Finding good BBQ in Brookville, NY takes more than a passing glance at a menu. Anyone who’s roamed the Gold Coast knows that the best barbecue is part flavor, part atmosphere, and a solid dash of local character. I still remember my first proper rack of ribs here, eaten at a corner booth while the scent of hickory drifted by—a bite that proved you don’t have to trek to the South to find smoked perfection.
Brookville’s BBQ options are varied, each offering its own twist on the classics. Some spots double down on smoky brisket; others branch out with inventive sauces or cozy patio seating. If you want to know which places deliver genuine flavor and avoid disappointment, you’re in the right place. This guide cuts through the hype and gets straight to the top spots, so you can skip the guesswork and head straight for your next meal. Ready for a journey through Brookville’s best? Let’s dig in.
Where to find the best bbq in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Brookville, NY:
- Lisbon Cafe
- Blowin’ Smoke BBQ
- House
- Jw’s Public House
- Del’s Bar & Grill
- Ringside Of Hicksvill
- 5 Brothers Grill Inc
- Taste Of Greece
- Canz Bar & Grill
- BBQ Nite
1. Lisbon Cafe
(516) 364-4641Call
Lisbon Cafe brings a warm, inviting feel to Jericho, blending South American flair with classic barbecue traditions. The first time I stepped in, I noticed the effort that goes into every detail, from the hand-made pastas to their signature steak cuts.
What sets Lisbon Cafe apart is their dry-aged steaks, aged for up to 35 days. The flavor is rich, tender, and stands head and shoulders above standard fare. You’ll want to try their grilled picanha—tender, smoky, and perfectly seasoned—it’s one of the best demonstrations of their barbecue style.
With each bite, you sense an attention to quality that isn’t easy to find. For BBQ in Brookville, Lisbon Cafe is a must-visit for anyone seeking both comfort and bold flavors.
2. Blowin’ Smoke BBQ
Walk into Blowin’ Smoke BBQ and you’re greeted by a smoky aroma that signals authentic barbecue. My last visit was a clinic in slow-cooked flavor and consistency—these folks know their way around a smoker. Every bite feels carefully considered, from smoke ring to sauce.
Brisket lovers will be right at home. The brisket here is melt-in-your-mouth tender, perfectly balanced with smoke and seasoning. Their pulled chicken is a solid option too, juicy and full of rich flavor without being overwhelming. Sides like spiced corn or slaw round out the meal.
What sets Blowin’ Smoke BBQ apart is their dedication to traditional methods and quality meats. If you want a true taste of barbecue in Brookville, this spot belongs on your bucket list.
3. House
House, known by many as Stuey’s Smokehouse BBQ, is the kind of place where barbecue dreams meet hometown pride. I wandered in one Saturday, drawn by the puffs of aroma that hinted at proper smoked goodness. The atmosphere is relaxed, warm, and rooted in genuine passion for barbecue.
What truly makes House special is their commitment to slow-smoking, a tradition started at local school fairs and perfected over time. Their smoked ribs stand out: beautifully glazed, tender, and packed with deep, smoky flavor. The brisket is another highlight, sliced thick and always juicy.
This is the spot for anyone who values homegrown talent and honest-to-goodness barbecue. Order the ribs or brisket if you want the true House experience—they never disappoint.
4. Jw’s Public House
(516) 200-9090Call
Jw’s Public House puts a polished spin on classic barbecue in the heart of Glen Head. My afternoon here turned into an unplanned feast, set against a lively, welcoming backdrop. Every visit feels a bit like joining friends for a celebratory meal—no pretenses, just good eating.
Their standout quality is the way they balance barbecue flavors with a sense of refinement. Try the barbecued chicken, grilled to perfection and served with a subtle sweetness that lingers just enough. If you prefer beef, their smoked brisket platter arrives juicy, tender, and full of deep, bold character.
Jw’s doesn’t try to be flashy. Instead, it focuses on reliable barbecue and a setting fit for both group gatherings and low-key meals. This is a smart stop for anyone chasing relaxed, elevated barbecue near Brookville.
5. Del’s Bar & Grill
(516) 922-4444Call
Del’s Bar & Grill is one of those neighborhood gems where regulars and newcomers feel equally at home. The first time I stopped by, the laid-back vibe made it easy to settle in for a leisurely meal, and I quickly learned that this spot has a loyal following for a reason.
The menu at Del’s keeps things classic with a focus on hearty, unfussy barbecue. If you want flavor without fuss, start with their barbecued chicken platter. The meat is juicy, with subtle smokiness that lets the natural taste shine. Pair it with seasoned fries or slaw for the full experience.
