Few quests match the comfort of hunting down truly memorable BBQ. In Menomonee Falls, the smoky aroma drifts down neighborhood streets, tempting anyone with a passing interest in ribs or brisket. Over the years, I’ve waded through saucy debates and empty plates, taking notes one bite at a time. Each stop brought its own flavor—some laid-back, some lively, all worth the trip.
Choosing the best BBQ in Menomonee Falls, WI is not about chasing the boldest claims. It’s about savoring honest, skillful cooking, often in places you’d never expect. Whether you’re craving slow-smoked classics, tangy sauces, or meat that simply falls apart, you’ll find it here. Feeling lost in the smoke? Let’s explore each spot together, starting with the standouts locals swear by.
1. Brisco County Wood Grill
Brisco County Wood Grill feels like a slice of the Southwest dropped into Menomonee Falls. Step inside, and you’re surrounded by bold murals, western decor, and the unmistakable aroma of wood-fired cooking. Even if you’re just here for BBQ, the atmosphere alone leaves an impression.
Their BBQ ribs, slow-roasted over wood, steal the show every time. Each bite grabs you with a subtle smoke and the perfect balance of tenderness and bite. The rotisserie chicken, juicy with hints of char, comes a close second—simple and skillful.
During my last visit, the generous BBQ platter let me sample a bit of everything, from the savory Black Angus beef to their signature sauces. Pair your BBQ with house-made sides to get the full Brisco County experience.
2. Blair’s Hardware – Menomonee Falls/Butler
Blair’s Hardware – Menomonee Falls/Butler isn’t just about tools; it’s where local BBQ fans quietly level up their backyard skills. More than once, I’ve lingered in their grill section, surrounded by top brands like Weber and Traeger. Their team is always eager to talk shop or give advice that actually makes a difference.
The grill aisle is the real highlight. If you’re hoping to nail brisket or get smoke just right, Blair’s selection of charcoal, wood chips, and rubs offers everything needed for legit BBQ at home.
Pick up a propane tank or a sturdy set of tongs, then ask about local recipes and grilling tips. You’ll walk out ready to cook, no matter how ambitious your BBQ plans.
3. Belly Up Twice
Belly Up Twice may fly under the radar, but locals know it as a no-nonsense spot for hearty, flavorful BBQ. My visits always start with the aroma of smoked meats drifting out to the parking lot—a promising sign if there ever was one.
The standout here is the barbecue pork sandwich, served stacked and unpretentious, with tender shreds that soak up every drop of sauce. Their sides keep things classic and comforting, rounding out the meal without distraction.
What sets Belly Up Twice apart is the laid-back setting, where conversation comes easy and the focus stays on honest cooking. When craving authentic BBQ in a setting that feels like home, this is where I end up.
4. Mibb’s & Viv’s
Mibb’s & Viv’s is a hidden gem tucked along N Lannon Road, where regulars swap stories over generous plates that smell of the grill. On my first visit, the cheerful staff made sure it felt like a true neighborhood hangout, and the food sealed the deal.
Their BBQ chicken is the star—juicy, subtly smoky, and always cooked just right. Each forkful is packed with flavor, never dried out or overwhelmed by sauce. The brisket platter is worth a look, too, for its tender slices and classic spice rub.
Here, it’s all about comfort and tradition, with each dish feeling both familiar and special. If you want a meal that lets you relax and savor, Mibb’s & Viv’s is tough to top.
5. Bar 107
(414) 355-5998Call
Bar 107 brings together everything that makes a neighborhood spot memorable: friendly faces, cozy booths, and a menu with unexpected highlights. My evenings here usually feature laughter from corner tables and a steady stream of regulars dropping by for their BBQ fix.
The pulled chicken sandwich stands out, packed with perfectly seasoned, tender meat and a sauce that keeps things tangy but never overpowering. For a shareable option, the BBQ platter covers all the bases, letting everyone at the table find a favorite bite.
There’s no rush at Bar 107; it’s a place to linger, savor your meal, and let the next round come when it’s ready. The BBQ here matches the warm, relaxed vibe from the very first bite.
6. American Parts Equipment Supply
American Parts Equipment Supply might not sound like a BBQ destination, but it has quietly become a go-to for anyone refining their outdoor cooking game in Menomonee Falls. My own backyard cookouts owe a lot to their range of grilling equipment and high-quality supplies—no need to hunt all over town for that one tool.
