Searching for the best BBQ in Hilliard, Ohio is a bit like looking for treasure. Every spot claims to have the best secret recipe, but only a few deliver that unforgettable blend of smoky flavor, tender meat, and sides that don’t play second fiddle. You want something with character, where the aroma seeps into your clothes and you don’t mind the sauce on your fingers. As someone who’s methodically sampled meat-packed menus from Main Street to the edges of town, I can say Hilliard hides a few gems worth every napkin.
What follows isn’t a random roundup. It’s built on more taste tests than I care to admit, careful note-taking (not just the brisket, but the vibe), and conversations with pitmasters who know their craft. If you’ve ever had to choose between a perfect rack of ribs or a smoked chicken sandwich, you’ll feel right at home. So, if you want not only to find a good BBQ joint but to know what sets each apart, keep reading. Hilliard’s BBQ scene is richer than you might think.
1. Legacy Smokehouse
Tucked into the heart of Old Hilliard, Legacy Smokehouse is a nod to classic southern BBQ with a local twist. The atmosphere leans rustic and relaxed, perfect for settling in with a hearty plate. My visit left me quietly impressed—smoke lingers in the air, and the staff treat regulars and newcomers with equal warmth.
What sets Legacy apart is its commitment to honest flavors. Brisket is the star here, cut thick with just the right amount of bark and silky fat. The pulled chicken holds its own, tender and thoroughly kissed by smoke. Pair with their seasoned fries or classic slaw for the full effect.
With each bite, you taste both patience and skill, making Legacy the spot for authentic BBQ in Hilliard.
2. Dickey’s Barbecue Pit
+1 614-777-4020
See Menu
Dickey’s Barbecue Pit brings a taste of Texas right to Hilliard. The aroma hits you first—the promise of meats smoked low and slow each night. My order was ready faster than expected, but the flavors made it clear: good things have been happening in those smokers for hours.
What gives Dickey’s its edge is consistency. The smoked turkey is juicy and rich, maximizing both flavor and moisture. Beef brisket is classic, with a smoky outer crust and soft center that speaks volumes. Their sides tell a story too; the creamed spinach and potato casserole are comfort in a cup.
For a quick lunch or easy family dinner, Dickey’s serves up reliable BBQ that feels home-cooked and straightforward.
3. Texas Roadhouse
Texas Roadhouse brings a bit of rustic charm to Hilliard’s BBQ scene. When you walk in, the energy is unmistakable—servers line dance, laughter bounces off the walls, and the kitchen buzzes with activity. My meal here began with a basket of their famous rolls, still warm, and each bite set the tone for what’s next.
The menu keeps things classic but doesn’t hold back on flavor. Fall-off-the-bone ribs shine with their rich, smoky taste and signature seasoning. The grilled chicken brings a savory, fire-kissed bite to the table. Pair your protein with their mashed potatoes or green beans for a true comfort-food experience.
Every visit feels both familiar and special, blending flavor with genuine hospitality in every meal.
4. Dickey’s Barbeque Pit
Dickey’s Barbeque Pit on Britton Parkway feels like a familiar BBQ haven, whether you’ve come for a speedy takeout meal or a sit-down feast. The atmosphere is simple, letting the food command the spotlight. On my visit, I was struck by how rich the air smelled, a sure sign those smokers work overtime.
Dickey’s is known for offering a full lineup of smoked classics. The beef brisket is a standout—tender, smoky, sliced to show off its well-earned bark. If you’re in the mood for variety, the Polish-style kielbasa brings a sharper, peppery profile that works with Southern-inspired sides.
Each plate underscores why Dickey’s remains a local go-to: reliable, satisfying barbecue every time.
5. Outback Steakhouse
Outback Steakhouse carves its spot in Hilliard with a menu that goes beyond steakhouse staples. The space manages to be both lively and relaxing—a place where you can hear the sizzle from the kitchen while you kick back and enjoy the laid-back mood. On my last visit, it almost felt like a mini escape from the daily grind.
While their steaks are the claim to fame, the wood-fire grilled chicken deserves your attention. It’s moist, with a slightly smoky flavor that pairs perfectly with their tangy BBQ sauce. The Aussie fries and seasoned green beans round out the plate for comfort that feels a bit elevated.
Outback’s BBQ offerings stand out by striking a balance: hardy flavors, generous portions, and an atmosphere that feels festive yet familiar.
6. Sports On Tap S Portsbar
(614) 921-9437Call
Sports On Tap S Portsbar blends the charm of a neighborhood tavern with the comfort of BBQ classics. It’s the kind of spot that feels welcoming right away, with flat screens lighting up every angle and regulars chatting at the bar. My last game night here showed just how much locals love this place—cheers, good food, and never a dull moment.