There’s nothing flashy here—just reliable barbecue and a comfortable setting. It’s the sort of place where you go for familiar favorites and leave happy every time.
6. Ringside Of Hicksvill
Ringside Of Hicksvill is the kind of spot where the sizzle from the grill is as much a part of the atmosphere as the friendly crowd. My last visit was a spur-of-the-moment stop, and I was greeted with generous portions and attentive service that didn’t miss a beat.
What separates Ringside from the typical barbecue joint is its blend of bold flavor and approachable style. Their grilled chicken is a highlight, cooked over open flames for a char that packs real depth. The menu keeps things classic with sides that feel homemade and consistently satisfying.
If you’re after relaxed barbecue with no frills and all flavor, Ringside Of Hicksvill should be on your shortlist. It’s easygoing, honest, and seriously tasty.
7. 5 Brothers Grill Inc
(516) 750-5243Call
5 Brothers Grill Inc knows the value of consistency. My first taste came on a rainy weekday—just me, a warm plate, and the quiet aroma of the grill. There’s a home-style feel to the place, inviting diners to settle in and linger over comforting food.
The menu leans on tradition, focusing on grilled chicken and beef dishes that are a tribute to true barbecue technique. The grilled chicken is especially worth ordering—juicy and lightly charred, it’s reliably flavorful with each visit. Every side is made with the same attention to detail, from rice to salad.
For folks who want straightforward barbecue without the theatrics, 5 Brothers is a sound choice. The food is honest, the service steady, and the flavors always satisfying.
8. Taste Of Greece
(516) 334-9600Call
Taste Of Greece puts a Mediterranean spin on barbecue, and the moment you walk in, you’ll notice the difference. My meal here was filled with fresh flavors and a level of hospitality that made even a quick lunch feel special. It’s a bright spot for anyone who wants something beyond traditional BBQ.
The real stars are their grilled chicken souvlaki and beef kebabs. Both are seared just right, balancing a smoky char with delicate spices and fresh herbs. Their sides, from crisp salads to roasted vegetables, round out the meal with vibrant accents.
If you’re in the mood for barbecue that goes beyond the ordinary but keeps every bite flavorful, Taste Of Greece is a smart pick for Brookville locals and visitors alike.
9. Canz Bar & Grill
Canz Bar & Grill blends lively energy with hearty barbecue, creating a spot perfect for groups and solo diners alike. I remember catching a sports game here, the sounds of laughter and clinking glasses as reliable as the barbecue coming out of the kitchen.
What makes Canz stand out is its commitment to classic bar and grill fare, but with a smoky, flavorful edge. The grilled chicken sliders are a favorite of mine—bite-sized, well-seasoned, and perfect for sharing. Their beef tips also get plenty of attention, arriving sizzling and tender.
It’s a place where you can unwind and enjoy barbecue favorites in a setting that’s never dull. For simple, satisfying options, Canz Bar & Grill delivers every time.
10. BBQ Nite
BBQ Nite is a no-frills, family-friendly spot where the focus is firmly on flavor. My first dinner here was casual, but what stuck with me was how expertly each dish was prepared, from the first bite to the last. You can sense the care in every plate.
This eatery is known for generous portions and a menu that brings together American barbecue with a twist. The best-selling barbecue chicken platter is juicy and subtly smoky, an easy pick for anyone craving comfort. Their grilled beef kebabs are also worth a try—tender, well-spiced, and perfect with their house-made sides.
The prices are easy on the wallet, and the food always feels home-cooked. BBQ Nite is perfect for those unfussy nights when you want food that’s both tasty and filling.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best BBQ restaurants near Brookville, NY?
Several standouts include Lisbon Cafe, Blowin’ Smoke BBQ, and House (Stuey’s Smokehouse BBQ). Each offers its own take on classic barbecue, with rich flavors and reliable service.
Do any Brookville BBQ spots offer vegetarian options?
Yes, many BBQ spots cater to vegetarians with grilled vegetable platters, salads, and hearty sides. It’s best to call ahead or check menus for details.
Can I find family-friendly BBQ in Brookville?
Absolutely. Places like BBQ Nite and Del’s Bar & Grill provide a casual, welcoming atmosphere suitable for families and groups of all sizes.
Which restaurants use traditional smoking methods?
Blowin’ Smoke BBQ and House are known for their authentic, slow-smoking techniques that make a noticeable difference in flavor and texture.
Are there any BBQ places with outdoor seating?
Yes, several restaurants, especially bar & grills, offer outdoor or patio seating for a relaxed barbecue experience.