If you’ve ever caught a whiff of slow-cooked ribs drifting across Peach Lake, you know the magnetic pull of good barbecue. This small, scenic spot isn’t exactly the first place you’d expect to stumble upon standout smoked meats, but that’s part of its charm. Years ago, after a detour gone right, I landed at a lakeside joint where brisket was king and sauce was a closely guarded secret. That taste—balanced and smoky—set the bar high. Since then, I’ve made it a personal quest to sample every notable BBQ spot in and around Peach Lake.
Finding truly great BBQ here is less about following your nose and more about following locals’ word-of-mouth whispers. From roadside grills that serve smoky classics to casual eateries that come alive after sunset, there’s genuine variety tucked between these tree-lined streets. Whether you crave pulled chicken that falls apart with a touch or ribs with bark so crisp it snaps, this guide will lead you straight to the most memorable plates in Peach Lake. Hungry? Let’s get into it.
Where to find the best bbq in Peach Lake, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Peach Lake, NY:
- In The Rough Grille
- B & B 46
- Northern Smoke
- Kelly’s Corner
- Billy’s Southern Style BBQ
- The Cue Restaurant
- Old Oak Restaurant Bar & Grill
- Texas Roadhouse
- Sticky Fingers Smokehouse
- Hoodoo Brown BBQ
1. In The Rough Grille
(203) 792-4653Call
In The Rough Grille is the sort of place where you can show up in jeans, grab a seat, and feel right at home. Tucked just outside Peach Lake on Ridgebury Road, this unpretentious spot has a way of making strangers feel like regulars. On my first visit, I struck up a conversation over a platter of fall-apart smoked chicken that came with a side of house-made slaw—each bite was tender, deeply flavored, and quietly addictive.
This is a BBQ joint that doesn’t try too hard; the food speaks for itself. The smoked turkey sandwich pairs smoky meat with crisp veggies, and the seasoning hints at days spent marinating. If you’re ordering for the table, get the BBQ pulled chicken sliders, which combine a rich, sweet-savory sauce with pillowy rolls.
Stop by on a sunny afternoon, and you might end up staying awhile. There’s comfort here—for the palate and for the pace of life around Peach Lake.
2. B & B 46
(203) 456-6561Call
B & B 46 brings BBQ dreams to life just minutes from Peach Lake, where woodsmoke drifts nightly from the kitchen. My first meal here was a feast of smoked chicken platter, served up with zesty house-made pickles and bread that soaked up every last drop of sauce. There’s warmth in the way the staff greets regulars—and a dash of pride in every plate.
What makes this spot stand out is the attention to detail. Their grilled turkey breast arrives with a smoky crust and just enough juice inside. For BBQ newcomers, the chicken skewers are a reliable first bite—simple, full of flavor, and always hot off the grill.
Portions are sized for sharing, so bring friends or family. If you find yourself sidetracked in Danbury, B & B 46 is worth a detour for anyone who loves real barbecue.
3. Northern Smoke
(845) 669-8600Call
Northern Smoke feels like the best-kept secret just north of Peach Lake. Tucked into Carmel, this spot radiates smoky charm the second you walk in. My table once disappeared under platters of smoked turkey breast—tender, with a whisper of black pepper and cherry wood that lingers. It’s comfort food done with real care.
What sets Northern Smoke apart is the consistency. Every slice, every side, feels curated yet relaxed. The chicken wings here don’t need fanfare; crisped skin and deep flavor do the talking. Try the pulled chicken sandwich—it’s juicy, smoky, and paired with fresh rolls that soak up every last bit.
There’s nothing flashy about Northern Smoke, but you’ll leave full and thinking about your next visit before you reach the car.
4. Kelly’s Corner
(845) 278-4297Call
Kelly’s Corner has the easygoing vibe of a local favorite, just a short drive from Peach Lake. My first night there, the place was humming—a mix of regulars at the bar and families tucking into hearty plates. What caught my attention was the aroma from the kitchen, promising BBQ without any pretense.
The standout dish is their BBQ chicken platter. The chicken arrives juicy and kissed with just enough smoke to keep you reaching for another bite. The coleslaw on the side doesn’t just play backup—it’s sharp, creamy, and pairs perfectly.
If you’re feeling adventurous, try the pulled BBQ turkey sandwich. With generous portions and a friendly staff, Kelly’s Corner proves that you don’t need big city hype to serve memorable barbecue.
5. Billy’s Southern Style BBQ
(203) 731-0501Call
Billy’s Southern Style BBQ sits in Bethel but it feels right at home for anyone searching for barbecue around Peach Lake. The vibe is all comfort, with décor that hints at a southern road trip and a staff who seem to know your name after a visit or two. My go-to order is the smoked turkey breast sandwich, stacked high and draped in just enough tangy, house-made sauce to make every bite memorable.
What sets Billy’s apart is the attention to balance and freshness. Their sides—especially the collard greens and BBQ beans—taste like they were cooked to accompany the headlining meats, not just fill a plate. Try the grilled BBQ chicken platter for a taste that’s smoky, moist, and layered in subtle spices.