BBQ at Sports On Tap keeps things fun and familiar. The smoked wings are a highlight, crisp around the edges and packed with flavor. The pulled chicken sandwich is another reliable option—simple, juicy, and generously portioned.
If you want a low-key vibe with hearty BBQ and sports on every screen, this Hilliard mainstay scores every time.
7. Roadhouse Wings & Grill
Roadhouse Wings & Grill makes BBQ simple, lively, and built for good times. Whether I’ve visited for a quick lunch or a game night, there’s always a friendly buzz in the air—and you can tell regulars feel right at home. This spot manages to mingle local pub vibes with a steady stream of bold BBQ flavors.
The smoked wings here are the main attraction, thanks to their deeply seasoned crispiness and just the right amount of smoke. I’d also recommend the grilled chicken platter, which is never dry and always filling, especially with their seasoned fries on the side.
For BBQ in Hilliard that’s unfussy, satisfying, and easy to enjoy, Roadhouse Wings & Grill checks all the boxes.
8. Tim Burkitt Service & Repair Co
(614) 777-9745Call
Tim Burkitt Service & Repair Co isn’t your typical BBQ stop. Instead of brisket or ribs, you’ll find the workhorses behind every great cookout—equipment that keeps Hilliard’s BBQ scene sizzling. I dropped by when my old smoker threw in the towel, and found service here refreshingly straightforward. Tim and his team jump right into diagnostics, treating every grill and smoker like prized possessions.
They specialize in barbecue equipment repair and supplies, making them the hidden backbone of many backyard feasts. Need a replacement part for your grill? Or a fix before your next gathering? This is where the locals go to get things sorted fast.
When maintaining your own BBQ setup matters as much as the meal, Tim Burkitt’s name quickly becomes a favorite.
9. City Barbeque
City Barbeque is the place you visit when you want BBQ that’s both dependable and deeply satisfying. The vibe is fast-casual but never skimps on the details that matter—a line of smokers working overtime, generous portions, and friendly faces behind the counter. My first plate here was a masterclass in comfort food, every bite tender and smoky in all the right ways.
The menu covers all the bases, but the beef brisket and St. Louis–cut ribs deserve special mention. They’re slow-smoked, carved thick, and full of flavor, making them local favorites for both dine-in and takeout. Their seasoned green beans and creamy slaw stack up as must-have sides.
If you want Hilliard BBQ that always delivers on flavor and friendliness, City Barbeque is an easy pick.
10. Texas Steele BBQ
Texas Steele BBQ brings authentic Lone Star tradition to the Hilliard area from its spot in Dublin. Walking in, you’re greeted by a smoky aroma that means business—no shortcuts, just serious pit work. My visit felt like a trip south, with friendly staff guiding newcomers toward house favorites.
The smoked brisket is where Texas Steele shines: moist, melt-in-your-mouth, and resting under a perfect bark. The turkey breast is another standout—delicate, juicy, and ideal if you’re in the mood for something a bit lighter. Add a side of their seasoned green beans or potato salad for the full experience.
If you’re after BBQ in Hilliard that captures true Texas spirit, Texas Steele BBQ is worth seeking out.
Frequently Asked Questions
What BBQ restaurants are most popular in Hilliard, OH?
Some local favorites include Legacy Smokehouse, Dickey’s Barbecue Pit, City Barbeque, and Roadhouse Wings & Grill. Each offers a unique spin on BBQ, from Texas-style brisket to smoky wings.
Are there halal BBQ options in Hilliard?
Most traditional BBQ spots in Hilliard don’t advertise halal menus. It’s best to call ahead and ask about their meat sourcing and preparation if halal is a priority.
What should I try for my first visit to a Hilliard BBQ spot?
You can’t go wrong with brisket or pulled chicken at most local joints. Add classic sides like coleslaw or green beans to round out your meal.
Is there BBQ catering available in Hilliard?
Yes, many places such as City Barbeque and Dickey’s Barbecue Pit offer catering for events, ranging from small gatherings to large parties.
Which BBQ places are good for families?
Texas Roadhouse and Outback Steakhouse both offer relaxed, family-friendly dining environments along with robust BBQ menus.
Do I need a reservation for BBQ restaurants in Hilliard?
Reservations are usually not required for casual BBQ restaurants. However, for larger groups or during busy times, it’s wise to call ahead.
Are there vegetarian options at BBQ restaurants in Hilliard?
Options can be limited but you’ll often find salads, seasoned fries, and a variety of non-meat sides. Always ask the staff for current vegetarian choices.
Are there BBQ takeout or delivery options in Hilliard?
Yes, most BBQ spots offer takeout, and several also provide online ordering and delivery services for convenience.