Barbecue in Arlington, NY is not a one-note affair. This is a town where the scent of slow-smoked brisket might waft through college avenues as easily as over backyard fences. I remember wandering the side streets one summer evening and following that unmistakable barbecue aroma, only to end up sharing a table and ribs with a stranger at a no-frills spot. It was the sort of meal that turns a regular Monday into something worth writing about.
Few things can spark a debate like the hunt for the best BBQ in Arlington. Pick one spot, and someone swears their pick has smokier ribs or sauce with more soul. That’s what makes the journey so enjoyable. This guide draws from experience, local buzz, and more than one saucy napkin. If you’re hungry for trusted picks and a few surprises, you’re in the right place. Arlington’s BBQ scene mixes classic comfort with a hint of local rivalry, and each spot brings something memorable to the table.
Where to find the best bbq in Arlington, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best bbq in Arlington, NY:
- Billy Bob’s BBQ
- Noah’s Ark
- Texas Roadhouse
- On My Way Home
- Dutchess BBQ Bistro & Bar
- Elia’s Barbeque Pit
- Sal’s Place
- Mulligan’s Irish House
- My Way Home Improvements Inc
- BBQ Red
1. Billy Bob’s BBQ
(845) 471-7870Call
Billy Bob’s BBQ feels like a throwback to backyard cookouts, with the bonus of polished service. On my first visit, the sound of laughter from the bar set the mood. The scent of smoked meats gave away the kitchen’s focus—low-and-slow classics made with care.
What sets Billy Bob’s apart is its balance between nostalgia and well-executed technique. The brisket arrives glistening, with the perfect smoke ring. Their signature ribs stay tender but don’t fall off the bone, which to me is a sign of a pitmaster who knows restraint.
If you’re hungry for something bold, try the pulled chicken sandwich. It’s juicy, flavorful, and not drowned in sauce. For sides, the cornbread comes out warm and crumbly, the kind you’ll remember.
2. Noah’s Ark
(845) 486-9295Call
Noah’s Ark isn’t just a barbecue joint—it’s a gathering spot. The moment you step in, you’ll notice the mix of regulars and newcomers trading stories over smoky plates. I once found myself at the bar, chatting with a local about the best side for brisket. The answer: their house-made coleslaw, no contest.
What makes Noah’s Ark memorable is the cozy, unpretentious feel paired with well-seasoned meats. The smoked turkey has a loyal following for good reason. It’s tender and smoky without being overpowered by sauce.
If you want a real taste, order the BBQ combo platter. It’s generous and lets you sample the heart of their menu. Don’t skip the baked beans—they round out the plate and carry that house-smoked flavor.
3. Texas Roadhouse
(845) 433-0338Call
Texas Roadhouse brings a lively, family-friendly vibe to the Arlington BBQ scene. Every visit starts with those warm rolls and cinnamon butter—I still remember how quickly my table disappeared. The space feels bustling but welcoming, with the sound of steak sizzling never far away.
Their kitchen knows how to handle meat. The smoked beef ribs arrive coated in a peppery crust, tender but with real substance. I’m a fan of the grilled barbecue chicken, which manages to stay juicy and flavorful, not just a vessel for sauce.
If you want a classic pairing, add a side of buttery corn or seasoned baked potato. It’s a well-rounded approach: familiar comfort, big flavors, and a dash of Texas bravado.
4. On My Way Home
(845) 849-3711Call
On My Way Home feels like your neighbor’s backyard party—if your neighbor happened to be a talented pitmaster. My first plate of barbecue here erased any doubt about the kitchen’s skills. There’s something comforting about the space: low-key, friendly, and full of regulars swapping stories over generous plates.
This spot stands out for smoked chicken that’s deeply seasoned and pulls apart easily. Each bite is smoky but never dry, which takes real know-how. I’ve also found their sides—like the collard greens—to be just as carefully prepared as the main event.
For an authentic taste, the BBQ sampler platter is the move. You get a bit of everything, from brisket to chicken, and it’s the best way to see what makes this place special.
5. Dutchess BBQ Bistro & Bar
Dutchess BBQ Bistro & Bar feels like a laid-back local secret—one of those spots you stumble into and wonder why you hadn’t heard of it sooner. My first visit started with the aroma of hardwood smoke drifting from the kitchen, hinting at the attention paid to craft here.
This place stands out for its carefully smoked brisket and house-made sauces. The brisket is fork-tender yet never soggy, with just enough bark to crave another bite. Their pulled chicken platter serves the same homey flavors in a lighter package, perfect for when you want something a little different.
Don’t skip the mac and cheese. It’s rich, creamy, and more than just a sidekick. For true BBQ fans, Dutchess hits that satisfying balance of comfort and quality every time.