Even if you’re just passing through, Billy’s Southern Style BBQ is worth pulling off the road for honest flavors and real southern hospitality within reach of Peach Lake.
6. The Cue Restaurant
The Cue Restaurant doesn’t hide its smokehouse roots—step through the door and the aroma tells the story. I once slid into a booth here for a rainy afternoon meal and left thoroughly convinced that BBQ in Peach Lake’s orbit had reached a new high. The highlight? Their smoked chicken platter, featuring juicy, char-grilled meat set off by bright, tangy sauce. Every bite brings a snap of smoke and spice.
The Cue stands out for its inventive sides, like maple cornbread and charred vegetables that hold their own against the classics. The BBQ turkey sandwich layers house-smoked meat with fresh pickles for a spot-on flavor match.
If you love BBQ with a modern twist, The Cue deserves a spot on your list.
7. Old Oak Restaurant Bar & Grill
(203) 748-6555Call
Old Oak Restaurant Bar & Grill leans into its classic, no-frills spirit. Just off Liberty Street in Danbury, it’s easy to find and even easier to linger a while. My first visit landed me in front of a smoked turkey platter—carved thick, full-flavored, and paired with simple sides that let the meat shine. It’s the kind of meal that feels like home, even if you’re just passing through.
Old Oak’s hallmark is honest flavor over gimmicks. Their grilled BBQ chicken sandwich comes with crisp lettuce and enough smoky char to satisfy any craving. If you’re with a group, order the BBQ chicken wings—juicy, saucy, and addictive in the best possible way.
This is comfort food that gets straight to the point, perfect for laid-back BBQ fans in the Peach Lake area.
8. Texas Roadhouse
Texas Roadhouse in Danbury is a familiar name, but it still manages to surprise. The energy hits you first—line-dancing servers, jukebox tunes, and laughter filling the room. I once ducked in on a busy Friday and landed a booth with a view of the open kitchen. Watching the staff grill a smoked half chicken over open flames, you could tell these folks take their barbecue seriously.
What sets Texas Roadhouse apart is the care in the details. Their BBQ chicken arrives juicy and perfectly charred, with just enough sweetness in the sauce to build anticipation for each bite. If you’re feeding a crowd, go for the family-style platters or the grilled turkey breast, both executed with consistency.
Portions here are generous, so expect to leave happy—and maybe with a box for later. For Peach Lake BBQ seekers, Texas Roadhouse blends crowd-pleasing energy with reliably good eats.
9. Sticky Fingers Smokehouse
Sticky Fingers Smokehouse is a destination that lives up to its name. The moment you walk along Katonah Ave, the scent of slow-cooked meats draws you in. My last visit featured a plate of their smoked BBQ chicken—the skin crisp, the meat tender, and each bite layered with subtle hints of spice and oak. This isn’t your standard smokehouse fare; it’s carefully crafted, with attention to flavor and balance.
What really makes Sticky Fingers stand out is the way they bring out big flavor in even the simplest dishes. The BBQ turkey sandwich is a sleeper hit, loaded with juicy meat and crunchy pickles. Their sides are more than just sides—try the house-made slaw for a bright, zesty lift.
For Peach Lake barbecue fans, Sticky Fingers Smokehouse delivers a memorable meal, every time.
10. Hoodoo Brown BBQ
Hoodoo Brown BBQ has built a reputation that stretches well beyond Ridgefield. The first time I ate here, it was on a weekend when the place was packed and the energy was infectious. The star of the meal was a plate of pit-smoked turkey breast—each slice moist, kissed by smoke, and generously seasoned. You know it’s good when people at neighboring tables are swapping tips on what to order next.
Hoodoo Brown stands out for its focus on technique and bold flavors. The pulled BBQ chicken is a must-try, slow-cooked and served with just the right balance of spice and sweetness. Their sides—especially the smoked beans—leave nothing to chance.
For those in the Peach Lake area craving big, honest barbecue, Hoodoo Brown is a destination worth the drive.
More Things to Try in Peach Lake, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular BBQ spots near Peach Lake, NY?
Favorites include In The Rough Grille, Northern Smoke, Hoodoo Brown BBQ, and The Cue Restaurant. Each offers its own take on house-smoked meats and classic sides.
Are there halal BBQ options around Peach Lake?
Some BBQ restaurants may have halal or vegetarian choices, but it’s best to call ahead and ask about specific menu items to ensure your dietary needs are met.
What BBQ dishes are best to try around Peach Lake?
Smoked turkey breast, BBQ chicken platters, and pulled chicken sandwiches are local standout options. Many spots put their own regional twist on these staples.
Are reservations needed for BBQ restaurants near Peach Lake?
While most BBQ joints are casual and accept walk-ins, it’s smart to reserve a table for larger groups or during peak dinner hours, especially at popular places like Hoodoo Brown BBQ.
Can I get takeout or delivery from BBQ restaurants near Peach Lake?
Yes, most spots offer takeout, and many partner with local delivery apps. You can enjoy quality BBQ at home or by the lake with a simple call or online order.