab a burger! I remember the first time I walked in, and I just loved the chill, surf-themed vibe. It felt so relaxed, and I could sit inside or outside, which is perfect for enjoying the nice weather while munching on some yummy food.
What really makes Surfside Burger Shack stand out is their grass-fed burgers and hand-cut fries. Everything is super fresh and tastes amazing! You have to try their classic cheeseburger—it’s juicy and full of flavor. And those fries? Oh wow, they’re crispy and so delicious!
If you’re looking for something fun, definitely order the hot dog. It’s tasty and always hits the spot. I promise, you’ll leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
9. A Taste of Bim | Caribbean Cuisine
A Taste of Bim | Caribbean Cuisine is such a fun place to eat! I remember the first time I walked in, and I was super excited to try all the yummy Caribbean food. The place has a bright and cheerful vibe, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It felt like a little piece of the islands right in Eureka!
What really makes A Taste of Bim special is their amazing flavors. They serve up authentic Caribbean dishes that are super tasty! You have to try their jerk chicken—it’s spicy and so full of flavor! And the cod fritters? Oh wow, they’re crispy and delicious!
If you’re looking for something really good, definitely order the curry goat. It’s tender and packed with spices that make your taste buds dance. I promise, you’ll leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
10. Applebee’s Grill + Bar
Phone: (707) 269-0533
Menu: restaurants.applebees.com
Directions: Open on Map
Applebee’s Grill + Bar is such a fun place to eat! I remember the first time I walked in, and I was super excited to check out their menu. The vibe is really casual, and I loved that I could sit inside or outside. It’s a perfect spot to hang out with friends and enjoy some yummy American food together.
What makes Applebee’s really special is their big variety of tasty dishes. There’s something for everyone! You have to try their riblets—they’re so tender and packed with flavor! And their classic cheeseburger? Oh wow, it’s juicy and always hits the spot.
If you’re looking for something fun to share, definitely order the boneless wings. They come with different sauces, and they’re perfect for munching with friends. I promise, you’ll leave with a big smile and a happy tummy!
Map of BBQ in Eureka, CA
Choosing the Right Restaurant for You
With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:
| Restaurant | Price | Seating | Takeout | Delivery | Wheelchair | Reservation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sammy’s BBQ & Catering | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Porter Street BBQ of Eureka | Moderate | Yes | Yes | No | Accessible | No |
| Humboldt Smokehouse | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Shamus T Bones | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Bayfront Restaurant | Moderate | Yes | Yes | No | Accessible | Yes |
| Lost Coast Brewery & Cafe | Moderate | Yes | Yes | No | Accessible | Yes |
| Pile High Deli | Moderate | – | Yes | No | Accessible | No |
| Surfside Burger Shack | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | No |
| A Taste of Bim | Caribbean Cuisine | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
| Applebee’s Grill + Bar | Moderate | Yes | Yes | Yes | Accessible | Yes |
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best BBQ restaurants in Eureka, CA?
Oh, there are some really great BBQ spots in Eureka! My favorites are Sammy’s BBQ & Catering, Humboldt Smokehouse, and Porter Street BBQ. Each place has its own yummy flavors that you just have to try!
2. Do these BBQ places offer takeout?
Yes, most of the BBQ restaurants here, like Sammy’s BBQ & Catering and Humboldt Smokehouse, totally offer takeout! It’s super easy to grab some delicious BBQ and enjoy it at home or wherever you want.
3. Are there vegetarian options at BBQ restaurants?
While BBQ places mostly focus on meat, some, like Humboldt Smokehouse, might have a few vegetarian sides or salads. It’s always a good idea to check the menu or just ask the staff!
4. Can I make reservations at BBQ restaurants in Eureka?
Yes, many BBQ spots, like Shamus T Bones and Applebee’s Grill + Bar, let you make reservations. This is really helpful if you want to make sure you get a table, especially when it’s busy!
5. Is outdoor seating available at BBQ spots?
Absolutely! Lots of BBQ restaurants in Eureka, like Porter Street BBQ and Surfside Burger Shack, have outdoor seating. It’s perfect for enjoying your meal in the nice fresh air!