6. Elia’s Barbeque Pit
(845) 691-7427Call
Elia’s Barbeque Pit is the definition of unpretentious. It’s the kind of place you stop by for lunch and find yourself lingering over an extra helping. I walked in once on a rainy afternoon, and the staff didn’t hesitate to share their favorites—which only made the food more inviting.
The real draw at Elia’s is their smoked turkey—moist, nicely seasoned, and not hidden under sauce. Every bite tastes like it was carved to order. The smoked chicken also impresses, staying juicy and packed with flavor thanks to their low-and-slow approach.
If you’re ordering on a cool day, the cornbread is a must. It’s always fresh from the oven, crumbly and warming. Elia’s serves up comfort with a personal touch every time.
7. Sal’s Place
(845) 691-2811Call
Sal’s Place feels like a true neighborhood hangout—part restaurant, part tavern, and a little piece of local history. I’ve dropped by more than once after work, drawn in by the sounds of laughter and the comfort of a game on TV. The vibe is equal parts family-friendly and classic sports bar.
The menu is a reliable mix of comfort foods, but the BBQ chicken and smoked turkey sandwich keep regulars coming back. The chicken is always just the right kind of smoky, not heavy-handed, and the turkey sandwich stays moist even late in the evening rush.
If you’re up for something shareable, their house-made coleslaw brings a nice crunch and tang to the table. Sal’s gets that BBQ should be simple, flavorful, and best enjoyed with good company.
8. Mulligan’s Irish House
(845) 486-9044Call
Mulligan’s Irish House gives Arlington a BBQ twist with an undeniable pub spirit. I first wandered in expecting classic bar fare, but the aroma of slow-cooked meats set the scene for barbecue beyond expectations. The place buzzes with friendly regulars and lively conversation over hearty plates.
What sets Mulligan’s apart is their smoked chicken. It’s a standout, balancing tender meat with just the right hint of wood smoke. Their beef brisket sandwich is generous, perfectly sliced, and sauced for flavor, not distraction.
Pair your meal with a side of crispy fries or their signature house salad if you’re after something lighter. At Mulligan’s, barbecue meets local tradition, and every meal feels like it has a story to go with it.
9. My Way Home Improvements Inc
My Way Home Improvements Inc might surprise you on a BBQ list, but locals know a good backyard isn’t just for relaxing—it’s for perfecting your barbecue game. I once chatted with a neighbor who raved about their new deck built by this team, claiming it made every family BBQ feel like an event.
What makes My Way stand out is their attention to detail and commitment to making outdoor spaces ideal for grilling and gathering. If you want your next BBQ to shine, start with their custom deck design or porch construction. Both are crafted to host everything from quiet Sunday dinners to full-blown BBQ spreads.
They might not serve ribs, but they help set the stage for unforgettable meals and good company. It’s the kind of improvement you’ll taste with every bite.
10. BBQ Red
(845) 632-3488Call
BBQ Red is one of those destinations you discover thanks to a glowing tip from a barbecue enthusiast. I ended up here after a friend swore by their slow-cooked style. The atmosphere is bright and straightforward—a focus on food, not distractions.
What sets BBQ Red apart is its smoked brisket, which manages to capture the right amount of smoke without overpowering the meat. Each order arrives juicy, sliced thick, and with just enough char to keep things interesting.
For sides, don’t skip the house-made baked beans and collard greens. They’re a nod to home-style BBQ, cooked long enough to meld flavors. If you want barbecue that’s honest, flavorful, and hearty, BBQ Red should be on your radar.
More Things to Try in Arlington, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best BBQ restaurants in Arlington, NY?
Some standout spots include Billy Bob’s BBQ, Dutchess BBQ Bistro & Bar, Noah’s Ark, and Elia’s Barbeque Pit. Each offers its own take on smoky favorites, from brisket to classic sides.
Are there any BBQ places in Arlington, NY with outdoor seating?
Yes, several BBQ spots offer outdoor seating during warmer months. Always call ahead, as table availability can depend on the weather and time of year.
What should I try at a local Arlington BBQ restaurant?
Look for smoked brisket, pulled chicken sandwiches, and house-made sides like baked beans or coleslaw. These dishes give you a real taste of each restaurant’s style and skill.
Can I find BBQ takeout or catering in Arlington, NY?
Most BBQ restaurants in Arlington, NY offer takeout, and many provide catering for events. Check restaurant websites or call ahead for menu options and availability.
Is it easy to find halal or vegetarian options at Arlington BBQ spots?
While the focus is meat, some places can accommodate vegetarian requests, offering sides like mac and cheese, salads, or roasted veggies. For halal options, it’s best to contact the restaurant directly.
