Smoke signals mean something good is cooking. If you’ve ever driven through Mohegan Lake and caught the subtle drift of grilled goodness in the air, you’re not alone. Barbecue here isn’t just another meal; it’s a ritual, a reason to linger, and a showcase of each local spot’s own smoky pride. I’ve spent months taste-testing brisket that falls apart at a glance, wings so well-balanced they don’t need sauce, and cornbread with just the right crumble. In short, I’ve gladly navigated every saucy shortcut and side street Mohegan Lake has to offer.
Whether you’re dedicated to ribs you can’t put down, or you’re just after an honest-to-goodness platter that sticks to tradition, you’re in the right corner of Westchester County. This roundup goes beyond hype, digging into the real stars of Mohegan Lake’s BBQ scene—from timeless family favorites to unexpected gems dishing up inventive takes on smoke and spice. The details aren’t dressed up; they’re just right, and you’ll know exactly where to sit down, roll up your sleeves, and let the flavors do the talking. Keep reading—your next favorite bite may be just around the block.
Where to find the best bbq in Mohegan Lake, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Mohegan Lake, NY:
- Home & Hearth
- Bob*B*Q’s
- Diego’s Deli BBQ
- The Patio
- Barnstormer Barbeque
- Round Up TX BBQ
- The Parting
- Johnny D’s BBQ and Burgers
- The Chophouse Grille
- Holy Smoke
1. Home & Hearth
At first glance, Home & Hearth might appear to be just your local fireplace shop, but step inside and you’ll be surprised. This family-owned business offers more than grills and cozy design. It’s a showcase for anyone truly passionate about mastering backyard BBQ in Mohegan Lake, NY.
Here, you’ll find expert advice on everything from choosing the right smoker to perfecting your kebab technique. I learned how to deliver a soft, smoky char on chicken skewers, getting a tip about the importance of even heat from their attentive team.
Order their specialty BBQ equipment—the pellet grills and smoker boxes set the serious BBQ-er apart. Home & Hearth doesn’t just sell products; they help you create legendary cookouts for every season.
2. Bob*B*Q’s
Bob*B*Q’s proves the best barbecue can come from a humble spot. Tucked in Shrub Oak, this cash-only joint delivers food that’s both unfussy and memorable. The aroma welcomes you before you’ve even stepped out of your car.
The smoked chicken is a quiet revelation—moist, gently seasoned, and just enough smokiness to steal the show. My recent order included charred corn on the cob, and I still think about the crisp edges paired with their tangy house sauce.
Don’t miss the brisket platter. The slices are tender and carry that rightful bark, making each bite worth the drive. Bob*B*Q’s keeps things simple and genuine, and that’s exactly what makes it a local classic.
3. Diego’s Deli BBQ
(914) 743-1679Call
Diego’s Deli BBQ is low-key but delivers above-and-beyond flavors. Walk in and you’ll notice the menu offers both classic deli options and serious barbecue standards—an unexpected but welcome combination in Mohegan Lake.
Their smoked turkey sandwich deserves mention, stacked high with juicy slices and just enough spice to keep things interesting. My own introduction came from a local’s tip, and I stuck around for their flavorful sides, especially the baked beans, cooked to a soft finish.
If you’re new, order the BBQ chicken platter. It’s rich, never dry, and finished with Diego’s own signature sauce, slightly tangy with a hint of sweetness. For a spot you might drive past, Diego’s Deli BBQ is hard to forget once you’ve tasted what they can do.
4. The Patio
The Patio lives up to its name, offering a laid-back vibe with plenty of open-air charm right in Peekskill. This spot becomes even better as soon as you catch a whiff of the grill. Here, it’s all about classic BBQ fitting for a long afternoon with friends or family.
The grilled chicken shines above the rest. There’s a perfect char on the outside, and the meat stays juicy—a trick not every BBQ place gets right. I came by on a busy Saturday and never felt rushed, which is part of The Patio’s easy appeal.
Don’t leave without sampling the sweet potato wedges. Their natural sweetness and hint of smoke represent exactly what The Patio does best—straightforward, well-executed BBQ with a few creative touches.
5. Barnstormer Barbeque
Barnstormer Barbeque feels like an escape to a smokehouse retreat, sitting comfortably along Route 9W. The rustic, aviation-themed décor sets a playful backdrop, while the aroma of slow-cooked meats greets you at the door. It’s a place for BBQ lovers who appreciate the process as much as the plate.
Their slow-smoked turkey breast stands out, sliced thick and boldly seasoned. When I visited, the turkey was paired with a side of collard greens, offering a burst of flavor with every forkful. You’ll want to savor the gentle smoke flavor that lingers just long enough between bites.
The cornbread here is another highlight, moist with a golden crust, perfect for mopping up their signature house sauce. Barnstormer Barbeque blends comfort, quality, and a bit of character at every table.