Their selection of barbecue grills and accessories stands out. From heavy-duty tools to reliable grill covers, every item leans toward durability and convenience, perfect for frequent BBQ enthusiasts.
Order a set of grill brushes or try their heavy-gauge grill baskets if you like a good sear on your chicken or veggies. American Parts Equipment Supply offers the behind-the-scenes gear that lets your BBQ shine.
7. Duplainville Station
(262) 695-5300Call
Duplainville Station has the kind of laid-back charm that makes you want to stay longer than planned. Nestled just outside Menomonee Falls, this spot brings together classic BBQ and a tavern vibe. On my last visit, locals chatted over their meals while the friendly staff kept the pace easy and welcoming.
Their smoked chicken is a highlight—tender, with just enough smoky depth. It’s expertly done, pulling apart effortlessly whether you go fork or finger. The BBQ beef sandwich is another safe bet, stacked high and paired with house-made sides that taste like home.
If you’re seeking a spot where comfort food and community go hand in hand, Duplainville Station brings both to the table, one flavorful plate at a time.
8. BigCountry’s Barbecue LLC
(414) 388-2848Call
BigCountry’s Barbecue LLC makes a strong statement with the promise, “You Don’t Need Teeth To Eat My Barbecue Meat”—and they deliver. My last lunch here was an eye-opener: generous portions, lots of smiles behind the counter, and that unmistakable aroma of meat cooking low and slow.
The ribs stand out for their fall-off-the-bone tenderness and deep, rich flavor. Hours on the grill and regular basting with house-made sauce mean each bite is packed with that signature juicy profile, never dry or bland. The chicken receives just as much care, coming out incredibly moist and smoky.
If you’re after true comfort BBQ with friendly service and fair prices, go for a rib or chicken dinner. It’s a meal that brings you back, every time.
9. Uncle Johnny’s
(262) 628-9211Call
Uncle Johnny’s balances small-town tavern charm with honest BBQ that draws regulars from all over. The space feels friendly and unpretentious, buzzing with conversations and the satisfying sizzle from the kitchen. My last visit saw families swapping plates and locals recommending favorites as soon as I sat down.
The pulled chicken sandwich shines for its tenderness and light, flavorful sauce. Pair that with a side of slaw for the full experience—it’s simple, reliable, and always satisfying. Their BBQ platter is also worth a shot if you want to sample a bit of everything.
Uncle Johnny’s wins on wallet-friendly prices and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. If you enjoy discovering BBQ where community comes first, this spot is a solid pick.
10. Dickey’s Barbecue Pit
Dickey’s Barbecue Pit is a familiar name for anyone who takes BBQ seriously around Milwaukee and Menomonee Falls. Walking in, the smell of smoky meats is the best greeting you could ask for. I’ve stopped by on road trips, family get-togethers, and days when only comfort food hits the spot.
Their classic beef brisket is a must—tender, smoky, and always sliced to order. The pulled chicken brings just as much flavor, pairing well with traditional sides like baked beans and potato casserole for a well-rounded meal.
Dickey’s stands out for consistent quality and a wide menu that caters to both BBQ newcomers and loyal fans. When you want reliable barbecue without any surprises, it hits the mark.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best BBQ in Menomonee Falls, WI?
Some standout places include Brisco County Wood Grill, Mibb’s & Viv’s, and Belly Up Twice. Each offers its own twist on BBQ favorites, from smoked chicken to classic ribs.
Are there good BBQ options for families in Menomonee Falls?
Absolutely. Spots like Brisco County Wood Grill and Uncle Johnny’s are family-friendly, with spacious seating and a relaxed vibe.
Which BBQ places in the area offer takeout or catering?
Selections like Dickey’s Barbecue Pit and BigCountry’s Barbecue LLC provide convenient takeout and catering options for gatherings large or small.
Do any Menomonee Falls BBQ restaurants have vegetarian or halal-friendly options?
Many local BBQ joints serve classic sides like baked potatoes, salads, and grilled veggies. For strictly halal needs, it’s best to call ahead to confirm.
What should I try for an authentic BBQ experience in Menomonee Falls?
Opt for house-smoked ribs, pulled chicken, or brisket. Savoring a platter that includes a bit of everything is a great way to sample each spot’s specialty.