Scouting for the best BBQ in Centereach, NY is an adventure worth savoring. The sheer aroma drifting from local grills feels like a warm invitation—one that promises smoky flavors and genuine comfort. On my first trip through Centereach’s BBQ scene, I discovered how diverse and inventive local pitmasters could be. From classic, wood-smoked brisket to grilled specialties infused with unique spices, there’s more than one way to satisfy a craving here.
This guide brings together the top-rated spots that locals and discerning visitors keep coming back to. Whether your taste leans toward traditional slow-cooked meats or bold, modern twists, you’ll find options that respect BBQ roots without being stuck in the past. Every spot listed delivers on flavor and authenticity, making the search for your new favorite as enjoyable as the first bite.
Where to find the best bbq in Centereach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Centereach, NY:
- Choopan Grill
- Dickey’s Barbecue Pit
- Just Wing It
- Wing Wah Restaurant
- Sportulas
- Island Outdoor, LLC
- Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill
- Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck
- Texas Roadhouse
- Thristy Scholar
1. Choopan Grill
(631) 696-1817Call
Choopan Grill scores high marks for its dedication to authentic flavors and a friendly, no-fuss atmosphere. Nestled just off Middle Country Road, it’s the kind of place where the scent of grilled meat promises a hearty meal.
On my last visit, the lamb kabobs were a standout—juicy and tender, charred to perfection. This isn’t a spot for bland barbecue; every dish carries its own character, especially the marinated chicken skewers that stay moist and flavorful.
Choopan Grill is perfect for anyone seeking Halal-friendly barbecue in Centereach. The BBQ platters let you mix and match, making each meal feel personalized. For first-timers, the lamb and chicken combo is a true showcase of the kitchen’s skill.
2. Dickey’s Barbecue Pit
Dickey’s Barbecue Pit brings Texas-style BBQ right into the heart of Centereach Mall. The moment you step in, the aroma of slow-smoked meats is unmistakable—think oak wood and just the right touch of spice. This is a place where tradition runs deep, and each plate reflects that legacy.
On my most recent visit, the smoked chicken stole the show. It’s juicy, well-seasoned, and falls apart with minimal effort. Dickey’s really shines with its sides, too. The coleslaw and baked potato casserole complement the proteins without overpowering them.
For a true taste of Dickey’s, order a two-meat plate with their famous chicken and turkey. Quality and consistency set this spot apart, making it a go-to for families or anyone craving a classic barbecue experience.
3. Just Wing It
(631) 676-7400Call
Just Wing It adds a playful, local flavor to the Centereach BBQ lineup. The name says wings, but there’s far more to explore for anyone who appreciates well-crafted American barbecue. It’s casual, with a laid-back dining area that welcomes everyone.
During my first trip, the grilled chicken wings impressed me the most—crispy skin, bold spice, and not greasy. Here, wings aren’t an afterthought. They’re the draw, and the kitchen takes pride in inventive sauces and perfect grill marks.
Try the BBQ chicken wings or a platter with extra sides. The portions are generous and each bite captures the bright, smoky notes you hope for. Just Wing It brings a neighborhood spirit and solid value to its menu.
4. Wing Wah Restaurant
Wing Wah Restaurant offers a unique blend of Asian-inspired barbecue and classic American comfort food. Located at The Center at Centereach, it has a loyal following for its consistent quality and broad menu. The atmosphere is relaxed, perfect for a family dinner or a quick lunch with friends.
On my visit, the grilled chicken and vegetable skewers were full of flavor with just the right amount of caramelization. Wing Wah isn’t just about barbecue, but their grilled dishes stand out for their freshness and balanced seasoning.
The chicken skewers and BBQ vegetable platters are the real highlights. Their kitchen’s blend of sauces and grilling techniques means each bite feels both familiar and just a bit new. Wing Wah’s menu brings something satisfying for every BBQ enthusiast.
5. Sportulas
(631) 240-0650Call
Sportulas isn’t a barbecue restaurant, but a must-visit stop for anyone serious about grilling in Centereach. Set in Smith Haven Mall, this store is stocked with unique BBQ tools and accessories—it’s where I found the perfect spatula for those summer cookouts.
Sportulas stands out for quality and selection. Their grilling gear has personality. Whether you’re shopping for a precision tongs or personalized grill tools, you’ll find items that make home barbecuing more fun.
The signature engraved spatulas and heavy-duty grill sets are worth checking out. If you’re looking to step up your home BBQ game, this spot has you covered. Every Centereach barbecue master could use an upgrade from Sportulas’ collection.