6. Round Up TX BBQ
Round Up TX BBQ in Cold Spring brings a touch of Texas to the Hudson Valley. The big, bold flavors make a strong impression, matched only by the lively, boots-and-jeans atmosphere. If you love digging into the classics with a Southern twist, this is your spot.
The smoked chicken here is the real deal. It arrives with crisped skin, deep smoke, and a juicy finish—everything you’d expect from a Texas pitmaster. The staff knows their way around spice, so each plate packs flavor without being overpowering.
Go for the smoked turkey if you want something both hearty and light. It’s a standout paired with their signature tangy sides. Round Up TX BBQ is where tradition meets a bit of Texas swagger, right in Mohegan Lake’s backyard.
7. The Parting
(845) 628-0649Call
The Parting, nestled along Route 6 in Mahopac, feels like the crossroads of lively bar culture and tried-and-true barbecue. There’s a buzz as soon as you walk in—locals trading stories while smoky aromas drift from the kitchen. It’s welcoming, relaxed, and always packed with regulars.
The smoked chicken wings instantly impressed me. Crisp on the outside, tender inside, each wing is kissed with just the right note of heat. Pair them with their grilled veggies and you’ve got a balanced meal served with no fuss.
The brisket sandwich is another highlight. You can taste the slow-roasted care in every bite, and there’s an unmistakable depth from the house-made sauce. The Parting nails the vibe of a proper BBQ joint without ever feeling overdone.
8. Johnny D’s BBQ and Burgers
Johnny D’s BBQ and Burgers delivers approachable comfort with a smoky kick, right off Route 6 in Mahopac. The space is lively but laid-back, making it one of those rare places where you can settle in with friends or grab something quick without missing out on quality.
The BBQ turkey burger stands out as a must-try. It’s juicy, stacked with fresh toppings, and balanced perfectly between hearty and healthy. My own visit meant devouring one in record time, then eyeing an order of fries dusted with their subtle house seasoning.
The slow-cooked chicken platter is another popular choice. Lean, never greasy, and finished with a hint of smoky sweetness, it sums up what Johnny D’s does well—classic BBQ made memorable through careful technique and friendly service.
9. The Chophouse Grille
The Chophouse Grille in Mahopac strikes a satisfying balance between steakhouse traditions and barbecue style. The inviting dining room and attentive service set the stage for a meal that’s both refined and hearty. Here, you notice the care that goes into every detail.
The grilled salmon is a pleasant surprise, full of smoky flavor and tender texture. I tried it with their peppered vegetables and found the combo perfect for anyone looking for a lighter, BBQ-inspired option.
The house special BBQ chicken is a signature—succulent, juicy, and generously glazed. Every order reflects the Chophouse Grille’s knack for merging steakhouse favorites with local barbecue flair. This is the place for a classic meal, upgraded by slow-cooked depth.
10. Holy Smoke
Holy Smoke sits just off Route 6n in Mahopac, and it’s the kind of place where the smoky aroma wraps around you before you see the sign. Inside, the atmosphere is unpretentious, soothing, and built for people who take their barbecue—and their time—seriously.
The smoked turkey platter is impossible to ignore. Slices are lean yet rich with smoky flavor, finished with a gentle glaze. I found myself savoring each morsel alongside their signature coleslaw, which brings a cool, creamy contrast to the heat.
The grilled veggie skewers here are a gem for BBQ lovers. Every vegetable gets a char that highlights its natural sweetness, proving Holy Smoke’s commitment to quality even in the sides. This spot keeps things honest, putting technique and ingredient first in every dish.
More Things to Try in Mohegan Lake, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best BBQ restaurant in Mohegan Lake, NY for families?
Many families enjoy Bob*B*Q’s for its laid-back vibe and reliable portions. The Patio also offers family-friendly seating and a mix of classic BBQ favorites everyone can enjoy.
Are there halal-friendly or pork-free BBQ options in Mohegan Lake, NY?
Yes, most BBQ spots here serve excellent smoked chicken, turkey, and veggie options. Diego’s Deli BBQ and Holy Smoke both offer flavorful platters that cater to those looking for pork-free choices.
Which BBQ places offer outdoor seating?
The Patio is known for its outdoor setup. Barnstormer Barbeque and Holy Smoke also feature options for enjoying your meal outside when the weather cooperates.
What are the must-try BBQ dishes in Mohegan Lake, NY?
Smoked chicken, brisket, and turkey platters are top picks at most local favorites. For something unique, try the grilled veggie skewers at Holy Smoke or cornbread at Barnstormer Barbeque.
Do any BBQ restaurants in the area provide takeout or catering?
Yes, nearly all listed BBQ spots, including Bob*B*Q’s and Diego’s Deli BBQ, offer convenient takeout. Some, like Round Up TX BBQ, also handle catering for parties and events.
