Barbecue in Tylertown, Mississippi isn’t a passing fad. It’s a full-blown tradition, and locals take their smoked meats as seriously as their sweet tea. Whether you’re after the kind of ribs that make a mess of your hands or pulled chicken that practically falls apart, this small town knows how to get it right. I still remember my first plate, eating under a faded sign while blues drifted from a back porch. The smoky-sweet aroma lingers in my memory as much as the taste itself.
Finding the best BBQ in Tylertown can feel like being let in on a secret. You want the hidden gems, the real-deal spots where folks order “the usual,” and everyone behind the counter remembers your face. This guide doesn’t just rattle off names; it dives into what makes each spot worth your stop. From time-honored recipes to that perfect tang on the sauce, you’re about to discover where the locals really eat.
1. Mcelveen’s Fish & Barbeque
Mcelveen’s Fish & Barbeque isn’t hiding from anyone. You can spot its unmistakable red sign just off Old Highway 24, and it’s only a short drive to an afternoon well spent. The place buzzes with regulars swapping stories and savoring the kind of smoky barbecue you don’t find just anywhere.
Their BBQ plates reflect both tradition and pride. The pork ribs come tender, smoky, and with just enough char at the edges to satisfy any craving. If you’re in a sharing mood, the BBQ chicken is a classic—moist, gently smoky, with a sauce that’s tangy but not overpowering.
You can’t talk about Mcelveen’s without mentioning the sides. The baked beans and potato salad seal the deal. For a full Tylertown experience, stick with their ribs and pair them with a classic side.
2. Grant’s Grille
(601) 736-0500Call
Grant’s Grille isn’t in Tylertown proper, but locals will tell you it’s worth the short drive down Highway 35. The dining room feels like a friendly gathering spot, with staff often calling out greetings to familiar faces. Once, I grabbed a seat by the window and let the smoky aroma do all the talking before the first bite.
The pulled pork here deserves its reputation. It’s tender, well-seasoned, and piled high without drowning in sauce. The BBQ brisket is another standout, sliced thick and edged with just enough bark to add real depth of flavor.
For a true taste of the area, order the pulled pork sandwich with a side of coleslaw. The smoky-sweet balance perfectly showcases what Grant’s Grille does best.
3. Double E BBQ
(601) 869-5005Call
Double E BBQ sits a little off the beaten path, but those who find it tend to return. This family operation in McComb has a knack for making guests feel right at home, and each visit feels more like Sunday supper than a restaurant stop. The first thing you’ll notice is the scent drifting from the smoker out back.
The brisket is the signature here. It’s slow-cooked the right way—smoky, juicy, and never dry. I once shared a plate with friends, and we argued over who would take the last slice. The ribs are also worth your attention, with just the right tug and a peppery edge.
If you want classic Mississippi barbecue, start with the brisket plate and add the homemade potato salad. It’s comfort food, plain and simple.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best BBQ near Tylertown, MS?
You’ll find top spots like Mcelveen’s Fish & Barbeque in Tylertown, along with local favorites nearby such as Grant’s Grille and Double E BBQ. Each brings something unique to the table, from fall-off-the-bone ribs to classic pulled pork.
What BBQ dishes does Tylertown do best?
Ribs, pulled pork, and BBQ chicken are the local standouts. These dishes are slow-smoked and paired with tangy sauces or classic sides like potato salad and baked beans.
Is Tylertown BBQ more sweet, spicy, or smoky?
It varies by spot, but in general, you’ll find a smoky base with just the right balance of sweet and tangy in the sauce. Some places add more pepper or spice, but nothing overpowers the flavor of the meat itself.
Do these BBQ restaurants cater or offer takeout?
Yes, most local BBQ places offer takeout and some even handle catering for group events. Calling ahead is a good idea, especially on weekends.
Are there vegetarian options at BBQ places around Tylertown?
Options may be limited, but most spots serve sides like baked beans, potato salad, or coleslaw. Always best to call and ask if you’re looking for something specific.
