Nothing quite drifts through Elmira like the aroma of slow-cooked, smoky barbecue. This city isn’t just an unexpected BBQ stop—it’s a place where local spots create unforgettable, saucy legends on the daily. Whether you’re after perfectly charred ribs, smoky pulled chicken, or beef brisket so tender it barely holds together, Elmira quietly boasts more than a handful of places vying for the BBQ crown. Finding the best one could turn into a worthy weekend mission.
I once found myself weaving down Water Street with friends, lured by the promise of real pit barbecue. We ended up sharing plates piled high with smoked meats and sides you dream about later. In Elmira, genuine BBQ isn’t about flash or food show theatrics—it’s about time-honored recipes, skilled hands at the smoker, and a neighborhood vibe that’s hard to replicate. If you’re searching for the top BBQ spots in Elmira, NY, rest assured—you’re in for some mouthwatering discoveries.
Where to find the best bbq in Elmira, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Elmira, NY:
- The Sand Dollar Saloon & Grill
- Bernie Murray’s
- Champions Sports Grille
- Roundin Third
- Texas Roadhouse
- Braun’s Pour House
- Hickory House Restaurant
- Outback Steakhouse
- Callear’s R & R Bar-B-Que
- Slammin Jammin Southern Smoked BBQ
1. The Sand Dollar Saloon & Grill
(607) 732-4286Call
The Sand Dollar Saloon & Grill makes its mark with a laid-back vibe and big BBQ flavors. I first stopped in on a drizzly Saturday and was greeted by the welcome sizzle of the smoker out back. The space feels both local and lively, filled with regulars swapping stories between bites.
The ribs here are truly the main event—smoky, fall-off-the-bone, and lacquered in a tangy sauce that strikes the sweet-salty balance right. Pair them with their signature loaded fries and you’ll see why locals become loyalists. The pulled chicken sandwich also earns high praise, thanks to its tenderness and house-made BBQ sauce.
If you love BBQ with character, this spot captures it in every dish.
2. Bernie Murray’s
Bernie Murray’s delivers a classic BBQ experience with the feel of a longtime community gathering spot. My last visit ended with a friendly server recommending the house specialty, and it paid off. Here, comfort comes as much from the vibe as from the food.
The BBQ chicken is a must-try—smoked until juicy and brushed with a sauce that’s hearty without being overpowering. Sides like creamy coleslaw and hand-cut fries round out the meal, showing a devotion to fresh, homespun touches. For those who like a bit of heat, the spicy wings add that perfect kick.
From friendly faces to really satisfying plates, Bernie Murray’s stands out as a reliable stop for folks craving true Elmira-style BBQ.
3. Champions Sports Grille
Champions Sports Grille isn’t just about the game; it’s where BBQ and friendly rivalry go hand in hand. My first time here, I was surrounded by the cheer of fans and the mouthwatering scent of smoked meats drifting from the kitchen. The big screens are everywhere, but the food is worth your focus.
Barbecue lovers should start with the smoked brisket sandwich—tender, smoky, and topped with just enough sauce to let the meat shine. The BBQ chicken platter is another gem, arriving hot with a house sauce that’s savory and satisfying. Add in crisp fries and a fresh side salad, and you’ll see why folks stick around after the final whistle.
For big flavor and a high-energy setting, this grille hits the spot.
4. Roundin Third
Roundin Third blends a casual sports bar feel with a BBQ menu that rises above the usual expectations. My first visit was for a quick bite during a midweek game, but I lingered thanks to the aroma of smoky meats drifting through the crowd. There’s variety here, but the BBQ shines brightest.
The pulled chicken is a highlight—tender, smoky, and piled high on a toasted bun. It’s the kind of simple, satisfying flavor that keeps you reaching for just one more bite. For something heartier, the BBQ platter brings together slow-cooked meats and classic sides, all made with care.
Whether you’re a regular or stopping by after work, Roundin Third serves up reliable BBQ with easygoing charm.
5. Texas Roadhouse
Texas Roadhouse in Horseheads pulls in crowds for its big flavors and lively atmosphere. My latest visit brought the buzz of country tunes and the unmistakable scent of slow-roasted meats. It’s a place where diners relax and tuck into generous portions without fuss.
The ribs steal the show—fall-off-the-bone tender, with a glaze that clings to every bite. Their BBQ chicken is another favorite: juicy and coated in house-made sauce, it’s perfect with classic sides like seasoned rice or green beans. There’s a contagious energy in the air, making it as fun for families as for friends.
Texas Roadhouse stands out for hearty plates and genuine BBQ, bringing bold flavor to every meal.