6. Island Outdoor, LLC
Island Outdoor, LLC is a go-to destination for anyone passionate about grilling in Centereach. Nestled in Ronkonkoma, this shop specializes in top-notch BBQ equipment and supplies, from premium gaskets to reliable grills. I stopped in searching for a new grill brush and was floored by their knowledgeable team and impressive range of products.
Shopping here means getting the right part or accessory the first time. Island Outdoor, LLC takes pride in offering gear that lasts and stands up to direct heat. Their team is always ready with advice or recommendations, which makes every visit productive.
Their replacement gaskets and grilling tools are essential for anyone serious about BBQ. It’s the sort of local resource that helps Centereach grill masters shine at home.
7. Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill
Smokey Bones Bar & Fire Grill lights up the BBQ scene near Centereach with its lively atmosphere and robust menu. The first time I dined here, the aroma of slow-cooked meats met me at the door. Their open kitchen draws attention, promising honest, smoke-infused flavors with every order.
This spot excels at balance. The fire-grilled chicken delivers juicy tenderness with each bite, thanks to careful seasoning and attentive cooking. Classic smoky notes and a cozy dining room set the scene for big gatherings or quiet meals.
The fire-grilled chicken and grilled shrimp deserve special mention. These dishes show off Smokey Bones’ knack for bold flavors and reliable quality. A visit here means hearty portions and a true taste of barbecue done right.
8. Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck
Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck brings fresh barbecue and a splash of personality to Centereach’s food scene. You’ll spot this food truck by the inviting aroma and the line of regulars waiting with high expectations. My first meal here was an impromptu lunch run, and it delivered on every promise of smoky, slow-cooked goodness.
What makes Rolling Smoke stand out is its flexibility. Whether you want quick takeout, catering for a party, or a taste of mobile BBQ at a festival, they deliver. Their food is always prepared with attention to flavor and quality.
Try the smoked chicken platter or the BBQ turkey sandwich. Each dish is made from scratch and packed with deep, satisfying flavor. Rolling Smoke shows how good BBQ can travel and taste just as amazing on the go.
9. Texas Roadhouse
Texas Roadhouse in Selden is more than a steakhouse—it’s a staple for hearty, crowd-pleasing barbecue close to Centereach. The lively, down-home setting draws families and friends who crave bold flavors and generous portions. My first visit left me impressed with the skill behind their open kitchen and the irresistible scent of grilled meats.
What sets Texas Roadhouse apart is the energy. Friendly staff, fresh-baked bread, and hand-cut steaks all play a part. The menu strikes a balance between tradition and comfort, making it easy to find something for everyone.
The fire-grilled chicken and country-style grilled vegetables are a smart pick for BBQ fans. With every dish prepared fresh, Texas Roadhouse sets a high bar for barbecue quality in the area.
10. Thristy Scholar
(631) 648-9454Call
Thristy Scholar is equal parts neighborhood bar and BBQ haven, a laid-back spot just a short drive from Centereach. The energy is warm and unpretentious, with regulars swapping stories over plates of comfort food. On my last visit, the service felt like stopping by a friend’s house—friendly, never rushed.
What makes Thristy Scholar shine is its straight-ahead approach to barbecue. Dishes are simple but flavors are deep, thanks to time-honored grilling methods and well-chosen marinades. You come here for food that’s as honest as the atmosphere.
Order the grilled chicken platter or try the seasoned vegetable skewers. Each plate celebrates smoke and spice without overcomplicating things. If you’re after genuine, unfussy barbecue in a fun setting, Thristy Scholar hits the mark.
More Things to Try in Centereach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated BBQ restaurants in Centereach, NY?
Some local favorites include Choopan Grill, Dickey’s Barbecue Pit, Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck, and Texas Roadhouse. Each offers its own spin on classic barbecue flavors, with options for every taste.
Are there Halal BBQ options in Centereach?
Yes, Choopan Grill stands out for its Halal-friendly BBQ, offering a variety of grilled meats prepared to suit dietary requirements.
What BBQ dishes should I try in Centereach?
Grilled chicken, lamb kabobs, smoked turkey, and classic barbecue platters are featured on many menus. Many spots also offer house-made sides and sauces to round out your meal.
Are there vegetarian or non-meat BBQ options available?
Definitely. Many restaurants serve grilled vegetable platters or skewers and other sides that let vegetarians enjoy the barbecue experience.
Do any Centereach BBQ spots offer catering or takeout?
Yes. Rolling Smoke Grill Food Truck and Dickey’s Barbecue Pit both provide catering and takeout services, perfect for parties or casual gatherings.
Can I find family-friendly BBQ restaurants in Centereach?
Absolutely. Many BBQ spots like Texas Roadhouse and Wing Wah Restaurant feature family-style dining and kid-friendly options, creating a relaxed atmosphere for everyone.