BBQ in Silverton, CO tastes like a slice of local adventure. Nestled in the shadow of rugged peaks, this tiny town brings big personality—and even bigger flavor. I still remember walking Silverton’s main street, the smoky scent of slow-cooked meats drifting on the mountain breeze. Every spot had its own secret blend of spices, and each forkful told a different story of small-town pride and time-honored tradition.
Finding the best BBQ in Silverton isn’t just about chasing a perfect brisket. It’s about discovering hidden gems where cooks have a knack for balancing tenderness and woodsmoke, and where locals nod in approval after every bite. Whether you’re a curious traveler, a BBQ enthusiast, or someone who appreciates authentic fare, this guide will lead you straight to Silverton’s tastiest tables. If you’re ready to uncover which pitmasters deserve your appetite, read on—Silverton’s BBQ scene deserves more than a passing glance.
1. Thee Pitts Again
If you stroll by Thee Pitts Again on Greene Street, it’s hard not to follow the scent inside. This spot feels like a local institution, with walls lined in memorabilia and the hum of satisfied guests trading stories over ribs. The team keeps things friendly yet efficient—my last visit started with a warm greeting and ended with a stack of napkins.
Thee Pitts Again stands out for its consistently tender, smoky meats. Their slow-cooked brisket is a favorite, melting into each bite. The pulled pork sandwiches and tangy house-made sauces are also must-tries if you want to experience their signature style.
For Silverton BBQ, the ribs claim bragging rights. They’re fall-off-the-bone good, with just the right char. Grab some for lunch, dinner, or a hearty late-night bite.
2. Natalia’s 1912 Restaurant
Natalia’s 1912 Restaurant feels like stepping into a piece of Silverton history. With its vintage charm and cozy dining room, this spot draws in visitors seeking both comfort and a hearty meal. On my last visit, a storm brewed outside while plates of hot, fragrant BBQ inside made the afternoon feel brighter.
The menu stands out thanks to its variety, offering everything from classic BBQ to global-inspired options. Families and groups flock here, knowing that there’s something for every palate. The staff make you feel right at home, adding a personal touch to every meal.
If you’re all about BBQ, try the smoked chicken or beef brisket. Both capture Natalia’s knack for juicy, slow-cooked flavor—ideal after a day in the mountains.
3. Fat Alley BBQ
(970) 728-3985Call
A bit of a drive from Silverton, Fat Alley BBQ in Telluride is worth every mile for BBQ devotees. The first time I stepped in, the aroma alone had me plotting excuses to return. This spot keeps things casual—paper towels on the tables and lively conversation all around.
What makes Fat Alley stand out is its unpretentious style and the smoky backbone running through every dish. You come hungry, and you leave with leftovers.
If you’re making the trip, the pulled chicken and beef brisket are crowd-pleasers. The brisket comes smoky and tender, trimmed just right, while the pulled chicken packs plenty of flavor. Pair either with their tangy slaw for the full Fat Alley experience.
4. Goldbelt Bar & Grill
Goldbelt Bar & Grill in nearby Ouray is a favorite stop when exploring the San Juans. The atmosphere buzzes with families, hikers, and locals all swapping stories over flavorful plates. My first visit ended with me plotting a return trip just for another taste of their BBQ.
What sets Goldbelt apart is its mix of classic comfort and creative touches. It’s the kind of place where you can grab a great burger, then spot BBQ on the next table and reconsider your whole plan. The service is quick, and the staff know their menu inside and out.
For BBQ fans, the smoked chicken and BBQ beef sandwiches offer generous portions and smoky, layered flavors. Both deliver a Colorado BBQ vibe with a relaxed, family-friendly twist.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best BBQ places in Silverton, CO?
Top picks include Thee Pitts Again and Natalia’s 1912 Restaurant. Both offer signature BBQ dishes in a laid-back, friendly atmosphere.
Is there vegetarian BBQ or sides available in Silverton?
Yes, many spots like Natalia’s 1912 Restaurant include vegetarian-friendly sides and meal options. Always check menus or ask staff for details.
Can I get takeout BBQ in Silverton?
Absolutely. Thee Pitts Again is known for easy takeout options. Call ahead during busy times to reduce your wait.
Are there gluten-free BBQ options in Silverton?
Yes, several restaurants, including Thee Pitts Again, offer gluten-free choices. Look for menu notations or speak with your server so you can order with confidence.
What BBQ dish is Silverton known for?
Ribs and brisket tend to be local favorites, with each spot offering its own twist on classic smoking and seasoning techniques.