6. Braun’s Pour House
(607) 873-7580Call
Braun’s Pour House is a hidden gem where southern comfort meets upstate charm, all at prices that keep locals coming back. My afternoon at Braun’s began with the hum of laughter and the unmistakable scent of smoked meat. The staff made the space feel extra welcoming, like you’ve been coming for years.
The pulled chicken sandwich stands out—tender, well-seasoned, and piled on a soft bun with their signature BBQ sauce. Sides like collard greens and seasoned fries round out the meal with a soulful touch, setting it apart from the usual.
If you’re after rich BBQ flavor without breaking the bank, Braun’s brings both value and character straight to your table.
7. Hickory House Restaurant
Hickory House Restaurant gives classic BBQ an inviting, down-home twist. My first meal here was on a chilly day, with the warmth from the smoker making the whole space feel cozy. Families and regulars fill the seats, drawn in by comfort and honest flavor.
The BBQ chicken platter is a solid pick—juicy, smoky, and paired with homemade sides like creamy coleslaw or baked beans. Their portion sizes mean you won’t leave hungry, and the house sauce brings every bite together. If you enjoy traditional BBQ done right, this spot has you covered.
It’s the kind of place where simple plates make big impressions, and where every meal feels like home.
8. Outback Steakhouse
Outback Steakhouse in Horseheads puts its own Aussie spin on American BBQ favorites. My experience here was marked by friendly service and the rich aroma of hardwood smoke lingering above each sizzling plate. It’s a bit livelier than your typical steakhouse and never feels rushed.
The grilled chicken on the barbie is the must-try—juicy, smoky, and char-grilled for top flavor. Pair it with fresh seasonal veggies or a baked potato for a satisfying meal. Their ribs are another crowd-pleaser: slow-cooked and brushed with a bold BBQ sauce that wins repeat orders from regulars.
With generous portions and consistent quality, Outback serves up BBQ with a spirited twist, perfect for weeknight cravings or family outings.
9. Callear’s R & R Bar-B-Que
Callear’s R & R Bar-B-Que offers that small-town feel where comfort and real smokehouse flavor meet. My last meal here was all about warmth, with friendly staff weaving between tables and plates piled high with BBQ classics. The atmosphere is easy and family-focused—no pretenses, just good food.
The pulled chicken is the star—smoked slow, incredibly moist, and piled with their tangy house BBQ sauce. Don’t skip the brisket either; slices are thick, hearty, and carried by deep, woodsy flavor. House-made sides like baked beans and potato salad bring plenty of soul to the plate.
For BBQ that brings people together and always hits the spot, Callear’s is a stop worth savoring—especially when you need true comfort food.
10. Slammin Jammin Southern Smoked BBQ
Slammin Jammin Southern Smoked BBQ brings deep Texas flavor to downtown Corning. My introduction to their BBQ was a three-story experience—historic setting, lively tables, and the scent of hickory smoke drifting from the kitchen. This spot packs a Southern punch, all in a family-owned space where details matter.
The brisket is the standout—slow-smoked, juicy, and rich with genuine Texas seasoning. Pulled chicken is just as good, packed with flavor and never dry. Classic sides like coleslaw and cornbread round out the meal for a true Southern spread.
For a slice of Texas BBQ tradition near Elmira, it doesn’t get more authentic or satisfying than Slammin Jammin.
More Things to Try in Elmira, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best BBQ restaurants in Elmira, NY?
Top favorites include The Sand Dollar Saloon & Grill, Bernie Murray’s, Champions Sports Grille, and locally loved spots like Braun’s Pour House and Hickory House Restaurant. Each offers something unique, from fall-off-the-bone ribs to piled-high pulled chicken.
Are there BBQ places in Elmira with vegetarian or family-friendly options?
Yes, many BBQ spots, such as Texas Roadhouse and Outback Steakhouse, offer family-style menus and sides like salads, baked potatoes, and veggies. You’ll find plenty for non-meat eaters and kids alike.
What type of BBQ styles can I expect to find in Elmira?
In Elmira, you’ll find everything from smoky Southern and Texas-style BBQ to classic American favorites. Some spots focus on juicy brisket and ribs, while others are famous for their chicken and homemade sauces.
Which Elmira BBQ restaurants are best for takeout?
Places like Hickory House Restaurant, Braun’s Pour House, and Champions Sports Grille are known for quick, reliable takeout. They package BBQ and sides so everything stays fresh by the time you get home.
Do Elmira BBQ restaurants cater events or parties?
Several BBQ joints, including Callear’s R & R Bar-B-Que and Leghorn BBQ & Catering, offer catering services for parties, from casual get-togethers to bigger celebrations. Menus can be customized for different group sizes and tastes.